Top Restaurants in North Lima
Top Things to do in North Lima
- 1. Vintage VanBlair Antiques and Oddities
- 2. Mill Creek Park
- 3. Fellows Riverside Gardens
- 4. SNPJ Slovenian Heritage Center
- 5. Dimension Paintball LLC
- 6. Mr. Darby's Antique & Collectible Emporium
- 7. White House Fruit Farm Inc.
- 8. Vintage Estate Wine & Beer
- 9. Birdfish Brewing Co.
- 10. Slammin' Sams' Stagecoach
Countries
Youngstown, Ohio Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in North Lima
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in North Lima, Youngstown, Ohio including Amore Cafe & Italian Kitchen, Boardman Belleria, Aqua Pazzo, Carmellas Italian Eatery, Caffe' Capri Italian Bar & Grille, Cafe 422, Nicolinni’s, Fireplace, Michael Alberini's, Johnny's Restaurant
Things to do in North Lima
10. Johnny's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 84 reviews
Reviewed By Mary C
We were part of a graduation celebration with a small family gathering. We were each able to order from the menu despite 20 people. I find that so accommodating. Both my husband and I were very pleased with our food. I had a simple fish dish and my husband ordered the salmon. Very good on both parts. And those around us were enjoying filet tips, chicken marsala, and a shrimp pasta dish, as well as a dish I think was called Chicken Victoria; smothered in a delicious sauce. No one was disappointed. And the service for 20 of us was very nice. Great place; I have never been disappointed here.
9. Michael Alberini's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 134 reviews
Reviewed By YankeeBell
Came here for our anniversary. Beautiful atmosphere. Lamp lollipops were excellent, however, we were disappointed in our main course. I ordered the baseball sirloin. The meat was tough and dry. My green beans had no flavor whatsoever, neither did my steak. My husband had the cherry medallions. Although they were tender, his lacked flavor as well. Mashed potatoes and the cherry sauce was great. But would have liked to have at least 3 medallions for what we paid for the entree. Would have loved my steak to be as well seasoned as the lamp lollipops. For what we paid for our dinner, it did not meet my expectations. The service, however, was excellent!
8. Fireplace
Overall Ratings
4 based on 39 reviews
Reviewed By DWathenYoungstown_OH
Here for a dinner meeting. Nice menu with lots of daily specials. I had Lasagna and wedding soup. Both excellent. Good portions of everything. The group had just about everything on the menu and no complaints. Good service with nice cozy atmosphere.
7. Nicolinniâs
Overall Ratings
4 based on 226 reviews
Reviewed By Allen M
Visited for the first time with another couple on a busy Saturday night. We all absolutely loved our dinners and we didn't even order Italian. Two of us had the stuffed chicken with mashed potatoes and a sherry with Portobello mushrooms gravy accompanied by asparagus. It was superb. The other two had the Salmon and were equally pleased. I look forward to returning again soon and we are a couple that eat out quite often.
6. Cafe 422
Overall Ratings
4 based on 101 reviews
Reviewed By dichuck
On Dec 23 we were a group of 30 people using a private room and a catering menu. The process from planning stage till our evening was finished could not have gone more smoothly. We had friendly assistance from all we had contact with. Our servers Jordan and Chris were extremely friendly and helpful, they could not have done more. Everyone enjoyed their food and the atmosphere. We recommend if you need a place for an enjoyable experience.
Most Popular Southwestern food in North Lima, Youngstown, Ohio
5. Caffe' Capri Italian Bar & Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 136 reviews
Reviewed By QuakerCowboy
We were at Caffe Capri on a Saturday night. The place is a very comfortable, family owned Italian food restaurant. We have been coming here for years and truly enjoy the dishes using their proprietary red sauce. They have an extensive menu and we enjoy the pasta, braciole, Italian Eggrolls and Bruschetta. They offer a good cocktail selection and a good wine menu (as you would expect in an Italian restaurant). The hostess is always very pleasant and we were served by Allison. She is friendly, efficient and offers suggestions without being too aggressive. The bar side has TV sets if you want to catch Saturday night college football games or the restaurant side is also very pleasant with good seating.
4. Carmellas Italian Eatery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 38 reviews
Reviewed By latidaboutique
I work near Carmella's and I think the food has come a long way. Sauce is great, atmosphere is cozy and charming, and the stuffed eggplant parm is delicious! Even my pick mother likes it! Plus the house cab is a very nice glass of red wine.
Youngstown, Ohio Food Guide: 3 Seafood food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in North Lima
3. Aqua Pazzo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By 772paml
Our first visit was very pleasant. The food was very good. We started with the caprese. Never had the mozzarella warm before.....excellent!! The rigatoni with fennel sausage and broccolini was very good. The warm butter cake with ice cream and sliced strawberries was fantastic !! Tuesday is $10 pasta. Our waitress, Lisa, was great.
2. Boardman Belleria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 37 reviews
Reviewed By SMartinchalk
Fantastic meatballs! All of the food my group of five ordered was delicious! The servings were generous. (We all took home extras.)
Where to eat American food in North Lima: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Amore Cafe & Italian Kitchen
Family friendly atmosphere and service, cafe seating, dining, as well as full bar. Our diverse menu features rustic Italian food, New York style pizza available from lunch through dinner. Cafe style items as well as traditional breakfast items served from
Reviewed By David T
Our first visiit. As a gift, I brought my mother-in-law, sister-in-law, wife, & myself for dinner today at 5:30. The place was empty; we were the only table; and we started with wedding soup. It was served in a tin coffee cup, was thin (watered down?), and cold. No, not really cold, but room temperature, far from hot. Next our entrees. Awful. My steak w/crab cake and a white sauce over broccoli was served minus the crab cake, the cheap steak was cold & tough, the broccoli, watery as if just thawed from the freezer; was cold, and there was no crab cake as described on the menu. The white sauce on the steak was disgusting; tasteless & pasty like a mix of flour & water. After requesting and finally receiving the crab cake it was so fishy it should've been used for bait. Nasty. My wife's stuffed eggplant was probably good three days ago when it was made but now tasted like the refrigerator. ...and it was cold too. My two in-laws had chicken parm and wouldn't say anything good or bad but didn't eat their meals, didn't bring them home, and my sister-in-law was served a side of cavetelli when she'd ordered spaghetti. She doesn't like or eat cavatelli. Out of four diners; two received incorrect meals; and all four were cold. We left with the table full of uneaten food. The waitress did not know what a marinara sauce was, a carbonera sauce was, and this is supposed to be an Italian restaurant. We paid our $110 bill ($85 + tip to the hopeless waitress) and will never return. This place has a long way to go before being recommended.
Where to eat Pizza food in North Lima: The Best Restaurants and Bars
