Location: Lake Mills
Top Restaurants in Lake Mills
Countries
Wisconsin, United States Food Guide: 5 American food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Lake Mills
Reviews on American food in Lake Mills, Wisconsin, United States. Lake Mills is a city in Jefferson County, Wisconsin, United States. The population was 5,708 at the 2010 census. The city is located partially within the Town of Lake Mills.
Things to do in Lake Mills
1. The Grist Bar & Table
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By PrairiePaddler
I'm so happy to have discovered this bar and café just off the Interstate in charming Lake Mills. The long stretch between Madison and Milwaukee is a food desert but this oasis is literally just minutes from the highway. I met friends here for lunch and everyone gave the food an enthusiastic thumbs-up. My grilled chicken sandwich with tomato and olive tapenade was really outstanding -- the bread was delicious and fries made to perfection. Service is friendly and the space is charming, welcoming and modern. Parking is easy on the town common. I make this drive across the state often and will definitely make this a regular stop along the way. Oh, and don't pass up the short half-block walk to Ephraim Pottery, a destination in its own right.
Lake Mills Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Lake Mills
2. Hering's Sand Bar and Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
Reviewed By patricialR6115QE
Went for a fish fry. Nice location and view. Coleslaw was very good. Boyfriend said potato pancakes were very good. Fish was black around edges and very greasy. Fries were greasy and crunchy even on the inside. They remade the fries with only minimal improvement -- still hard. Never offered to remake fish or bring me something else. Boyfriend ate most of his fish only because he was very hungry. Left my plate pretty much untouched. Ended up having to get something elsewhere. Even the soda tasted watered down and flat.
What to do and see in Lake Mills, United States: The Best Places and Tips
3. Aztalan Inn Bar & Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 29 reviews
Reviewed By Tucker1575
We visited here on Tuesday night. They have a surf and turf special on Tuesdays, your choice of beef fillet, ribs, rib eye and shrimp or scallops for $20.They also have prime rib on special several nights during the week. Drinks are well made and prices are good. Prime rib was good as was the rib eye and tenderloin fillets.There is a very extensive chicken wing menu and I understand you can even get them boneless. We had the deep fried pickles and they were very good, as were the deep fried mushrooms. It is not a fancy place but service was good, prices were right and our tummy's were full afterward. Too full to even consider one of the dessert drinks they offer. Oh well. Next time.
4. The Cafe on the Park
Overall Ratings
4 based on 36 reviews
Reviewed By Mamiya7
When traveling between Milwaukee and Madison WI, I try to stop here for breakfast. Two persons can get a hearty breakfast of pancakes, eggs, hash browns, toast, and decent coffee for around $20 plus tip. It has a a true small-town feel with many historic properties. The people are exceptionally nice and very forgiving if you do something awkward like spill your glass of water.
5. Lake Mills Family Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 15 reviews
Reviewed By Jrmmb
Great food very reasonably priced in this hidden gem. We ended up biking here and having great breakfasts with excellent food, service and very reasonable. Need to come back and check out dinner specials. Will do very well if even close to breakfast offerings!
