Location: Oyster Bay
Top Restaurants in Oyster Bay
Top Things to do in Oyster Bay
- 1. Old Westbury Gardens
- 2. Sagamore Hill National Historic Site
- 3. John P. Humes Japanese Stroll Garden
- 4. Cold Spring Harbor Fish Hatchery & Aquarium
- 5. Shu Swamp Preserve - Charles T Church Nature Preserve
- 6. NYCB Theatre at Westbury
- 7. Bayville Adventure Park
- 8. Caumsett State Park
- 9. Planting Fields Arboretum State Historic Park
- 10. The Paramount
Countries
Where to eat Steakhouse food in Oyster Bay: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Steakhouse food in Oyster Bay, New York, United States. The Town of Oyster Bay is the easternmost of the three towns which make up Nassau County, New York, in the United States. Part of the New York metropolitan area, it is the only town in Nassau County to extend from the North Shore to the South Shore of Long Island. As of the 2010 census, it had a population of 293,214.
Things to do in Oyster Bay
1. Mill Creek Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 183 reviews
Long Island's most popular neighborhood restaurants, Mill Creek Tavern serves seasonal robustly flavored, American cuisine in a relaxed setting of casual elegance. We offer a full dinner menu with daily specials in the dining room and the bar. Behind the
Reviewed By daspork
Mill Creek's one of our go-to places around the North Shore. The food is always great, staff is friendly and the place is cozy and well decorated. Bayville's a cute town and there's no way to get to MCT that doesn't involve a nice scenic drive along either Oyster Bay or the LI Sound. They have a menu with plenty of options from land-based to seafood, very good specials and nights with themes (Bavarian is really good). Good selection of drinks and beers on tap including local options round out the options. Well worth the trip!Thank you so much for that awesome detailed review. We greatly appreciate it and we appreciate you!! With Gratitude - Rich
Most Popular Diner food in Oyster Bay, New York, United States
2. Rothmann's Steakhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 174 reviews
Reviewed By JVernel
Both of us opted for the three course special. Tasty spicy tuna rolls were sized to pop in the mouth. Filet mignon was perfectly prepared. Creamed spinach and broccoli sides recommended. Finished with creme brûlée and cheesecake. Place was full on Wednesday evening in August. Wait service professional. Valet parking. Definitely would consider returning for dinner again.
3. Rare 650
Overall Ratings
4 based on 262 reviews
Reviewed By sklyce
For a romantic Valentine dinner, friends acquainted us with Rare 650, which we had been to in the past for a group business dinner. Since it was the busiest night in the year, I wasn't;t expecting too much, but we were greeted with a wait at the bar (where there no seats), and seated not too beyond the reservation time at a table wonderfully out back and away from the noise. Wait staff were amazing, and Dina suggested a special sushi appetizer which was just beyond the beyond, with a lovely presentation. At the bar we saw an incredible porterhouse for 2 being served, but one of the specials was a bone in filet. We both ordered one, but when they arrived they were over-cooked and tough! Come on! Filet mignon may not be the most flavorful, but tender it should be! Not only were they tough, but the presentation? A black grizzled, rough-shaped mass. Yuck! We did send them back and asked the manager to send us the steak on the menu he would order for himself--sirloin. So they arrived and cooked to order (medium rare), but over-carbonized on the outside. We did eat them, but they certainly were not the prime aged quality advertised or expected. In any case, we did have a nice night out, but suggest to Rare 650 they change their beef supplier before they loose their repeat customers. Oh, and the smokers were placed immediately outside the front door in an enclosed area through which one exited the restaurant--not pleasant for some.
4. Sur Argentinian Steakhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 110 reviews
Reviewed By Sarah L
Six of us shared the mixed grill (described as serving 2) plus a ribeye, with two sides of mashed potatoes and one mixed vegetables. We had modest appetizers (three empanadas and one stuffed provolone dish), which we actually didn't need. The bill, including two beers and a bottle of Malbec (delightful recommendation by our waiter) came to only $172 and we were stuffed. The meat was cooked to perfection at the degree we requested (medium rare). I will say that for half of our time there (Sunday evening), it was quite loud and we did feel as if we had to shout to be heard. Once the room emptied a bit, noise was not an issue. Will not hesitate to go back.
5. Upstairs at the Woodlands
Overall Ratings
4 based on 9 reviews
Reviewed By JesusDad
Hidden next to Fox Hollow in the Town of Oyster Bay Golf Course, the The Woodlands Restaurant at Woodbury offers a great place to dine, grab a quick bite or hold a family function. Check out their website or stop by for a visit. If you have never been their, you will be amazed.
Where to eat Seafood food in Oyster Bay: The Best Restaurants and Bars
