Location: Shelter Island
Top Restaurants in Shelter Island
Countries
Where to eat Pub food in Shelter Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Reviews on Pub food in Shelter Island, New York, United States. Shelter Island is a town and island at the eastern end of Long Island in the U.S. state of New York. It is part of Suffolk County, although it is separated from the rest of the county by water. The population was 2,392 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Shelter Island
10. Dory
Overall Ratings
2 based on 121 reviews
Reviewed By jake120
This restaurant enjoys a great setting but continues to disappoint due to a very unpleasant owner who seems to delight in being a jerk and putting off everyone on Shelter Island. Food mediocre, service mediocre, not at all worth a visit. Go to Marie Eiffel Market across the street or to Salt. Food better and they know how to smile and show caring for their customers.
9. The Half Note
Reviewed By ronacom13
This is special! A jazz trio plays in the background. Bar service is terrific. Food is absolutely top-notch. Great place for a date night out. Expensive, but really worth it; the food quality is amazing and well-prepared, allowing ingredients to shine. The music is a gift.
8. Whiskey Wind Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 25 reviews
Reviewed By Trashcar
Stopped there on a Sunday afternoon for a beer and dinner. There were six of us. We found ourselves to a table in a mostly empty restaurant. We sat there...and sat there...and sat there. We're not demanding, but how about eye contact or a head nod??? Something!!! We pulled up stakes and headed out...To the Townsend Manor Inn...Great food and a better staff...
7. Founders Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 98 reviews
Reviewed By travelgal617
Enjoyed lunch here twice during our stay on the North Fork. Burgers were great as were the salads - everyone was pleased! Got to enjoy local wines and some local beer on tap. Service was friendly and efficient. Sandwiches are big and the fries and onion rings were good. Enjoyable lunch!
Where to eat Mexican food in Shelter Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
6. Industry Standard
Overall Ratings
4 based on 50 reviews
Reviewed By Brenda D
Although I was able to have a vegetarian meal (falafel), this was the only option. I was more impressed or I should say NOT with how the owner treated his wait staff. He was rude and obnoxious and if my kids worked there I would have made them quit on the spot. Our waitress was absolutely wonderful and I felt terrible for her. Hence we will not be going back. The food was nothing but ordinary and the drinks were weak. Seems like this business owner is only interested in seeing how he can take advantage of the local tourism.
Best American food near Shelter Island, New York, United States
5. Crabby Jerry's
Overall Ratings
3 based on 107 reviews
Self-serve, family-friendly, waterfront dining. Specializing in lobster in the rough and other fresh seafood.
Reviewed By JerseyDevil
Stopped here for the first time because Claudioâs was closed for renovations. Basically the same menu and lobster rolls. Connecticut style lobster roll is butter with no mayo or celery. Claudioâs style has mayo and celery. Very good lobster rolls.
4. Corner Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 150 reviews
Reviewed By KNICKRD
Stopped in for a quick bite. Good size Drink, for a reasonable price.$9-$11.Had the Reuben, and Spinach Salad, both substantial and good. The Corn Fritters, were pretty good, with dipping sauce in a To Go portion cup, found that odd for an in house plating.
3. Deep Water Bar and Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 80 reviews
A gathering place for friends and family old and new. New American menu with a focus on fresh local seafood!
Reviewed By dennis1027
Stopped in for an outdoor lunch on Sunday afternoon. Great selection of food and drinks. Food was served promptly as well.
Most Popular Pizza food in Shelter Island, New York, United States
2. Brix & Rye
Overall Ratings
5 based on 30 reviews
Reviewed By Vanessa L
LOVE the pizza, salads, meatballs and cocktails here! Great place to have dinner with friends or a casual date. It can get loud later on weekend nights so I recommend going earlier in the evening to get seated. This is definitely adults only and I've seen people drink too much and be very loud.
Top 10 Italian food in Shelter Island, New York, United States
1. The Flying Goat Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By Hawk470
The Flying Goat wonât set the world on fire. Its food wonât banish the memory of super meals past. Nonetheless, the combination of the view, the drinks, the friendly, if not always efficient, service, and the capably prepared food offers you a most pleasant and, for Shelter Island, reasonably priced meal.Good hamburger and fries. Very good pappardelle with garlic shrimp and broccoli (all al dente). Flavorful and not overcooked sautéed spinach on the side. Delicious local Greenport IPA. And the magnificent view across the golf course to the South Fork in the distance.Whatâs not to like?
Most Popular Seafood food in Shelter Island, New York, United States
