Location: Webster
Top Restaurants in Webster
Countries
Where to eat Pizza food in Webster: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Best Pizza restaurants nearby. Discover the best Pizza food in Webster. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Pizza restaurants near you.. Ronald W. Nesbitt (R; 2006-present)
Things to do in Webster
10. Pontillo's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By Barbara E
Pontillos has been around for a long time, and we have ordered delivery from them in the past. It has been a few years, and we tried them again. Wow! It cost $38.00 for a four-topping large pizza and 12 wings with one extra bleu cheese. The pizza arrived in a timely manner. The toppings were good, but the crust was under baked. The wings could have fried a little longer too. Service was friendly. I would have preferred them to come late with the food done. I will not be ordering from them again any time soon.
9. Salvatore's Pizza & Specs
Overall Ratings
3 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By JrMushroom
After getting take-out pizza here several times, I brought my family to the actual restaurant for pizza and wings. I had always thought of their pizza as merely adequate, but I was very pleasantly surprised. The pizza was excellent! We enjoyed all of the food, and the experience, immensely.
8. Mark's Pizzeria
Reviewed By Travelpapi153
You are treated like a valued customer, the pizza is always made the way you ordered and the service by far is the best in the business. For only the price of a pizza, the staff treats you like you are spending big money at a 5 star restaurant. My pick up is always hot, perfect and sold with a smile. Thanks, the little things go a long way and keep me coming back for sure. Whomever trains the staff does an excellent job with customer service prep.
7. The Lake Road Country Store
We are a local convenience store and Gas Station and dine in establishment. Casual family dining with home made menu items. Subs made on homemade ciabatta bread, Pizza featuring homemade dough, Grill Menu featuring fresh ground and steak, Panini's, Salads
Reviewed By TBBXRR
The Frank Brothers of Webster, NY own 3 establishments from the village of Webster intersection with Rt104 (Hanks), just across the street (AM/PM Minimart), and the flagship Country Store on Lake Road at the end of Rt 250. While Hanks is Ice Cream and grill items, the Country Store has a full range menu and seating under a rustic fishing interior on the ceiling!Pizza is always available and they have an extensive menu. Famous for their Friday Fish Fry that is always done in fresh oil for burp-less digestion, and their subs made to perfection for sub-lovers who often travel from the West Coast (Yes, California!) for this taste treat, the food is why people come in. You can order from the on-line menu and have your dinner delivered. I just like to drive up in my car (on bad weather days) or on my bicycle. It's only 1/2 a mile away!
6. Empire Pizza
We are Webster's only true Pizzeria. Clean, friendly, family Pizzeria. Plenty of free parking and quality NY style pies.
Reviewed By Kim M
it is still thin-crust pizza and I used to love it, but something has gone seriously wrong the last two times I went here and have given up on the place. Sauce was not good, but I am not sure that was the real issue with the pizza.
5. La Bella Vita
Overall Ratings
3 based on 61 reviews
Reviewed By Aimee G
This was my first time going to La Bella Vita for dinner, I'd been there for lunch. It has a really nice bistro feel to it. The Salmon Grigliato was just spectacular. Grilled Faroe Islands Salmon that they get in fresh daily over sauteed greens and lentils. The salmon was crispy, sweet, and perfectly charred and cooked. We had no room for dessert. We decided to eat at the bar and just enjoy the busy Friday night atmosphere. We recommend getting reservations. There were several large parties there as well as many smaller ones. Prices are mid range to a little on the pricey side depending on what you get. They have wood fired pizzas, salads and paninis as well as pricier entrees. Highly recommend!
Where to eat Cafe food in Webster: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Wegmans Market Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
Reviewed By Reen0007
I wasn't happy at all with Wegman's this morning. I prefer this location because they have better selections at the marketplace than the others. I bypassed 3 Wegman's to get here and with surprise they didn't have the salad bar ready or anything else. I will not come back to this location again. I looked at the store hours to clarify the time and it had 8:30am to 9:00pm for the marketplace. I always come here to pick up my healthy lunch. I'm not happy and left with nothing. On my way to Pittsford. That's the largest one anyway. I didn't want to take that long drive, but I want to be satisfied and stay healthy.
3. Rhino's Pizzeria & Deli
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
We have a huge selection of specialty subs including the garbage sub and the Donovan. We also offer specialty pizzas, like buffalo chicken wing pizza, chicken fajita pizza and a steak and cheese pizza! We have Buffalo chicken wings and other flavors like
Reviewed By tlizzie
After a day of sightseeing we were interested in eating in the room and relaxing. This is a great place for pizza or sub take-out. Also ordered a side salad. (The wine will have to come from the liquor store on Hard Rd.) Consider this an option if you want to eat in.
2. UNO Chicago Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 100 reviews
Reviewed By Steve C
Yes - UNO's has lots of choices and hardly treats as if they are a franchise....but they should be an early choice for pizza. They truly have more creative, better variety and higher quality pizza then most places. The others often do minimum pizza types and cut quality in order to have any price margin/profit...UNO's doesn't rely on Pizza only. We had both their deep dish and their thin versions and both were excellent. Plenty of toppings and the dough was tasty and perfectly cooked. Toppings went all the way to the edges and were plentiful. Only warning....there are good size. We will easily get 3 or more meals out of the pizza's. One was heavy on the pepperoni, another was heavily meat filled and one was a vegetable pizza,,,,colorful and rich with veggies.Special mention to our server, Morgan. She was industrious - helpful and had a knack for balancing her great smile and friendly demeanor without at all being fake or having to work hard at it. She made us all feel welcomed and comfortable as if she sincerely loved what she did...and it showed.
Most Popular American food in Webster, New York, United States
1. Pub 235
Overall Ratings
4 based on 126 reviews
We offer a full lunch and dinner menu including specialty pizzas, sandwiches made with meats that we roast in house, salads, burgers, entrees and more. We have a full bar with traditional offerings, in addition to showcasing local favorites.
Reviewed By 15lesliej
Stopped at Pub 235 for lunch with colleagues- what a nice surprise, haven't been there for years since it was Hank's. They have retained the classic Beef on Weck on the menu if you are missing the past. The waitress was enthusiastic and knowledgable. The daily vegetable was snap peas which was a nice change from the usual side. Great salads and sandwiches, I had the Chicken French sandwich which came with a very generous amount of French sauce for dipping. Outdoor seating was enjoyable as well.
