Location: Saugerties
Top Restaurants in Saugerties
Countries
Where to eat Pizza food in Saugerties: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pizza food in Saugerties, New York, United States. Saugerties (/ˈsɔːɡərtiːz/) is a town in Ulster County, New York, United States. The population was 19,482 at the 2010 census. The Town of Saugerties contains the Village of Saugerties in the northeast corner of Ulster County. Part of the town is inside Catskill Park.
Things to do in Saugerties
6. Village Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
3 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By onbelay66
With so many superb pizza options in Saugerties and so many conflicting opinions about them, it's hard to know where to go. My strategy is to first decide what type of pizza I want and then pick the pizzeria based on that. Village Pizza is my go-to pizzeria when I've got a hankering for a tomato basil pie with extra garlic. It's also my choice when looking for quieter dining. Their back dining room is very nice and a more relaxing experience. The cheesy garlic bread is always a nice prelude to the main pie event. For a quick slice the front storefront is nice since there's always a variety of fresh by-the-slice pies waiting for you.
5. Pizza Star
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By OBX717
While visiting my parents they wanted pizza so we got two pizzas. The place is your typical pizza joint with no real atmosphere to speak of other than institutional. We got a meat lovers and a meatball with onion. Both pies were good, the crust was also very good, not super thin, but it had taste and good texture. I was going to say the staff was friendly but after a being down south I will now say the staff was pleasant. Will visit again when in the area.
4. Two Brothers Deli & Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By UpstateNYGal
Inconsistent was my last review. The place is close so we tend to keep trying. But, it's good then bad...good then bad. Lately, they seem overwhelmed when you call. You get a very brisk female answering the phones with a rushed 'please hold' before you can say ANYTHING. Then you hold for awhile...then you give your order and you get 'it'll be an hour/half...CLICK!' You have no time to agree or disagree to that timing. Huh? An hour and half for a damn pizza? So, I call back, again put on hold, this time longer to where I figured I was forgotten about. My call back is to simply ask if we can pick the pizza up to make it quicker, maybe 40 minutes'ish?. She says matter-of-factly; 'probably not'. Whatever! I cancelled the order and called another local place. It took 30 minutes and they were friendly...as in... they appreciated our business instead of acting annoyed by it. These guys need more than '2 brothers'...and the girl that answers the phone. She is obviously exasperated and unhappy there.
Most Popular Italian food in Saugerties, New York, United States
3. Federico's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By supernurse12477
Pizza is bad assed, spinach rolls are just awesome. Family owned business and prices are reasonable. It's a win win. Although their dining room is a bit dated it doesn't take away from the quality of the good. Best pizza in Saugerties!
2. Bella Luna
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By alanjgreenhalgh
I know better than to expect really great food at "Italian Restaurants" in the United States. It is just not fair to compare different type of food. Nonetheless, I always expect good Veal Parmigiana for some reason since you just cannot get that in Italy at all, so no comparison problems. It was mediocre, barely acceptable. The Montepulciano was of poor quality. I don't mind paying more for decent wine, but there was no option as far as I saw for a better quality Montepulciano. I had fusilli with the veal which was also mediocre. The included salad was minuscule and poor. So that was the food. The service was excellent with attentive waiters and very efficient. The hostess was also very nice and accommodating. The atmosphere was very nice.
1. Slices of Saugerties
Overall Ratings
4 based on 111 reviews
Reviewed By Bruce W
This place rocks! Cannot imagine what the recent reviewer could be talking about....that Slices has "slipped?? Simply order a Pizza 'Diane' and see for yourself. My family is particularly in love with any of the Grandma pizzas these folks make. Saugerties would be much less of a destination without Slices around. Just sayin'!
