Location: Bexley
Top Restaurants in Bexley
Countries
Where to eat Pizza food in Bexley: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Bexley. Bexley is a suburban city in Franklin County, Ohio, United States. The population was 13,057 at the 2010 census. Founded as a village over a hundred years ago, the city of Bexley is an old, tree-lined suburb of Columbus, the Ohio state capital, situated on the banks of Alum Creek next to Driving Park and Wolfe Park, just east of the Franklin Park Conservatory. It is horizontally bisected by the National Road (Main Street), serving as a reminder of Bexley's origins as a merger between the prestigious Bullitt Park neighborhood to the north, and the Lutheran college community of Pleasant Ridge to the south.
Things to do in Bexley
10. East Coast Pizzeria LLC
New York style hand tossed pizza made fresh daily along with salads calzones Stromboli subs. Family owned
Reviewed By William B
I had never ordered just a slice of pizza because I was worried about the quality of it. Well I was needing a snack and a slice of pizza sounded good. And boy was it good. I had the pepperoni, sausage and banana pepper slice and when I folded it to eat it the sausage and peppers all collected in the middle of the fold. The slices are huge and next time I will have them cut it into 2 or 3 pieces to make it easier to eat. Nice crispy crust and good flavor. Would liked to see salt and pepper on the table to add to the pizza but it was still very good without it.
9. Mikey's Late Night Slice
Overall Ratings
4 based on 60 reviews
Reviewed By TheGameCrafter
We were craving some pizza while we were exhibiting at Origins in the Columbus Convention Center. So we found Mikey's on Trip Advisor and it did not disappoint. Often times large pizza slices like this can be greasy, but this was excellent. Highly recommended. Only issue I could see is that the temperature in the restaurant is super hot due to all the pizza ovens I would assume. So we ended up taking the pizza outside and eating at the tables outside of the convention center. Way too warm for us to sit in there.
8. TAT Ristorante Di Famiglia
Overall Ratings
4 based on 52 reviews
We are the oldest Italian restaurant in Columbus and proud to have been serving our community for over 80 years. With homemade spaghetti, sauces, and pizza, we know there's something here you'll absolutely love. Don't have to time to eat in? Don't worry,
Reviewed By Toofaraway
We had dinner here on a Sunday afternoon. I had heard of it for many years, but it was my first time there. Homey ambience, very good service, reasonable prices and an amazingly wide selection of food. I enjoyed my dinner very much. The only negative comments I have are that the booth we were at seemed about six inches too narrow and the restrooms were located so that you had to squeeze around a servers station. All in all a very enjoyable meal and I will be back.
7. Yellow Brick Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 60 reviews
Olde Towne Easy's Original Pizza Shop, est. 2009
Reviewed By Karenj1129
This corner pizza and bar establishment was a great recommendation to meet out of town family and friends staying in the area. Our server was attentive but understood our need for conversation. Appetizer were fresh and deliciously prepared. Pizza were great, good selection of fresh toppings. Neighborhood street provided good parking.
6. Forno Kitchen + Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 192 reviews
Located in the heart of the Short North Arts District, Forno offers the best atmosphere and contemporary cuisine in the city, with alluring views of our custom stone-fire oven and High Street happenings. An unrivaled Happy Hour includes hand-crafted drink
Reviewed By GaryC768
Stopped in here after a play for a meal and were very happy with the taste and quality of the wood fired pizza. The pepperoni was truly the way it should be, small, curled up and a little grease holding in the curle. Great taste, well prepared and worth it. The house salad was excellent as well. Will definitely return here
Where to eat Sushi food in Bexley: The Best Restaurants and Bars
5. Harvest Pizzeria
Reviewed By Lola M
I was very disappointed when the Harvest located in German Village closed- Well, this new harvest is even better. The place is spacious, cozy and with a big patio and a bar. We sat outside and although it was raining the big umbrella protected us from the rain. We shared the tuna poke (delicious), Brussels sprouts (one of my favorites) and the Spicy Yuma (really, really good)- Anyway, I am very happy that we have now a Harvest closed by and I am definitely going back.
4. Harvest
Reviewed By 454christinac
Tried the bexley harvest given the German village location has closed. Interestingly the menus are a little different. They have sandwiches and sadly didnât have the green goddess salad I loved. The pizza is on par with being from harvest. Delicious thin crust. And the Cesar kale salad is fabulous as always. Service was a little slow. But overall will be back. And no wait! Which was wonderful. Also outdoor seating.
3. Anthony's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By Itraveldou
Had our first visit to Anthony's Pizza last Friday night! We ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and it was awesome. I would have preferred a little more ranch on it, but I'm sure if I had just asked, they would have put a bit more on it. The crust was one of the best I've ever eaten on a pizza. It was the perfect thinness. I will definitely visit this hometown shop when in the Bexley area again! YUM!!
2. Bexley Pizza Plus
Overall Ratings
4 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By Eligablegayman4you
This is a great pizza for delivery. It is beyond traditional with great mixes of toppings. Though they were terrific a decade ago when they created most of these pizzas..and times and tastes do change. These are pizzas that make meals!A bit expensive. But worth the change when you want more than just basic pizza.Plus the location is the historic early Dobb's Toddle House...which makes it very fun!
1. Rubino's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 122 reviews
Reviewed By 73randallw
Being from Upper Arlington rather than Bexley, I'd heard about Rubino's for decades, but never eaten there. I read a number of reviews before going with the family and now understand why folks either love the place or hate it. Opened in 1954, Rubino's hasn't changed much since then nor have they spent any money on decor, furnishings, or cleaning, so if you're looking for an upscale pizza experience, this ain't it and the pizza certainly isn't "deep dish". But if you're looking for one of the best thin crust, and I mean really thin, pizzas in a throwback atmosphere, this is the place. Order double cheese on anything you get. The pepperoni is great as are the other vegetable toppings, but while a lot of people rave about the thinly sliced sausage loaf, it didn't do anything for me. No beer, wine or liquor. Very kid friendly and the waitresses are great. Also remember it's cash only.
Ohio, United States Food Guide: 7 Asian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Bexley
