Location: Amityville
Top Restaurants in Amityville
Countries
Where to eat Pizza food in Amityville: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Find out what Pizza restaurants to try in Amityville. Amityville is a village in the town of Babylon in Suffolk County, New York, in the United States. The population was 9,523 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Amityville
9. Gino's Pizzeria and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 41 reviews
Reviewed By edlanc50
I spent 6 nights in town and ate at Gino's 4 times! That alone should tell you something. Very attentive staff, excellent pizza, pasta dishes, and my favorite...seafood! Monday pasta special is not to be missed!!
8. Sbarro
Home of the original XL NY Slice. Since 1956, Sbarro has been serving the XL NY Slice. Starting with made-daily hand stretched dough, San Marzano style sauce and topped with 100% Whole Milk Mozzarella cheese.
Reviewed By Mollymike
I've been coming to this sbarros since the mall opened up in the 1970's. It has been at this same location in the mall ever since. Have had meatball Heros , but mostly I come here for the pizza.It's pretty clean , staff is friendly, prices are good.
Where to eat Seafood food in Amityville: The Best Restaurants and Bars
7. Saverio's Authentic Pizza Napoletana
Overall Ratings
5 based on 28 reviews
We are a family owned and operated business since 1967 and added Saverioâs in 2015! Saverioâs is a taste of Napoli here on Long Island! We serve authentic pizza Napoletana and treat your like family! Come and eat! Vieni a mangiare!
Reviewed By CRDixHills
Don't think about it! Just come! Don't leave it bookmarked for too long as I did I truly regret it now hahaha! Street parking but we were able to find parking with no issue. It's located in AS PORK STORE. They have a good amount of tables. Three located in the pizza entrance and the remaining tables in the market. Due to other reviews I expected just two tables but glad to see they have put more in. Great options in the market as well- prosciutto cheese rolls, rice balls and etc. we were tempted to order but decided to do so next time. Service was top notch despite being busy with market patrons. Amazing service and amazing pizza! A business that appreciates their customers! The owner came up to us and introduced herself pointed out her husband and also her daughter who happened to be one of staff taking care of us. We had about three attending to our every need. Now onto the food!So many different types of pizza we couldn't decide. We went with meatball and bufala cheese pie. There's two style of cooking it Italian (softer) and NYC (crisper) we went with the Italian style. Wow the cheese sauce and meatball man sooooooo good! We also ordered two peronis this place offers a few beers and wines which I was not expecting but was excited to see on their menu. We ordered their half order of dough strips that comes with Nutella and marshmallows wow really good too! The half order is perfect for 2-3 people anymore than that I suggest you order a full. I can't wait to come back and try other pizza options!
6. Albert's Pizza Shop
Reviewed By spome03
We do not have large square pies at home. So each summer visit my kids love to order Alberts. They always are very friendly in this location and the sauce is terrific. I will say that I love it cold the next day for breakfast.
5. Phil's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 125 reviews
Reviewed By sukieusa
This is a gem of a little restaurant in a strip mall. It is also a pizza place. The decor is nothing fancy, but the food is fantastic. All are very large portions, enough to take home and have another meal the next day. The wine is a reasonable price too.First trip I had the eggplant parm, excellent and so much food. The second visit I had the grilled salmon. 3 really nice size grilled pieces, cooked just right and so tasty, served with a salad or pasta on a bed of broccoli rabe, also cooked just right.The only critical thing I can say is that there is way too much oil in everything and that is the only reason I didn't give it 5 stars, but of course that makes it taste good.The serve on both visits was good, attentive but not annoying. Will be back!
4. Mikes Pizza
Reviewed By LollysLook
Mike's Pizza is a secret. There is no storefront. It is delivery only by text. You really have to be in the know to order. They only deliver to a small radius a few days a week for a few hours. So, if you are able you absolutely have to try their pizza. It is very good!
Most Popular Pub food in Amityville, New York, United States
3. Phil's Pizza II
Overall Ratings
4 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By Suzanne K
We eat here a few times per month. The pizza topping choices are always changing and inspired! The entrees and especially the weekly specials are extremely good. The food is always fresh and plentiful!! The owners, Sal and Tony, are two of the nicest people I've ever met. The dining room is newly redone.
2. Raimo's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 42 reviews
Reviewed By TheSushiGuy
I came here for lunch on 7/12/18. This place has seriously gone downhill since the new owners took over. The Chicken Caesar pizza was just OK. The grandma with chicken was absolutely disgusting.
1. Giovanni's of Massqpequa
Overall Ratings
4 based on 57 reviews
Reviewed By Torres8174
Attended a reunion with about 35 others. The service and attentiveness of the staff was great. We had the veal and chicken it was very good, nice portion. We had a pre-fix menu but everything was great. Giovanni was attentive and ensured everyone was ok.
