Location: Shelter Island
Top Restaurants in Shelter Island
Countries
Where to eat Mexican food in Shelter Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Mexican food in Shelter Island, New York, United States. Shelter Island is a town and island at the eastern end of Long Island in the U.S. state of New York. It is part of Suffolk County, although it is separated from the rest of the county by water. The population was 2,392 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Shelter Island
1. Lucharito's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 284 reviews
We will be CLOSED Jan 22 - Feb 1. Both Locations. Reno & Relaxation. See you for lunch Friday the 2nd!
Reviewed By ajwmlwslw
Maybe it was just an off day. We sat for 15 minutes before someone came over to us. Then our food was very slow to come out. We didn't like the chicken taco and I ordered another fish taco which was very good. It took so long to come out that I just got the check.
Most Popular Seafood food in Shelter Island, New York, United States
2. Maria's kitchen
Overall Ratings
4 based on 48 reviews
Reviewed By 7DD
This place is so good, I looked at previous reviews so decided to call for a reservation, I should have looked more at the pictures etc, so when I rang the lady on the phone was like ya come by, took no name for the booking so I was like ok.I rocked up with my wife all dressed up to find a little building with people ordering take out, we were surprised to say the least but there is a little out back with like 5 tables in a little garden.We sat out the back and I grabbed a beer from the Shelter Island craft brewery next door,We ordered chips and guacamole with salsa to start, our entrees were chicken enchiladas en mole and my wife had the chicken tacos, we waited a little while as they were busy and everything came together, everything was so tasty and had a little kick in the sauces, Delicious The staff were so nice, highly recommend for take out or even to relax in the back yard
Top 10 Italian food in Shelter Island, New York, United States
3. Agave grill and cantina
Overall Ratings
4 based on 56 reviews
Reviewed By robertpf2015
We visited Agave for the first time this week. Had a short wait to get in- its a small place and quite popular on weekends. White tablecloths in a nice dinner environment for a Mexican Restaurant. Had the Fish Tacos, Steak Fajitas and Pollo Poblanco, all were well prepared and well presented. Tasty and filling. Will go back.
Best American food near Shelter Island, New York, United States
4. Tikal 1
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By RonaSomerville
This is a family place that serves fresh Mexican/South American food. (They are Guatemalan.) Not Tex-Mex, real country food. We got there in the dead spot after lunch and before dinner. Even though only two tables were in use, we got attentive service. After school, a pack of children came in (clearly part of the family.) It felt like I was in someone's house -- someone who cooked well! PS -- they were quiet and very well behaved children! It was a pleasant surprise to find this place. Greenport is way out near Orient Point, where there is fishing and farming and tourism. We are the kind of tourist who get bored of businesses that are aimed at tourists. This is the kind of business I did not expect to find in Greenport. It doesn't have the feel of tourist trap; it felt like a place that is a local favorite. We spent $19 for two people, including tip, and were totally satisfied.
5. Estia's Little Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4 based on 165 reviews
Reviewed By CHD6265
.... for a Brit in the current dollar pound environment! Setting aside 5 burritos, 5 beers and a margarita with 10% tip (only? Only in the US would 10% be an insult - in U.K. That would be good performance) cost me £140, the food here was great. Don't be put off by the shack appearance and give it a go.
