Location: Schererville
Top Restaurants in Schererville
Top Things to do in Schererville
Countries
Where to eat Italian food in Schererville: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Schererville, Indiana, United States. Schererville is a town in St. John Township, Lake County, Indiana, United States. The population was 29,243 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Schererville
10. Carrabbaâs Italian Grill
Overall Ratings
3 based on 74 reviews
Reviewed By Jillyjillyjilly
Every time I go here it seems to get better! The servers are friendly and I love their small plates! The prosciutto asparagus is salty delicious! I also enjoyed the sausage stuffed mushrooms!
9. Giordano's
Overall Ratings
3 based on 35 reviews
Famous Chicago-style deep dish pizza right in your neighborhood. Visit us for a family-friendly atmosphere and delicious food or order your meal online for pickup or delivery.
Reviewed By Teresita A
Great pizza and pastas with meatballs. Slow service and not too efficient staff. Our waiter misunderstood our order and brought two full meals each for 2 people. We paid for 4 meals for two people. We didn't want to make a fuzz so we simply took the extra home.
8. Livio's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 58 reviews
Reviewed By mexicangirl2
I thought this was an Italian restaurant but the decor is weird. There's airplanes, hot air balloons hanging from the ceiling, fishing nets and boats near the booths. We ordered the tomato bread which was good but when I told the waiteress that I wanted the stuff shells for dinner she told me that they weren't that good and that I'd be better getting something else. I ordered the fried perch my husband ordered the rigatoni with sausage. He said it tasted like it came out of a jar. The perch was flat and even before I tasted it you could tell that they were frozen. The food here is definately not fresh. I could have stayed home and heated up something from my freezer
7. Rosati's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By Jaime C
Order a pick up and the lady repeated our whole order to assure it was correct and she we went to pick up we decided to eat there instead well very good service and understanding we were tired the manager Kathy was very accommodating and was very pleasant
6. Aurelio's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 48 reviews
What sets Aurelio's apart from other Chicago-style pizza? We're different because we use only quality ingredients, serve a variety of generous sizes, and specialize in customizing orders to suit each individual taste. Since 1959, the Aurelio family has be
Reviewed By MarthaWK
Very disappointing for an Aurelio's. The place was dark and poorly lit. The environment was not friendly when we arrived. After being seated the waitress was too distracted by other things going on to even look at us while she was taking out order. The wings were raw. The mozzarella sticks were cold. The food then took forever and they were almost wanting to kick us out while we were eating because it was getting close to closing. No worries as we won't be back.
5. Ciao Bella Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 156 reviews
Reviewed By Magellan3
In search for a restaurant that brings a level of quality the Region desperately deserves, we made a first time visit to Ciao Bella. A slow start from service was a look into the future of what we can expect from our food. When asked about why they were using a special Valentineâs Day menu three days after the holiday, we were inadvertently tipped off that the food was prepared in advance. Management refused to offer anything from their regular menu. Had I realized it then, I would have walked out. Their special menu reflected prices averaging $7 above their normal menu pricing. The Linguini di Mare was lackluster. The seafood was small and chewy. It tasted like it came from a bulk bag you would buy from a wholesale club warehouse. The Gnocchi Della Nona was flavorless. I tried their spicy tomato sauce on the linguini and spaghetti and the best way that I can describe it is a watered down version of Chef Boyardee sauce minus the meat. Shirley Temples for the kids were flat and tasted like plastic. An unfortunate first and last visit to Ciao Bella.
4. Pepino's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 47 reviews
Reviewed By yogajane07
I canât say enough about Pepinoâs, they are amazing. The beef sandwiches and combos on garlic bread, sweet peppers and cheese, sweet potato fries, couldnât make us happier for dinner. The sandwich is so large (and yummy) we can only eat half and then you get an amazing lunch the next day. The pizza is really good as well, but the beef is the star in our books. You can dine in or carry out. You can even order ahead, itâs all good. Make sure you get there, you wonât regret it. FYI they are closed on Mondays.Enjoy!
3. Little Italy
Overall Ratings
4 based on 132 reviews
Reviewed By Robin R
Very tasty Italian food served in either small or large plates. The small plates can easily feed two while the large can feed four! Dinners come with bread, salad and baked ziti. We had shrimp and spinach Alfredo, crispy pork shoulder, penne and sausage al la vodka and sausage and peppers. All were excellent and more than enough to feed eight adults. Would definitely go back.
2. Tomato Bar Pizza Bakery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 139 reviews
Reviewed By LauraAgardy
Decent beer selection, wide variety of sandwiches, appetizers, and salads, and premium specialty pizzas cooked to perfection....one word- YUM. If you are a pesto and veggie lover, they have a pizza called Magic Potion that's amazing. It traditionally comes with sausage, but my mom doesn't eat meat, so she orders the pizza without the sausage every time we go. It is so dang good....great. Now I'm hungry. Hahaha, well at least I know what I am doing for dinner tonight!
1. Giuseppe's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 214 reviews
We are proud to offer authentic Neapolitan pizza here in North-West-Indiana. Our Staff has been trained by an Italian Master Pizza Chef with over 30 years of expertise. The 19th Century recipe begins with pizza dough that is made with Imported Italian flo
Reviewed By 881joel
My wife and I were in the area and stumbled upon this place. All I could say is wow! When we walked in I knew we were going to love it. The decor and the atmosphere were wonderful the service was outstanding and the food was awesome. We had Pizza and raviolis with meatballs they were both delicious. I can't wait to try it out again.
