Location: Newberry
Top Restaurants in Newberry
Countries
Where to eat Italian food in Newberry: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Newberry, Florida, United States. Newberry is a city located on the southwest side of Alachua County, Florida, United States. The population was 4,950 at the 2010 census and its population has grown since 1990. The University of Florida estimates the city's population at 5,946 as of September 2016. Much of the city borders the neighboring Gilchrist County to the west. The current mayor is Jordan Marlowe.
Things to do in Newberry
10. Fresco Pizza and Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
Reviewed By kingofhma
Not all items on the menu have the same quality. The Sicilian Chicken was absolutely to die for. The cream sauce was unique. The Salmon Miguel was also worth ordering again. The Eggplant Parm and the Chicken Marsala, were not memorable. The garlic bread with dinner was worth coming back for more. The pizza dough may have been the same as the garlic bread and great. Had meat-lovers pizza and tomato sauce was good but needed more cheese and Italian sausage and pepperoni were from a package. Be selective on what you order. liked the ambience. Note there is outside seating and plastic protects from elements and cold temp are handled with heaters.
9. Francesca's Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 488 reviews
Reviewed By Cynthia B
I've eaten at this restaurant a few times before and was expecting a reasonably delicious array of dishes. Suffice it to say that the buffet on steam tables fell so far short of expectations that none of my table of eight found much to their liking. The scrambled eggs were hard and dry, the link sausage cold, French toast flat and soggy. The pork loin and its balsamic/prune sauce promised to be tasty, but the dryness of the meat and the tart sauce just didn't work. Mushrooms with rice looked like vomit. The price - $35+ per person, half that for children under age 10 - was really a cruel slap in the face for such terrible food. Very, very disappointing.I am very sorry that you felt disappointed in our Mother's Day buffet which has been presenting for many years. I personally have gone to the tables to ensure that all guests are happy and enjoying their meal and the selections that we have provided. I have many repeat customers that book well in advance of the event. This year was no exception and was well received by the guests. I do get feedback as people are leaving.We are continually bringing freshly cooked food to the buffet line so that no item is there for very long and it comes directly from the kitchen's ovens and stoves. It would have been helpful if you had let us know that you had an issue and we would have done everything to correct it at that time.
8. I Love NY Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By himalb2345
The pizza here is authentic to actual NY pizza. We absolutely love it. Although the pizza is their specialty, they sell authentic Italian cousins such as strombolis. Also the garlic knots are great!
7. New York Pizza Plus
Overall Ratings
4 based on 113 reviews
Reviewed By marybel1
I have eaten here many times and food is always good. We usually go for dinner. I especially like Thursday night all you can spaghetti. The spaghetti is delicious and one serving is more than enough. I was surprised to see they have a wonderful lunch buffet. There was all kinds of Italian dishes, salads, and pizza. The price includes a drink so what lunch would normally cost. I could never sample all the dishes but what I did was very good. I will have to come again to try more dushes. I highly recommend if you are in area.
6. Tony and Al's Deli
Overall Ratings
4 based on 82 reviews
Reviewed By ransom007
There is free street parking in the area and a parking lot across the street. It is a storefront restaurant. There is a full bar There are a few televisions. I got a distinct feeling that it is a place locals frequent. The service was great and my food was, likewise, great.
5. Pomodoro Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 222 reviews
Reviewed By Vic P
Met a couple of students there to have lunch. I had gotten their lunch soup and salad before and loved it. This time there was something different. It may be as simple as the onions in the salad were strong and overpowering and affected by taste. Their open face calzone with soup looked amazing and I know their pizza are. Staff was friendly as always. Owner wanted to open the door to the patio, but I asked it to be closed as it was COLD outside and made us discomfortable. He closed it, but I got the look. Ill go back, but it will be something else. BTW, their BOGO carry out is great.
4. Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 314 reviews
Piesanos is a locally owned restaurant with three convenient Gainesville locations, two Ocala locations, and one location in the Villages!
Reviewed By Michael F
i have been using Piesanos for catering events for the past couple months and they do a great job. the food is delicious and the serving size is plentiful. the prices are good for what you get.
3. Blue Highway Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 141 reviews
Blue Highway is a a casual, family-friendly neighborhood restaurant specializing in traditional Neapolitan style pizza and calazones (Glueten free options are available). Small plates, salads, paninis, sandwiches, pastas and desserts are served. A good se
Reviewed By Nancy N
This was a first for 2 in our party. Happy hour cabernet was good and the cheese bread appetizer was terrific. I had linguine with spicy marinara and fennel sausage. The sauce was indeed hot because there were rings of jalapeno pepper in it. I ate half my meal because of the appetizer and reheated it the following night for dinner--it was just as good as the first night. I will definitely be back. Nice, casual atmosphere.
2. Villaggio's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
5 based on 69 reviews
Reviewed By StephanieBello516
The only authentic thing about this pizzeria were the friendly Mexican staff and the cannolis. Otherwise the pizza came close but still needs work. I would give this location another try but the sauce needs work. Was not impressed by the mushroom pizza.
1. O Sole Mio
Overall Ratings
4 based on 111 reviews
Reviewed By BlueWaterGator
We love to enjoy dinner at OâSolo Mia because the food is flavor-packed, always tastes fresh, served hot, and we never leave hungry. The menu has a huge selection of entrees, salads, appetizers, desserts, and drinks. We love their specialities and the salads. Occasionally we will order an appetizer and salad or just get a pizza. Their pizzaâs are also huge. They have wonderful desserts and a nice selection of wines.The Serve Staff does their job well. We always feel as though the service is superior to most.The restaurant is busy (because it is good food for a good price). I would suggest going before 6 p.m. if you donât want to wait. The wait times are not awful but weekends are the worse between 6:15 and 8:00 p.m. Nice place for couple or Family. I hope you will enjoy! Fun place to get a GREAT meal.Thank You OâSolo Mia!Cheers...BlueWaterSailor
