Location: New Cumberland
Top Restaurants in New Cumberland
Top Things to do in New Cumberland
Countries
Where to eat Italian food in New Cumberland: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in New Cumberland, Pennsylvania, United States. New Cumberland is a borough in easternmost Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, United States. New Cumberland was incorporated on March 21, 1831. The population was 7,277 at the 2010 census. The borough is noted for its historic downtown which includes landmarks like the historic West Shore Theater and the yearly Apple Festival, which gathers hundreds of vendors and thousands of visitors.
Things to do in New Cumberland
10. Sammy's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 115 reviews
Reviewed By AdmiralRN
Had another delightful encounter at this BYOB Italian resturant. Service by LeRoy top notch; and food by owner/chef Sammy delicious. Lobster bisque was yummy only to be out done by the entrees. Pesto sauce is my favorite. A trip to Sammy's helps me miss Italy less.
9. Gabriella Italian Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 482 reviews
Reviewed By Yucatan-Admirer
My husband took me for a birthday dinner. Chris was our waiter and was very good. Made an excellent chocolate martini. We had an appetizer which was delicious. Can't remember the name because it was a special, but cheese, roasted red peppers, and tomatoes - sort of like a caprese. We love the bread, which they will continue bringing. My husband had manicotti which he loves and it was as good as ever. I had the crab cake which was plentiful and delicious. Of course I had the creme brulee - it was my birthday!
8. Villa Roma Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By Dean_Amy-2004
Appearance is deceiving. We came here twice and it was like a different restaurant because the menu is so broad...pizza and subs to Italian dinners to Mexican. Portions were generous and quality was good. Order and pay at the counter, then they bring it to your table. Street parking available for free. Check it out if youâre in the area.
7. The Pizza Grille - Camp Hill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 363 reviews
The Pizza Grille offers stylish and casual dining at each of our locations in Lemoyne, Camp Hill & Carlisle, which all include covered outdoor dining year round. Voted Simply the Best by Harrisburg Magazine since 2003, The Pizza Grille offers award winnin
Reviewed By lcb513
Food was tasty, server was friendly and helpful and the place was packed. That's probably why the service was a little slow but we didn't mind. Met an out-of-town relative there and that gave us a chance to catch up. We'll be going back.
6. Pastorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 152 reviews
Reviewed By Aimen
My husband and I were really looking forward to eating here. we encourage and enjoy local non chain restaurant and were excited after reviewing all the wonderful reviews. Our experience here was below average perhaps they were having an off day regardless will not be returning. We drove 25 mins to get here and were seated at 6: 32 Pm. Our orders were taken right away. Till now attentive staff and reasonable ambience. It went all down hill from there this was sunday night and the place was packed. There was only one hostess catering to approx. 18 - 20 ppl. There was only one chef with another person who appeared to be a bus boy mostly. It took 30 mins for our waters and 45 mins for the bread to show up at our table. It took 1 hour 30 mins for the food to show up. By this time we were close to walking out and eating at a near by Taco bell. There problem I think were the numerous take out / uber eat orders that were coming in. The hostess was apologetic and offered to take off the 2.45 cents below average garlic bread off out tab. We were ravenous so once the food showed up we were ready to forgive and forget. The unfortunate thing is even though we could have chewed on our arm by this time and found it delicious the food was anything but. My husbands alfredo pasta was runny and al dante to the point of being edible. MY crab / shrimp vodka sauce pasta was delicious but soggy. Sometime the wait is worth it this time it really wasn't. Below average and not memorable. DO not visit on a busy weekend night perhaps for lunch would be acceptable.
5. Dolce Vita Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 220 reviews
Reviewed By Donna S
When it comes to front porch dining, Dolce Vita is the BEST by far on the West Shore! Cozy, intimate, peaceful setting to enjoy a fine dining experience and create beautiful memories with treasured friends and family. This dinner only, bring your own beverage restaurant excels with warm hospitality, gracious service, scrumptious baked manicotti and lasagna which will delight your taste buds everytime! Thank you Dolce Vita for another wonderful dining experience!
What to do and see in New Cumberland, United States: The Best Places and Tips
4. Bacco Pizzeria and Wine Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 108 reviews
Reviewed By Donhumphrioni
The surroundings and the service were fabulous . The brick oven pizzas are really good. Our waitress worked really hard and we were astonished how she successfully served the entire restaurant single handed. The menu is a little limited with regards to nibbles and appetisers but was a really enjoyable experience
New Cumberland Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in New Cumberland
3. Mangia Qui
Overall Ratings
4 based on 226 reviews
Mangia Qui offers regional Italian dishes using local ingredients as well as artisan Italian meats and cheeses.
Reviewed By Michael R
Dined at Mangia Qui with a group of clients and colleagues while in Harrisburg on business. Mangia Qui provided a very sophisticated dining experience. The main dining area is small and quite, perfect for conversation. The service was very attentive. We shared a couple varieties of oysters on the half shell and a smoked ham/prosciutto plate for appetizers, which were all very nice. Between us we were evenly split on orders for the tuna steak special and the veal with pheasant sausage and cranberries special. I had the veal, it was unusual and quite good.) Wine selections were primarily Italian and quite good as well. It is not inexpensive. Expect to spend $75 per person, potentially more or less, depending on what you order. But the quality is worth it.
Best Cafe food near New Cumberland, Pennsylvania, United States
2. Cork & Fork
Overall Ratings
4 based on 191 reviews
Cork & Fork believes in working with local farms and purveyors to maintain sustainability and seasonality. We recognize the local culture, their customs and environment by adapting our menu, cuisine and ingredients accordingly with the utmost respect and
Reviewed By Jay N
We very much enjoyed having a casual lunch there. We passed by the evening before during dinner and it was packed and also had some nice outside street tables. We went back for lunch and weâre not disappointed.
Top 10 American food in New Cumberland, Pennsylvania, United States
1. Bricco
Overall Ratings
4 based on 392 reviews
Refined Italian cuisine in the heart of downtown Harrisburg. Bricco is a collaboration between the Olewine School of Culinary Arts and the Harrisburg Hotel Corporation. Founded with funding from the Benjamin Olewine III family, our kitchens feature the br
Reviewed By LynneS856
We went on a slow night but still got great, welcoming service. Very interesting and unique menu. The food that was great was really great. The polenta was out of this world. There were couple of small misses in taste nut that didn't ruin the fantastic experience. Thank you for taking the time to review us!
Most Popular Asian food in New Cumberland, Pennsylvania, United States
