Location: New Castle
Top Restaurants in New Castle
Countries
Where to eat Italian food in New Castle: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in New Castle, Pennsylvania, United States. New Castle is a city in and the county seat of Lawrence County, Pennsylvania, United States, 50 miles (80 km) northwest of Pittsburgh and near the Pennsylvania–Ohio border just 18 miles (29 km) east of Youngstown, Ohio. The population was 23,128 as of the 2010 census. It is the commercial center of a fertile agricultural region.
Things to do in New Castle
10. Fourstar Pizza & Fresh-Baked Subs
Whether you need pizza for a party, or just don't feel like cooking tonight, call Four Star Pizza & Fresh-Baked Subs for a meal delivered to you fast. Save with our coupons and specials. Ask us about our daily lunch specials. Four Star Pizza is proud to b
Reviewed By biztravler18
Slow delivery. Pizza is dry and doesn't have that much flavor. Just a small chain pizza joint. Nothing special for me.
9. Faraone Brothers
Reviewed By vacationlover061
We had Farone Bros. make food for my mother in law's 80th birthday party. We got penne, meatballs and eggplant parmesan. The eggplant was truly to die for. Even the old italian aunts loved it. Said it was prepared right - even asked how they prepared it and approved (salted, drained first). Go out of your way for this. The outside is nothing to look at and there are only a few small tables but...
8. Pizza Man's Pizza
Reviewed By Jaythereviewer
With all the pizza places in New Castle, Pizza Man's will get lost on you. The pizza, sausage, peperoni and bacon, was flavorful but was not memorable. It did not leave a lasting impression. They sell pizza by the slice so if I'm in the area, I might stop by for a slice. The service was adequate.
7. Soni's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By fjung2016
chicken parm was frozen patties, crust came off when cut revealing a white rubbery meat, not very tasty, sambucca pasta had moldy taste, kitchen said we had to accept it due to taste not being a return factor, spaghetti tasted good but bad on stomach later that evening, maybe because it was served luke warm. bad restaurant. they do not care about customer satisfaction an retention only profits. won't be back.
6. Gallo's Italian Villa
Overall Ratings
4 based on 34 reviews
Reviewed By 111russell
My high school class had our annual dinner here for the last two years. The food was very tasty and served at the right temperature. They provided a buffet with pasta, meatballs, chicken, potatoes, green beans, and salad. Drinks were also provided.We had a nice private room that was more than adequate for our group of 40. The staff kept the buffet foods warm and replaced the foods before the containers ran out. The staff was very cordial and efficient.Price was very moderate considering how good the quality of food that we received and the good service that we received.
5. Ladies of the Dukes
Overall Ratings
4 based on 17 reviews
Italian restaurant with great home cooked meals. Take-outs are available from 10:00 - 5:30 and the restaurant is open from 11:30 am - 6:00 pm. We are only open on Sundays. Reservations are accepted but not required.
Reviewed By Silverstreak46
I love this place. It has extremely tasty food and is incredibly inexpensive. I usually get spaghetti and meatballs or ravioli. This last visit I decided to try their Eggplant Parmesan. I was blown away by its incredible taste. We have no restaurants around us that come close to the quality and taste of their sauces. Did I say I love it?
4. Mangino's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 25 reviews
Everything is homemade Best pizza in the entrire area by far
Reviewed By Nautique210
I work near manginos pizza and stop quite frequently for pizza slices at lunch. The pizza slices are $2 a slice. They have a bunch of different toppings to choose from. I recommend the buffalo chicken pizza, I would say they have the best buffalo chicken pizza I've ever had.
3. II Tomato
Overall Ratings
4 based on 68 reviews
Reviewed By Mitzi301
We gathered in town to do some work on our late parentsâ home. Before going our separate ways (we are all out of state) we had an early dinner. Everything was fine, food was good but maybe itâs because weâre all older but portions seemed large, even the early bird specials. Definitely enough that one sibling took some leftovers so not wasted. Prices are actually pretty good. Iâm sure weâll be back in a few months.
Most Popular Fast Food food in New Castle, Pennsylvania, United States
2. Chuck Tanner's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 45 reviews
Reviewed By 110avam
There were 6 of us for lunch. Both service and food were great. Staff very friendly. Prices reasonable. Wedding soup was fabulous as was eggplant parmigiana.
1. Pagley's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 109 reviews
Most popular italian restaurant in New Castle , PA Great italiuan sauce
Reviewed By Treece36
Food was decent. I don't think it's excellent as I've had much better but raviolis were good. Smelts were pretty good. Didn't care for the stuffed banana peppers, too much bread in the stuffing. This restaurant is considered good in the city of New Castle - but sorry to say but there's not a lot of great restaurants.
Top 10 American food in New Castle, Pennsylvania, United States
