Location: Manorville
Top Restaurants in Manorville
Countries
Where to eat Italian food in Manorville: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Manorville. Manorville is a hamlet and census-designated place (CDP) in Suffolk County, New York, United States. The population was 14,314 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Manorville
10. Alfredo's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By johnkL3739AE
So went in for a bite on Sunday evening. The girls working the front said we could sit anywhere; OK, all the tables were dirty, so we sat at the table she was using to drop her serving tray. So to rephrase, 8 tables 7 dirty, one had a serving tray sitting on it. The two young girls were sweet and friendly, maybe there first job. They need to be taught how to be a server.Its not like they were busy, you clear, set and serve then repeat. Another couple came in after us, had to be in there 80's they sat down and said "the table is dirty" again after the girls said sit anywhere you want. They don't know.I order the Pasta Alfredo, specifically fettuccine, Alfredo. and a dish on the menu called Chicken Vendura Balsamic grilled chicken with spinach, broccoli and mushrooms. The young lady came back and asked me if I ordered fettuccine pasta. My wife was brought a dish of Chicken fried in egg batter topped with broccoli. She didn't want to change the dish, but when the girl came over she made mention of it. I had looked at the menu and did not see the dish she brought us was not listed. I pointed that out to the server. So to reiterate, the dish she brought us was not on the menu, how could we have ordered it.The food was good the servers need work.
9. Anton Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By dennis1027
Pizza was very good and fresh. Went on a Friday evening during lent so it was a little crowded. Would definitely visit again
8. Alitalia Pizza and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
Reviewed By Rubank13
I think that their Pizza is usually excellent and they have a large selection too. I bought the Wednesday night special large cheese pie last week for $11.95 added sausage, peppers and onions at $3.00 for each topping. $9.00 for toppings isnât the problem. The problem is the sausage was not slices and could not be found. They used shavings or ultra thin (paper thin slices) which you could not see or even taste on the pie. I never saw that before in 30 years of eating at this joint! I also ordered a dozen and a half of chicken wings as a treat to the family. Terrible - my family of 4 tried to eat them but couldnât. They where not crisp, slightly under cooked and drowned in a sauce that was tasteless. Threw them out! Cook must have had a bad day. I think this is the first time they disappointed us so I will go back and try again but will eat at the store like I usually do. Sorry but this was a bad dinning experience that was too costly at $45 bucks for 1 large pie and 18 wings.
7. Carlo's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By AlyssaAdventures
Absolutely love this pizzeria. Food is always piping hot and pizza is always perfect. We call in advance to pick up and it can sometimes be 30-45 minute wait but it's always worth it.
6. La Bistro Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 33 reviews
Reviewed By Stever516
Appetizer of Muscles in Red Sauce. Excellent. Large portion flavored excellent. Not sandy, large and delicious. One eggplant rollatini. Great. Flavor,large portion not at all dry. One linguine red clam sauce. Excellent. Plenty of clams. $32 for all. I will go back.
5. Mama Lisa
Overall Ratings
4 based on 125 reviews
Reviewed By mayortony
visited here last Sunday with my wife and son and i have nothing but raves for the place. the food was tasty and plentiful, served piping hot. the Sunday menu specials were wonderful and reasonably priced at $20 and under. they include soup or salad, entree, dessert and coffee. the wait staff was friendly and attentive. both the owner and cook take an active role in the dining room, circulating among the guests to make sure all is well. We canât wait to return. best first time restaurant iâve been to in ages. absolutely loved Mama Lisa.
4. Desmonds Restaurant & Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 98 reviews
Hidden in the grand East Wind Long Island at the gateway to Long Island's famed North Fork and Wine Country is Desmond's Restaurant & Pub, a casually elegant restaurant and lounge. Our Italian-American cuisine showcases the finest locally grown ingredient
Reviewed By Tootsy J
Excellent service - Sunday evening Price Fix. Seafood & Pasta dishes. Key Lime Pie and Flourless chocolate cake for desser....Stayed in the Hotel for Spa treatments - Service was very attentive and food was good and reasonable. Will definitely be returning.Dear Tootsy - Congratulations on your 30th Anniversary and we are so delighted you chose to spend it with us. Thank you for your great review and we will see you again soon. Cheers!
3. La Volpe Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 132 reviews
Reviewed By fascor
Have been here a few times on different occasions and the food has always been great! The Linguine Al Nero was excellent!
2. Pennachio's
Reviewed By reddvixen
Hard to believe that this gem is hidden away off the LIE in Manorville. Authentic Italian food at reasonable prices.At first glance this is just a regular pizzeria. It is a pizzeria but it also has delicious main courses.....Pasta, al dente, with great gravy.The spicy mussels and accompanying pasta with the same sauce is to die for.Veal parmesan is meaty and tender....clearly the quality of the meat did not require it to be pounded to death.Side salads are not filled with iceberg lettuce and unripened tomatoes but a blend of spring greens. Check it out!!!
1. Carlo's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By H Hope M
Nice to have a reasonably priced Italian Eatery in the are where the food is really good. We dined off the menu but the pizza looked good as well. Nicely done newly opened. But the decor does not say Italian at all. Fairly priced dessert list as well. We enjoyed our meal and we will return.
Most Popular Bar food in Manorville, New York, United States
