Location: Macedon
Top Restaurants in Macedon
Countries
Where to eat Italian food in Macedon: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Reviews on Italian food in Macedon, New York, United States. Macedon is a town in Wayne County, New York, United States. The population was 9,148 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Macedon
10. Jason New York Pizzeria
Reviewed By BigDawgMAF
My first visit to this place and it won't be my last. We had the Steak subs, slices, and Louisiana charbroiled wings. Everything was outstanding!10 inch steak subs with lots of meat and cheese. Rolls are made onsite and they are thick & moist. Louisiana charbroiled wings are hard to find. These were just great as they are fresh and not frozen (per the owner). We ordered slices of Buffalo chicken and pepperoni. Thin NY CITY style and very good. Owner brought us a free slice of cheese so we could try that also. Owner checked in on us multiple times and was very friendly. Prices are very reasonable and place was very clean.
9. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
4 based on 124 reviews
Reviewed By GLaSota
Had dinner here on a Friday night after going to the movies. Since it was 6:30, I thought for sure that we would have to wait for a table, but we were seated immediately and service was prompt. It is wonderful that Olive Garden includes the calories for each dish...made it very easy for us as we were counting calories. Had the chicken piccata with the salad. Even though they are delicious, we had to pass on the breadsticks. A delicious dinner........just what I would expect from Olive Garden. The atmosphere and decor of this branch is true Tuscan. All-in-all we had a wonderful dining experience.
8. Bistro 11
Overall Ratings
4 based on 149 reviews
Reviewed By DownEast47
We enjoy bringing friends to Bistro 11. However, it can be noisy, making it difficult to hold a conversation ... even if you're a "young senior." On our recent visit, we booked a later reservation, so toward the end of our dinner, it was quieter. Our server was a joy - funny and yet professional and helpful.The food is always delicious!! On Saturday I enjoyed your salmon special - delectable; not overdone! The veggies were done just right; even the summer squash which can tend to be overcooked when paired with other veggies.I don't recall that you had Finger Lakes wines on your wine list - at least not a white. After all, the Finger Lakes Region was voted #1 in the USA again this year. How about supporting our local wineries - a treasure!
7. Perinton Pizza
Overall Ratings
3 based on 25 reviews
Perinton Pizza Emporium offers you a completely original take on the pizza pie with some of the most unique combinations in Fairport. Our mouth-watering pizza lineup starts with the 9" small, moving up to the 18" large". Some of our specialty pizzas inclu
Reviewed By Hex585
We have been ordering for delivery and pickup from Perinton Pizza for well over 15 years. They had great food choices and their sauces were great. Lately their sauces have become too salty for our tastes. Looking for another Pizza place in Fairport.
6. Prosecco Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 102 reviews
Prosecco Italian Restaurant & Jazz Bar is one of the best choices if your looking for an authentic Italian restaurant in the Finger Lakes Region. We are located in Farmington, NY on Route 332, just a short drive from Exit 44 on the New York State Thruway.
Reviewed By tcimike
Enjoyed a family get together to celebrate a family birthday. Lively happy hour bar experience to enjoy a toast before sitting down for dinner. Often there is live music on Fridays which adds to the overall experience. Shared the Sicilian calamari and arancini (mini risotto balls with bacon and leeks).Enjoyed the warm signature bread right out of the oven- delicious! Evening specials are not to be missed in addition to the expansive menu. Table selections included blue crab stuffed homemade ravioli, gnocchi with vodka sauce with scallops, veal marsala, meat balls and arugula caprese salad and pork shank special. Mini cannoli to celebrate birthday Italian style.Brittany our personable waitress added to our very enjoyable evening with her attention and warmness. Have enjoyed this restaurant many times with friends and family. Food is always consistent along with the service.Mike, thank you for choosing to celebrate with us! We hope that everyone enjoyed the Sicilian calamari and arancini with our house bread. We're lucky to have such loyal customers like yourself, and we hope to continue to serve you for many years to come. We'll see you next time!
5. Mark's Pizzeria
Reviewed By _vacation_dreamer_SB
Mark's pizza is surpassed only by the outstanding attention to customer service. Pros include: large menu, fresh ingredients, excellent on-line ordering service, respectful and informed employees, fair prices, and access to coupons.Only con is it is very difficult to make a left out of their parking lot.
4. Mr. Dominic's on Main
Overall Ratings
4 based on 278 reviews
Reviewed By Elliemae2828
We ate here for the first time. Calamari was hot and crispy, delicious. Salads were okay, bread was too. I had chicken saltimboca with rigatoni. It was very good. My husband had blackened swordfish with rigatoni, he enjoyed it. The waitress was fine, friendly and helpful. The only problem was the party of 6 seated next to us, with one loud, obnoxious drunk being in charge. He kept telling the waitress to take care of them and she would get 35% tip. Wow, arenât you impressed, or so we were supposed to be. I donât know what the restaurant could do, but it clearly was spoiling our meal and several other tables too. Will go back, but hope the drunk is elsewhere.
3. TK's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 67 reviews
When you're in the mood for a slice of pizza that will overtake your mouth with the robust flavors of fresh tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and hints of garlic and Italian spices, visit the finest pizza place in Fairport, NY. TK's Pizzeria is the place to go
Reviewed By Jerold J
T K's has been our favorite for many years. We get pizza from all the other places, but keep coming back to T K's because we like it the best.Although there is seating, the interior isn't much. I'll stop in for lunch if by myself but otherwise we use them for takeout.I've read a couple of comments about the owner being rude. He is matter-of-fact, and maybe a bit blunt, but I've never considered him rude. He is hard working and extremely fair. One time I came in at the tail end of lunch service (they close immediately after until evening) and he was done serving. He had a couple of slices left but just gave them to me because they'd been sitting for a bit. Anyway, great spot, give them a try.
Where to eat American food in Macedon: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Otto Tomotto's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 320 reviews
Reviewed By naivancygg
Love the atmosphere. Many antiques, quiet corner for dining, wonderful wait staff. The service was quick but not rushed. An old fashion stove greets you when you walk in...a trip to yesterday when life was simpler. That's how I feel when I go there; no rushed, just ready to enjoy a good meal
1. Mozzeroni's Pizza & Pasta
Overall Ratings
3 based on 9 reviews
Reviewed By Larry W
I stopped into this local sub/pizza shop yesterday as I was passing through Macedon. I wanted lunch "on-the-go," and was hoping for something as good as this stores predecessor, the old "Shell's" sub shop. What I found was OK, but not up to that level, at least not yet. The place is still relatively new, although it's been open long enough that it should have had the kinks worked out already.The staff who took my order seemed a bit confused by my request (a chicken-salad wrap), which they apparently didn't have, which wasn't a problem. But the two people up on the ordering station did have to consult the chef a few times,which made me think that perhaps he was the supervisor, which he wasn't. When I changed my order to a "club wrap," they all seemed confused by his question (the chef's) about "what kind of club sandwich?" No worries...they did get it straightened out. But then the chef made me wonder even more as he spent a few minutes reading the instruction sheet on how to make the wrap,which didn't seem like that tough a topic.I took my wrap to go, along with a soda, and ate it in the car. The contents of the wrap itself were pretty good; nice mixture of turkey, bacon, lettuce & mayo. But the actual wrap (the flour tortilla, or whatever it is that holds it together) tasted funky...just not good. I don't know if the whole wheat flour in the wraps had gone rancid, but I found myself eating around most of the wrap itself, and not eating the ends. BTW, the service itself was OK...friendly and intent on getting me what I wanted.Overall, the wrap contents were good, but the wrap itself was not. It wasn't the cheapest of wraps, either, as the wrap and the soda came to about $11.00. It was edible, but I probably won't go back there.
