Location: Highlands
Top Restaurants in Highlands
Top Things to do in Highlands
Countries
Where to eat Italian food in Highlands: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Highlands. Highlands is a borough in Monmouth County, New Jersey, United States. As of the 2010 United States Census, the borough's population was 5,005, reflecting a decline of 92 (-1.8%) from the 5,097 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn increased by 248 (+5.1%) from the 4,849 counted in the 1990 Census. It is the home town of film maker, director, and comic book writer Kevin Smith. The eastern part of the town is built on a high bluff that overlooks Sandy Hook and the Atlantic Ocean, from which the borough derives its name. Atop this bluff are the Navesink Twin Lights.
Things to do in Highlands
10. Chiafullo's Navesink
Reviewed By njphilly
You must visit this place, it's sweet as well as a BYOB. Homemade fresh food, I had the Vodka Penne with sundried tomatoes it was verryyyyyyy good, hubby had chicken Parm sandwich. Well your in the area you can visit the scenic route along the ocean and the rest of the area by Sandy Hook. They have a diverse menu along with pizza of course. Great desserts also. Yummy
9. Ristorante Giorgia
Overall Ratings
4 based on 74 reviews
Reviewed By 760billa
Having recently returned from Italy, I was pleasantly surprised to try Ristorante Giorgia for the first time and discover how wonderful their food is. It was very much comparable to the style and quality of food that I have enjoyed in southern Italy. A co-worker who recommended the restaurant to us, suggested that we try any of the specials. We did ... for both appetizers and entrees ... and we were very pleased with our choices. For appetizers, we tried the sausage, swiss chard and white beans and the grilled artichokes over arugula. For entrees, we had the "Sunday Sauce" and the sword fish. All of the dished were very flavorful and cooked to perferction. I have read some of the other reviews on Trip Advisor that commented about poor service. Our server was good and we had no issues. I will say, though, that we had dinner at 5pm on a Sunday when the restaurant was just opening and was not crowded. Based on the food alone, I would recommend giving Ristorante Giorgia a chance (or second chance) and hope that their issues with service are behind them.
8. Taliercios
Overall Ratings
5 based on 108 reviews
Reviewed By 1109RandyS
This is THE best italian deli in the area. The sandwiches are enormous. The bread is fresh. Most of their business is catering for events. We order here all the time for small gatherings when we need food. Everything they make is outstanding. Its a no brainer. If you live in the area and have not tried this place, do yourself a favor and stop in.
7. Maria's Pizza & Restaurant
Reviewed By jerseygirl339
We ordered takeout for delivery to beach in highlands. They delivered it as we sat around our bonfire celebrating a hurricane that wouldn't come. We ordered a square pie, calamari, cavitteli and broccoli, mussels and pepperoni bread. Everything was delicious and fresh. High quality Italian food and great pizza. Now my go to place for pizza and takeout.
6. Il Lago
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By 201Ang
We have been here twice in the last month since we discovered this little gem. The first time we didnât have a reservation but they accomodated us in a reasonable amount of time on a busy Saturday night. The second time, we made a reservation for a special occasion. First of all, the staff is extremely friendly and the service is great. The food is outstanding and consistent in the preparation. The veal is the best anywhere. I am fussy about tender veal and it was so good the first time that I ordered it on the return visit. Aside from all if this, we love the atmosphere! Bravo!!!!!
5. Francesco's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By Lenny O
This is the first time I ordered Pizza from this place. We live in the area since 1984. I tried many Pizza places near me but this one by far is at the bottom of do not buy list. I ordered a large pie half sausage. The pizza was drenched in oil and very soggy. The sausage seemed fake with no taste. The sauce I bet came from a can. I cannot believe people says this place has good pizza. So far Villa Pizza, Bertucci's and Tommy's in Red bank all have good pizza.
Where to eat American food in Highlands: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Undici
Overall Ratings
4 based on 189 reviews
Undici, replete with ancient stone, wood, tile and plaster, is a faithful recreation of a Tuscan farmhouse. The rustic cuisine is curiously reflective of its surroundings. Every effort has been made to source the best of the best ingredients and formidabl
Reviewed By kathleen e
What a fabulous, warm, inviting, beautiful & delicious restaurant....We always sit at the bar to eat, its fun to talk to the bartenders & staff. The service is impeccable there, from the welcome hello to the knowledge of the menu and drink selection and the courtesy with which every patron is treated.
3. Anjelica's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 195 reviews
Reviewed By bluedevils22
WOW!If you are seeking a first class dining experience look no further than Angelicaâs.We enjoyed a birthday celebration at Angelicaâs and it couldnât have been a better evening.Service by Oscar was thoroughly professional-attentive and friendly and not intrusive.There is outside dining in front and down a side alley which must be enjoyable in the spring, summer and early fall-we however ate inside. The only downside of Angelicaâs is the seating is somewhat cramped and loud in the dining room but the service and the food overcome this shortcoming.The pasta, all of the pasta is homemade and is absolutely to die for and can stand alone as a reason to visit. It is truly special with a sauce that is light and not overpowering.Apps to check out include the fresh jersey tomatoes with mozzarella and a roasted cauliflower in a pool of a light cream sauce-Yumm!Main courses were outstanding as well. Grilled Halibut was crispy on the outside yet warm and moist on the inside on a bed of sautéed spinach and pasta. Veal Parm on the bone was special-Huge and almost didnât fit on the plate. Terramisu was heavenly and served on cold plates and was also to die for.Angelicaâs is BYOB with parking on the street and across from a municipal parking lot. Spring Lake has a hip upbeat street vibe which was nice for a walk after dinner.Reservations are a must-at least a month in advance for the weekend so plan ahead.Angelicaâs is not cheap by any means but donât let that dissuade you! Special experiences are special for a reason. Angelicaâs is absolutely worth every penny.
Most Popular Seafood food in Highlands, New Jersey, United States
2. Christines Italian
Overall Ratings
4 based on 109 reviews
Reviewed By kazu79
Early Motherâs Day outing. Owner Ron was so welcoming. Food was perfect portions were more than enough. Servers were outstanding! BYOB but offers a delivery service from local store if you forget. Canât believe I missed this all these years. Will be back!
1. Porcini
Overall Ratings
4 based on 83 reviews
Chef Chris Atamian is preparing some of the best Italian-American cuisine at the Jersey Shore. Utilizing local ingredients such as freshly caught seafood and Jersey tomatoes, a meal at Porcini Italian Trattoria is sure to impress. Our BYOB is cozy and wel
Reviewed By Joe D
A small italian restaurant (BYOB) in the Highlands. Apps; wife had a shrimp bisque that was good. I had a salad of Jersey tomatoes, cucumbers and cubes of bread (quite good). Wife had an entree of scallops which she loved. I had a duck special - the slices of duck were like steak and a quarter duck as well. It was the best duck dish I have ever had. Dessert was a warm apple pie with gelato. Will definitely come back for another visit.
Best Brew Pub food near Highlands, New Jersey, United States
