Location: Dyer
Top Restaurants in Dyer
Top Things to do in Dyer
Countries
Where to eat Italian food in Dyer: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Dyer, Indiana, United States. Dyer is a town in St. John Township, Lake County, Indiana, United States. The population was 16,390 at the 2010 census. It is a southeastern suburb of Chicago.
Things to do in Dyer
10. Beggars Pizza
Overall Ratings
3 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By Martha D
When this place first opened up the food was decent enough and the prices were reasonable. Well all that has changed. The quality of the food is not as good and the prices have soared. They want 15.99 for a hunk of lasagna and then if you want anything with it like say "a salad" they charge 2.99 extra. Come On!!...that is just outrageous..we have a lot better Italian choices in Dyer,Schererville to choose from for Beggars to get away with this. We will not be dining here again!
9. Pepino's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 47 reviews
Reviewed By yogajane07
I canât say enough about Pepinoâs, they are amazing. The beef sandwiches and combos on garlic bread, sweet peppers and cheese, sweet potato fries, couldnât make us happier for dinner. The sandwich is so large (and yummy) we can only eat half and then you get an amazing lunch the next day. The pizza is really good as well, but the beef is the star in our books. You can dine in or carry out. You can even order ahead, itâs all good. Make sure you get there, you wonât regret it. FYI they are closed on Mondays.Enjoy!
8. Svagati ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By Mary M
Myself and a friend of mine do "dinner of the month" so we chose Svagati as our place of choice yesterday evening. The restaurant is on a smaller scale located in a strip mall in Dyer. Well appointed with about 12 tables the interior was well decorated and cozy. The menu was "extensive" so it took us a while to make a choice. Wines are abundant and the bread and oil was fantastic. Server was very attentive and the food was brought "in the right timing" and was delicious and hot. If you like to eat in a quiet atmosphere with a lot of ambiance, I might suggest you give this place a try. Owner, Tony, did come by our table to check on us and tell us that he makes everything from scratch. Nice personal attention. Try it sometime!Mary M.Hobart, IN
7. Aurelio's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 48 reviews
What sets Aurelio's apart from other Chicago-style pizza? We're different because we use only quality ingredients, serve a variety of generous sizes, and specialize in customizing orders to suit each individual taste. Since 1959, the Aurelio family has be
Reviewed By MarthaWK
Very disappointing for an Aurelio's. The place was dark and poorly lit. The environment was not friendly when we arrived. After being seated the waitress was too distracted by other things going on to even look at us while she was taking out order. The wings were raw. The mozzarella sticks were cold. The food then took forever and they were almost wanting to kick us out while we were eating because it was getting close to closing. No worries as we won't be back.
6. State Line Pizza II
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By Edelweiss122112
Whenever we visit my family in Indiana we try to work in some Stateline Pizza. It is delicious. Also, good pasta and salads. I also really appreciate their service. They have always been accommodating to our special requests (we have highly specific pizza requests and a few vegan requests to work around) .
5. Sanfrantello's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 26 reviews
Reviewed By willie35
This is our favorite pizza place in the area. Fair prices and tasty food. I should try their other food but the pizza is so good that it's the only thing I order.
4. Cafe Borgia
Overall Ratings
4 based on 208 reviews
Established in 1986, Cafe Borgia features the Italian specialties of Chef-owner Mike Jesso. A popular meeting place in Chicagoland, this northwest Indiana eatery is known for homemade menu offerings in an artistic atmosphere. With high praise for it's win
Reviewed By juliemann2016
If you leave this restaurant hungry, it's your fault. Our waitress was Jules who was fantastic! One person ordered the eggplant parmesan while I ordered the shrimp and shells. Both dishes came out hot, fresh and huge. Plenty to share!! I tried the Blueberry Martini which was delicious and sweet, after which I tried another drink that had rum in it and was beachy-I cannot remember the drink name. Our complimentary bread and butter was warm and never empty. Our table was kept clean, empty dishes and glasses were removed promptly. We sat in the bar area, but the big seating room was very whimsical with the different lights and artwork. One area they need to advertise more is their outdoor seating. I know that I look for that in a restaurant because I like to sit outside. The only issue is that this restaurant does not do separate checks which is inconvenient. The day after and I'm still full!
3. Tomato Bar Pizza Bakery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 139 reviews
Reviewed By LauraAgardy
Decent beer selection, wide variety of sandwiches, appetizers, and salads, and premium specialty pizzas cooked to perfection....one word- YUM. If you are a pesto and veggie lover, they have a pizza called Magic Potion that's amazing. It traditionally comes with sausage, but my mom doesn't eat meat, so she orders the pizza without the sausage every time we go. It is so dang good....great. Now I'm hungry. Hahaha, well at least I know what I am doing for dinner tonight!
2. Giuseppe's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 214 reviews
We are proud to offer authentic Neapolitan pizza here in North-West-Indiana. Our Staff has been trained by an Italian Master Pizza Chef with over 30 years of expertise. The 19th Century recipe begins with pizza dough that is made with Imported Italian flo
Reviewed By 881joel
My wife and I were in the area and stumbled upon this place. All I could say is wow! When we walked in I knew we were going to love it. The decor and the atmosphere were wonderful the service was outstanding and the food was awesome. We had Pizza and raviolis with meatballs they were both delicious. I can't wait to try it out again.
1. Little Italy
Overall Ratings
4 based on 132 reviews
Reviewed By Robin R
Very tasty Italian food served in either small or large plates. The small plates can easily feed two while the large can feed four! Dinners come with bread, salad and baked ziti. We had shrimp and spinach Alfredo, crispy pork shoulder, penne and sausage al la vodka and sausage and peppers. All were excellent and more than enough to feed eight adults. Would definitely go back.
