Location: Caldwell
Top Restaurants in Caldwell
Countries
Where to eat Italian food in Caldwell: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Caldwell. Caldwell is a borough located in northwestern Essex County, New Jersey, about 16 miles (26 km) outside of New York City and 6 miles west of Newark. As of the 2010 United States Census, the borough's population was 7,822, reflecting an increase of 238 (+3.1%) from the 7,584 counted in the 2000 Census, which had in turn increased by 35 (+0.5%) from the 7,549 counted in the 1990 Census.
Things to do in Caldwell
10. Russillo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 51 reviews
Reviewed By Resort355128
We first came here in February and we really pleased. We ate this evening and food just gets better and better. The clans casino were delicious. We each had the veal princepesa and enjoyed it tremendously. The servers are wonderful and the owner very friendly and gracious. A wonderful find.
9. Primavera Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 115 reviews
Reviewed By Sunshine34500
Great go-to place for everyone. Noisy, vibrant crowd. and large crowds- especially families visiting their children, etc....Huge Menu, Specials, Signature Drinks, Bar Scene, High Chairs. Totally committed to customer service the minute you enter the restaurant.Very popular for bridal and baby showers and all kinds of events.
8. La Familia Ristorante and Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 29 reviews
Reviewed By AnAnthropologist
From the street this looks like a storefront pizzeria, especially because of the painted chef statute out front. Inside it is actually a well decorated white tablecloth restaurant with good ambiance, food and service. My husband started with calamari and I had eggplant rollatini. Then I had shrimp francese and my husband had shrimp fra diavolo. Everything was well made. The Wednesday evening we visited there was pleasant live music which wasn't too loud.
7. Stephanie's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 56 reviews
Fish is always fresh. Great presentations. . Great Hosts. . . . delicious food and nice portion sizes.
Reviewed By fscornavacca
We moved into the area about 5 years ago. Stgephanie's was one of the early restaurants we tried. We were impressed with good food, good service, pleasant staff. We have been back many times over both for lunch and dinner and have never been dissappointed. This is a BYOB restaurant. The menu is varied and creative without going crazy as seems to be the case in many restaurants these days. The food is consistantly excellent with a nice variety of seafood, veal, chicken, and other meats in both northern and southern Italian styles. If you decide to visit Stephanie's, I would suggest that you make a reservation particulary on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday as it can get quite crowded.
6. Tony D's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By AnAnthropologist
We have been ordering from Tony D's for several years and always ordered the wild mushroom or the sausage and Gorgonzola which are always terrific but last week decided to try something different. We ordered the vegetable pizza which is a square pizza cut into squares but the crust was thin and delicious and my preference. Not a thick Sicilian crust which is typical for a square pie. The vegetables- zucchini and roasted pepper- were perfectly cooked and the cheese and sauce were perfect as well. Be aware for planning purposes that there is usually a wait- sometimes 45 minutes or more for take out- but it is always worth it.
5. Angeloni's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 104 reviews
Reviewed By Sunshine34500
Great meal with those garlic knots. Large skinny pizza and then Homemade gnocchi covered in cheese. Pasta with bolognese sauce and lobster ravioli. Finished with famous signature coconut cream pit and cappuccino. Crowded as usual. Service was a tad off but still a wonderful evening over the raucous loud crowd.
4. Forte Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 95 reviews
Reviewed By SusanK815
My husband, daughter and I have birthdays all within 3 weeks. We took our immediate family here for dinner Saturday. They were very accommodating. We split 2 ginger calamari and one regular marinara. We had 1 Chicken Margherita, 3 Chicken Giambotta, 2 Chicken Francese,1 Chicken Piccata, 1 Calzone and a hot dog. Everything was delicious and the waitress Dora, was very helpful. The portions were generous and the prices were reasonable. We will make this our regular Italian Restaurant.
3. Calandra's Bakery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 191 reviews
The Calandra Family welcomes you to "Calandras Italian Village". The Calandras passion for their Italian heritage and the importance of family values and traditions is evident throughout the "Villaggio Italiano.â Experience the old world atmosphere with E
Reviewed By paul3776
Calandraâs is a huge building housing an upscale Italian restaurant, deli, pizzeria and bakery. The bread is historically known for itâs quality and crispness, the pizza is equally well known, the deli serves hot and cold sandwiches, paninis, wraps & salads and the restaurant which we did not visit is a full service, white table cloth restaurant with a full bar.
Most Popular Pub food in Caldwell, New Jersey, United States
2. Dough Artisan Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 104 reviews
At Dough, we have a deeply rooted passion for hand-crafted cuisine. Our philosophy means sourcing the finest & freshest local ingredients to provide our patrons with an authentic dining experience. We are proud to partner with local farmers & promote sust
Reviewed By Saint100
Really tasty wood fired pizzas made from quality ingredients. Friedly and helpful staff. Unfortunately will not be back as we are visiting from the UK. Mores the pity, as I could easily have become a regular here.
1. Divina Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 84 reviews
Reviewed By Robert H R
Divina isnât much to look at, but everything going on inside makes you smile. The staff is unfailingly cheerful and enthusiastic, the menu offers lots of traditional choices and the food is well-prepared. Nothing creative â but thatâs the whole point of this place. You know what to expect and you get it!We always smile while weâre here, and so does everyone else.
