Location: Boardman
Top Restaurants in Boardman
Top Things to do in Boardman
- 1. Fellows Riverside Gardens
- 2. Mill Creek Park
- 3. Vintage VanBlair Antiques and Oddities
- 4. White House Fruit Farm Inc.
- 5. Vintage Estate Wine & Beer
- 6. Mr. Darby's Antique & Collectible Emporium
- 7. The Butler Institute of American Art
- 8. Slammin' Sams' Stagecoach
- 9. Mill Creek Golf Course
- 10. Lanterman's Mill
Countries
Where to eat Italian food in Boardman: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Boardman, Youngstown, Ohio. Boardman is a census-designated place (CDP) in Boardman Township, Mahoning County, Ohio, United States, just south of Youngstown. Boardman is one of two major retail hubs in the Mahoning Valley. The population of the CDP was 35,376 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Boardman
10. The Elmton
Overall Ratings
4 based on 101 reviews
Reviewed By tldonal
We absolutely love the Elmton pizza. The crust the cheese and the sauce yum. Tuesday the have a pizza special we usually try to go that night. Everything we have eaten there is delicious. Hubby loves the chicken I love the pasta. Only thing we like but donât get often because sometimes they are soggy instead of crispy is the hot chips. The French onion dip they give you with them is so amazing. If you havenât been to the Elmton you need to make a trip soon.
9. Scarsella's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By Karma203
We went there with extended family for dinner. Its a friendly non pretentious place with tasty fresh food.We were promptly seated and served. I liked their Italian sausage with shells. Meat portions are slightly small. Its a mid range place and you could do a lot worse in Boardman, Ohio. Neighbourhood is a bit sketchy and so you may want to be a bit careful.
8. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
4 based on 86 reviews
Reviewed By michaelkU7381KK
First happy I got seated very quickly but waiting almost 20 minutes for server?Alexa was friendly but not experienced and the long waits showed it. Breadsticks were dry? Seriously toughSalad portion minimum... 3 refills?Mushrooms appetizer was surprising tasty... Very niceFETTUCCINE Alfredo was a disaster!Whoever decided on glue consistenty sauce on nice fettuccine pasta ... GrossNot seasoned at all. No garlic?Asked for olive oil to try and save Breadsticks...Olive Garden.. "Olive"Is in your name.. Gave me vegetable oil?That's just idioticIn this area alot of choices.. Skip this dump
7. Cafe 422
Overall Ratings
4 based on 101 reviews
Reviewed By dichuck
On Dec 23 we were a group of 30 people using a private room and a catering menu. The process from planning stage till our evening was finished could not have gone more smoothly. We had friendly assistance from all we had contact with. Our servers Jordan and Chris were extremely friendly and helpful, they could not have done more. Everyone enjoyed their food and the atmosphere. We recommend if you need a place for an enjoyable experience.
6. Johnny's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 84 reviews
Reviewed By Mary C
We were part of a graduation celebration with a small family gathering. We were each able to order from the menu despite 20 people. I find that so accommodating. Both my husband and I were very pleased with our food. I had a simple fish dish and my husband ordered the salmon. Very good on both parts. And those around us were enjoying filet tips, chicken marsala, and a shrimp pasta dish, as well as a dish I think was called Chicken Victoria; smothered in a delicious sauce. No one was disappointed. And the service for 20 of us was very nice. Great place; I have never been disappointed here.
5. Boardman Belleria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 37 reviews
Reviewed By SMartinchalk
Fantastic meatballs! All of the food my group of five ordered was delicious! The servings were generous. (We all took home extras.)
4. Aqua Pazzo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By 772paml
Our first visit was very pleasant. The food was very good. We started with the caprese. Never had the mozzarella warm before.....excellent!! The rigatoni with fennel sausage and broccolini was very good. The warm butter cake with ice cream and sliced strawberries was fantastic !! Tuesday is $10 pasta. Our waitress, Lisa, was great.
3. Caffe' Capri Italian Bar & Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 136 reviews
Reviewed By QuakerCowboy
We were at Caffe Capri on a Saturday night. The place is a very comfortable, family owned Italian food restaurant. We have been coming here for years and truly enjoy the dishes using their proprietary red sauce. They have an extensive menu and we enjoy the pasta, braciole, Italian Eggrolls and Bruschetta. They offer a good cocktail selection and a good wine menu (as you would expect in an Italian restaurant). The hostess is always very pleasant and we were served by Allison. She is friendly, efficient and offers suggestions without being too aggressive. The bar side has TV sets if you want to catch Saturday night college football games or the restaurant side is also very pleasant with good seating.
2. Michael Alberini's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 134 reviews
Reviewed By YankeeBell
Came here for our anniversary. Beautiful atmosphere. Lamp lollipops were excellent, however, we were disappointed in our main course. I ordered the baseball sirloin. The meat was tough and dry. My green beans had no flavor whatsoever, neither did my steak. My husband had the cherry medallions. Although they were tender, his lacked flavor as well. Mashed potatoes and the cherry sauce was great. But would have liked to have at least 3 medallions for what we paid for the entree. Would have loved my steak to be as well seasoned as the lamp lollipops. For what we paid for our dinner, it did not meet my expectations. The service, however, was excellent!
Most Popular Mediterranean food in Boardman, Youngstown, Ohio
1. Nicolinniâs
Overall Ratings
4 based on 226 reviews
Reviewed By Allen M
Visited for the first time with another couple on a busy Saturday night. We all absolutely loved our dinners and we didn't even order Italian. Two of us had the stuffed chicken with mashed potatoes and a sherry with Portobello mushrooms gravy accompanied by asparagus. It was superb. The other two had the Salmon and were equally pleased. I look forward to returning again soon and we are a couple that eat out quite often.
