Location: Bellport
Top Restaurants in Bellport
Top Things to do in Bellport
- 1. Fire Island National Seashore
- 2. William Floyd Estate
- 3. Holtsville Ecology Site
- 4. TWA Flight 800 International Memorial
- 5. Corey Beach
- 6. The Gateway - The Performing Arts Center of Suffolk County
- 7. Long Island SUP
- 8. The Escape Room Game Long Island
- 9. Long Island Jet Ski Rentals
- 10. Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts
Countries
Where to eat Italian food in Bellport: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Bellport. Bellport is a village in Suffolk County, New York, United States. The population was 2,084 at the 2010 census. The village is named after the Bell family, early settlers of the area. The public education system in Bellport makes up the South Country Central School District consisting of six schools, three elementary schools (Kindergarten – grade 3), Frank P. Long Intermediate School (grades 4–5), Bellport Middle School (grades 6–8) and Bellport High School. Bellport is in the town of Brookhaven and is on the South Shore of Long Island. The village is officially known as the Incorporated Village of Bellport.
Things to do in Bellport
10. Onofrio's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 30 reviews
Reviewed By momoboosh
Their pizza is not exactly your tradition pizzeria pie, but it is fantastic. A crispier, buttery crust that reminds me of a deep dish without the thickness. I recommend ordering a meatball/pepperoni pie with extra sauce (or as they call it "juicy") Add a house salad with their amazing garlicky creamy Italian dressing. Incredible combo.
9. Sicilia D'oro Family Restaurnt
Overall Ratings
3 based on 25 reviews
Reviewed By MissDRC
We really enjoy veal and there are not too many restaurants that offer it. The veal here was excellent. Large portions. The garlic rolls are the best, served warm from the oven. The ricotta cheesecake tasted like grandma used to make.
8. Delfiore
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By BullyLover2
When in Patchogue always looking for a great hoagie. Tried the Italian at Delfiore and it was very, very, good - loaded with lots of meats and cheese and the bread was very fresh. They didn't have a Caprese hoagie on their menu but I described what I wanted and they created it for me. I wish I knew the name of the young man that helped me (tall muscular fair and light-haired very friendly) but the owner wad there and he was just as charming as he could be. He make a mean fresh buffalo mozzarella. We'll be back when we're in Patchogue again.
7. La Margherita Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 57 reviews
Reviewed By V5571WHerics
The pizza here is excellent and the staff is friendly and very helpful. Was there recently and saw a slice with some eggplant (which we liked) but the eggplant was not prepared as we would have liked - the gentleman behind the counter was quick to point out they could make a pie exactly as we wanted. We ordered one, as well as a few other pies, and they were all delicious! Definitely recommend!
6. Lombardi's On The Bay
Overall Ratings
3 based on 292 reviews
Reviewed By NYDina
Use to be a favorite however this recent visit revealed disappointing weaknesses. The young boy pouring water had more manners than not just our waiters, but numerous wait staff within the area of the table. I understand this is an Italian restaurant with âauthenticâ feel, but feeling like Joe Pesci was the server was a bit much. The waiter had a dirty apron, forgot some of our order & used a chin flip to acknowledge a request. (Are you getting the idea??). The rib eye was $48., chilean sea bas $32. Al a cart. So I may not return until the management puts some shine on the customer experience.
5. Cafe Gia Pizza & Pasta
Overall Ratings
4 based on 81 reviews
Reviewed By OzzysAngel
This is my 2nd review of Gia's, the 1st written a few years ago. The reason for an updated review is my disappointment in all my visits since. Note: this is for the pizza side only. Saturday afternoon, 4pm. I was a few miles away and my daughter wanted pizza. Upon entering, the counter was pretty bare, and anything resembling pizza was burnt looking and old. It's nice to see the same miserable faces behind the counter. They don't smile or pay attention to you for longer than the few seconds it takes to take your order. They put the pizza in the oven and move on to the next person. Every. Single. Time. I have to ask them to take my food out. If I don't, it gets overcooked, crust burnt. They never give a receipt nor are there signs anywhere telling you how much anything is. Chicken bacon ranch slice? I think he called it? Old, hard chicken, cheddar cheese? And no ranch anywhere. Threw most of it out. The pepperoni pinwheel is always good. And the regular slice was ok. There were no knives or napkins in the dispensers. The garbage was full. The tables and floors were absolutely disgusting. I just stood there waiting for the young girl at the door to stop looking at us and get someone to wipe down a table. She finally looked annoyed enough and did it herself. I wish I could say that it was a one time deal, but the past few times we drove out of our way, it's just been bad. I'm disappointed. I used to love going here. What happened Gia's?
4. Pizza Shoppe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 7 reviews
Reviewed By mikenpat
Super solid regular pizza pie. The pizza has the best taste that I've ever had. I grew up in Nassaul, live in Suffolk and work in NYC and have eaten pizza all over. Trust me this won't let you down. Get it well done with sesame sedds. Also try the Grandma pie for pizza and the wings and baked clams are crazy good. This is my favorite pizza place.
3. Papa Nick's Pizza
Reviewed By Steven B
great pizza for take out or delivery. working over a friends house he ordered some , awesome crust great sauce and cheese plus the gluten free ones are good
2. Cafe Castello
Overall Ratings
4 based on 30 reviews
Reviewed By Suddenly I
Well, we won't return that's for sure. We are very discriminating. On the plus side, the very pleasant, friendly, helpful owner and attentive staff are great. The service is very good. The ambience is like an old-fashioned, inexpensive pizza parlor with tables with traditional, red, checked tablecloths. It is not romantic, though it is a clean, bright, airy space. They are open daily, a boon, as some of the best restaurants in Bellport have limited winter hours now. There is a lot of free parking on the street. The prices are fair. On the negative side, the food is just not that good, except for the delicious, warm bread sticks, which were excellent. The salad is mainly iceberg lettuce with very few other ingredients. One is supposed to use the oil and vinegar on the table, no other salad dressings were offered. The shrimp parmesan was not too good, not many shrimp, with a very thin, non-spicy tomato sauce. The spaghetti was just okay. The desserts were frozen and just okay after they had thawed. All in all. we suggest that you go elsewhere for a truly good meal.
1. Avino's Italian Table
Overall Ratings
4 based on 69 reviews
Reviewed By PATRICIA F
Even though the rooms upstairs were crowed because of our attendance the wait staff was on top of everything. The salad and the baked clams were great and hot. All of the main dishes came within minutes of each others and the portions were large. The chicken was tender and juicy. Will go back there with my husband when we can enjoy the restaurant at more leisure time .
