Location: South Bethany
Countries
Where to Eat in South Bethany: The Best Restaurants and Bars
South Bethany is an incorporated town in Sussex County, Delaware, United States. According to the 2010 census, the population of the town is 449, a decrease of 8.7% over the previous decade. It is part of the Salisbury, Maryland-Delaware Metropolitan Statistical Area.
1. Misaki
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By ThunkWhat - Frederick, Maryland
Hidden in a strip mall next to Grotto Pizza this place is a gem! A must try signature item is Bangkok Dangerous - lump crab, spicy tuna, special sauce heated roll- my advice-- just go there - located just north of Fenwick Island before Bethany proper on the bayside - ask about the Special of the day - impossible to make a disappointing menu choice- stellar service
2. Fishers Popcorn
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 165 reviews
Reviewed By barbara115de - Bethany Beach, Delaware
Fishers popcorn is a family tradition, but fair warning, once you start eating you can’t stop. In the summer you can watch them make the caramel corn. Different flavors are offered including Old Bay seasoning or one with nuts. Bethany is not open all the time off season. You can find Rehoboth Beach and Fenwick island stores have more hours. Save your buckets as when you return you receive $1 off.
3. Off the Hook
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 610 reviews
OFF THE HOOK is located in Bethany Beach, DE. Our menu centers around the "ocean & farm to table" concept. Please come in and enjoy great food and a full beer, wine and liquor selection. * Fresh * honest * local *<br><br>NOTE - the menu on Tripadvisor is outdated and cannot be changed. Go to offthehookbethany . com for the most accurate menus.
Reviewed By barbara115de - Bethany Beach, Delaware
We have been here multiple times for their Monday taco night. This is a deal not to miss. Arrive early or expect to wait in line. This small restaurant has delicious fish/shrimp tacos for $2.00. These are not tiny but good size. Two fill me up. Their Brussels sprouts are yummy as are the other sides if you want more food. Last time my husband ordered the roasted corn,jalapeño crab bisque which was outstanding. Their regular fish entrees have always been well cooked and tasty. The wait staff is friendly, helpful and efficient. Definitely try this restaurant! You won’t be disappointed.
4. Fishers Popcorn
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 214 reviews
Reviewed By travelexplorer27 - Salisbury
We can't make a trip to Ocean City/Fenwick Island without buying some Fishers Caramel Popcorn. It has a taste like no other and I don't mean to be knocking other places, but Fisher's is the BEST! Of course, we start eating it right away and we always buy several containers to bring home to friends. In our opinion, it's worth going to the beach just to get Fisher's Caramel popcorn. They have other flavors, but we like the Caramel, with nuts, the best. Go and enjoy!
5. The Cottage Cafe Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 843 reviews
The Cottage Café is a family restaurant with a full bar that is open 7 days a week year round. We serve Lunch and Dinner every day with a breakfast buffet on the weekends in season and a breakfast buffet on Sundays year round.
Reviewed By mondah54 - Limerick, United States
Had passed many times when staying in Ocean City, MD and thought it looked rather pricey. Decided to give it a try and was not disappointed. Seems like many of the locals have found it a favorite place to dine. Dinner menu was diverse and portions were good. We had the prime rib special and saw many dishes passing our table that looked very interesting. Plan to go there when down there in February.
6. Sunshine Crepes
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 131 reviews
We are a creperie located in downtown Bethany Beach, Delaware. Our origins derive in the Czech Republic where the palačinky have been made for centuries. We opened in 2010 and proudly serve during every summer season. We offer a wide variety of sweet and savory crepes in addition to many tasty drinks as well. See you soon!
Reviewed By Grumpyone88 - Plainfield, Illinois
We discovered this little gem a number of years ago, go two or three times during our week at the beach and are never disappointed in our crepes. We have probably tried every breakfast crepe on the menu. We have introduced numerous friends and family to this restaurant and they all go back. Kids especially love to see their crepes made. Only complaint... it is being discovered too much... small place and hard to get seating!! Fantastic Crepes!!
7. McCabe's Gourmet Market
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 39 reviews
Reviewed By haveticketwilltravel - Vienna, VA
We (3 adults) went to McCabe's to get sandwiches for lunch one day while we were renting a house on Fenwick Island. The sandwiches were freshly made and very good. The selection is limited: deli meats and cheeses and salads. Select meat, cheese, bread, and condiments. Prices for sandwiches are $5.25-$9.95. Make it a platter (potato salad and pickle) for an additional $1.55. There are a few tables in the store and outside on the patio. I ate half my sandwich one day and the other half the next day for lunch, so the price wasn't bad. -- We also bought a large frozen (store made) meat lasagna for dinner that night. It was great. $45.00. -- There were also coffees, bagels, soft drinks, olives, olive oil, fancy napkins and other souvenirs and gifts. It's a nice little store with good specialty foods. I'd go there again. -- It is not where I did my basic grocery shopping for the beach house stay. For that I went to Food Lion or Giant. -- If you want alcoholic beverages in Delaware, you have to go to a liquor store.
8. Jimmy's Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 241 reviews
Reviewed By artie69 - Middleboro, Massachusetts
Fastest service that I've ever had for breakfast. It was a 10min wait for a table but took less than 5mins for our food once we placed our order. All was delicious.
9. Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 100 reviews
Reviewed By Kaitlin S - Arnold, Maryland
This is definitely a go-to beach dessert. It's enticing and easy to access. The prices are reasonable and there are a lot of flavor options.
10. DiFebo's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 358 reviews
DiFebo's is family owned and operated. We are an authentic Italian family serving our family recipes since 1989. We have been awarded the BEST of DELAWARE award many tears running for Best Italian! We are known for our famous meatballs and authentic Red Sauce, Gravy as well as our veal and seafood dishes. We are neighborhood Italian, Coastal Italian and just plain old Authentic Italian!
Reviewed By Dean S - Bethany Beach, Delaware
Usually go to DiFebo's and get great meals and service. But tonight when we arrived, there appeared to be some staffing issue developing. However, that situation didn't last very long. Within minutes the Assistant Manager Sandy stepped in to help with hands-on tasks and Jordan, a waitress, stepped in for the 1st time to bartender.
