Location: Saint Marys
Top Restaurants in Saint Marys
Top Things to do in Saint Marys
Countries
Where to Eat in Saint Marys: The Best Restaurants and Bars
St. Marys is a city in Elk County, Pennsylvania, United States. The population was 13,070 at the 2010 census. Originally a small town inhabited by mostly Bavarian Roman Catholics, it was founded December 8, 1842. It is home to Straub Brewery and the first Benedictine convent in the United States. In 1992, the borough of St. Marys absorbed the surrounding township of Benzinger and incorporated as a city.
Things to do in Saint Marys
1. Casali's Italian Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 50 reviews
Casali's Italian Grille is a family owned and operated restaurant established in 2013. Boasting freshly prepared meals with hand selected and a wide variety of locally purchased ingredients as well as second to none service. Casali's is a great place to come and relax enjoying free wifi, 13 TV's as well as a full service bar with professionally trained bartenders and servers. Casali's best known dishes include Rustic Style Sausage and Peppers, Oak Aged and Marinated Steak Gorgonzola Alfredo, Freshly breaded-to-order Veal Chicken or Eggplant Parmesans, Award Winning Wings as well as many fresh Pub-Style burgers and amazing Signature Salads. With a new amazing lunch menu available before 4pm containing many burgers, wraps, sandwiches and salads there is something for everyone on any budget. Of all the things we offer our staple has been our freshly prepared wedding soup, but there are several other soups and appetizers available as well. Casali's has one of the largest beer selections in the area with over 80 different styles to choose from along with a full service bar and many non-alcoholic drinks to choose from. Casali's is great for groups large and small. We are a great place to host your parties, meetings, seminars and family gatherings. The entire restaurant can be rented for your event. Catering and Delivery is also available with advanced notice and a minimum purchase. (Call for details) Take out is also available. Casali's is a smoke free facility and fully handicap accessible. We hope you come check us out today!!!
Reviewed By Madsim - Mt. Albert, Ontario
It's a sports bar repleat with signed Jerseys on the walls, but don't let that turn you away. The food is great. On a trip with the family including 2 teenagers we ate here last night. Service was prompt and friendly, drinks came quickly and...MoreGreat Advice!!! I agree!!! :-) Thanks for the great review! Please stop in again!
2. D D's Specialty Bakery Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By LazyBum2 - Westboro, MA
After struggling through the free breakfast at Holiday Inn Express, I decided to go here. I was greeted warmly at the counter and ordered typical eggs over easy cooked perfectly with 3 slices of bacon and home made delicious English muffin toast and bottomless coffee. It was so good I went out of my way to go back a second time and had scrumptious french toast again with their bakery bread. Service was super and I would go back in a second.
3. Dairy Queen
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 4 reviews
Reviewed By Mark C
We got ice cream, portions were small for a large ice cream. It was made very skinny tall did not even cover the rim around the cone but the cherry dip was delicious. Tables outside were clean too.
4. Rick's Dough Boys
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 26 reviews
Reviewed By mrpesce - Doylestown, Pennsylvania
Rick's is your average local pizza place. If you've eaten pizza in 'sany other town in the country you've eaten at Rick's. The menu is the same old standards and the pizza is just ok. The one thing that makes Rick's stand out is the decor of the place. It's not like your average pizza place but I want pizza, not cars.
5. Gunners
Overall Ratings
4 based on 89 reviews
Reviewed By Karen G - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
We had a nice meal here at Gunners. The decor is dated but the restaurant is clean. The staff is friendly. I had the carbonara which I enjoyed. I left my credit card there by accident and the staff promptly mailed it tome.We are happy that you were pleased with your experience!!!
6. Village Peddler Country Store
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By Kathy M - State College, Pennsylvania, United States
We visited this cafe while stopping through Saint Mary's. Had a very nice meal. I ordered a lunchtime salad -- greens, orange wedges, craisins, blue cheese crumbles and red vinagrette dressing. It was presented beautifully and was very filling. My husband ordered the special -- meatball sub, which came with melon slices and chips. His was also very good and filling. We would definitely return.
7. Marienstadt Public House Beer Garden
Overall Ratings
5 based on 9 reviews
Reviewed By cissi15905
Small German style restaurant-Beer Garden. Unpretentious. Authentic, and I am very familiar with very good German cuisine-I've been there several times & am also German heritage. Charming with indoor & outdoor seating. This is what you look for when you want to find local flavor & are really tired of the Same-o restaurant chains. We were pleasantly surprised.
8. Don's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 12 reviews
Reviewed By SZQ - Pittsburgh
We ordered delivery from Don's pizza to our hotel in St. Marys.
Our order was accurate and the food arrived hot and ready to eat. You must try their pizza and wings. Delicious, and not overly greasy. My husband enjoyed his hoagie (baked sub) also.
A pleasant surprise while traveling!
9. Merlin's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By Lewis M - Saint Marys, Pennsylvania
Very reasonably priced dining place with a bar. They get your meal out quickly and it's clean. I would take clients there for a meal and feel confident our service would be good and the meal tasty. The atmosphere is uplifting and the dining area decorated with unique quotes painted right into the timber.
10. Tablespoons Cafe & Deli
Overall Ratings
5 based on 6 reviews
Reviewed By Jean Z - Chicago, Illinois
Eclectic, country furnishings, tin walls and ceilings set the atmosphere for this small-town cafe. The food is simple but satisfying: made-to-order sandwiches, salads, soup (especially the local German favorite Spatzle), etc. It's nothing fancy but that's what Saint Marys is all about. The place is a good value; my mom and I had lunch and dessert for less than $25. It's also one of the only places in town where you'll get a good fresh salad. A local bakery, StoryBook Sweets supplies the desserts; the peanut butter brownies were fantastic.
