Location: New Holland
Top Restaurants in New Holland
Countries
Where to eat Dutch food in New Holland: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best Dutch food in New Holland, Pennsylvania, United States. New Holland (Pennsylvania Dutch: Seischwamm) is a borough in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, USA. As of the 2010 United States Census, the population was 5,378, up from 5,092 in the 2000 United States Census.
Things to do in New Holland
10. The Pretzel Haus
Reviewed By TheSushiGuy
I had an amaing fresh squeezed lemonade here. Definitely worth a visit. Next time, I will save room for a pretzel!
9. Katie's Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1075 reviews
Reviewed By PinkCat14
We went because of the excellent reviews but I have to say it was the worst. My pattie melt was flavorless. The bread was soggy and I didn't want french fries, no substitutes. I tried the french fries and they were cold. Since I didn't want them in the first place, I just left them. My husbands bowl of chili was awful. Nothing but tomato and again, no flavor. The fried green beans were sticks of fried breading. With all of the fantastic restaurants there, we were sorry we chose this one. There were a lot of out of state licenses plates in the parking lot, ours included. I didn't even bother taking pictures, we were in and out quickly.
8. Good 'N Plenty Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1502 reviews
At Good 'N Plenty Restaurant, we are pleased to offer our guests family style dining, menu dining, a takeout program, an award winning bake shop and an extensive gift shop. Bring family, friends and neighbors to enjoy our traditional Lancaster County home
Reviewed By 168jamesk
Plenty, yes. Good? No. Wanted to try a âtraditionalâ Amish country lunch over a chain or diner. We opted for the menu seating, vs. all-you-can-eat family dining side. Fried chicken was very average (greasy, dry in the inside, tasteless crust) potato salad too sweet and creamy, pork and sauerkraut more like sauerkraut with a little shredded pork in it. The âchopâ seemed like canned veggies and beans in a sweet vinegar marinade.
7. Miller's Smorgasbord
Overall Ratings
4 based on 2626 reviews
Lancaster PA Restaurant & Smorgasbord 85 years ago... Anna Miller served chicken & waffles to truckers as her husband repaired their rigs. It was a simple dish, but it was always served up with a smile. Today our tried & true recipes may not be as simple,
Reviewed By jmufan24401
Comfortable setting, plenty of room, good home cooked food. Lots of choices for everyone. Salad bars, some seafood, ham, turkey, beef & chicken, Surrounded by fresh breads, vegetables and potatoes. Lots to choose from. Then the desert bar awaits you with fresh pies and many other choices.Open for breakfast, lunch and dinner. A bit pricey at $26 per person though. Beer and wine are available.The service was very attentive and courteous.jmufan24401, Thank you for dining with us! Although we no longer serve breakfast, we are so glad that you were able to join us for lunch or dinner! We love to hear that you savored our scrumptious variety of PA Dutch offerings and enjoyed the atmosphere as well! It was our pleasure to serve you; we look forward to your next visit!
6. Good 'N Plenty Bakery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 269 reviews
Good âN Plenty Restaurant is in the heart of Lancaster County. Choose from three delicious ways to dine: family-style, menu dining, or our ToGO program. Guests love our traditional PA Dutch food and enjoy the family-friendly atmosphere. We have plenty of
Reviewed By elliek753
Too much food! The turkey was my favorite. The nice part of family style people will be more adventurous since they know something else will come along as part of the meal.
5. Bird-in-Hand Family Restaurant & Smorgasbord
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1620 reviews
Smorgasbord buffet, menu dining, and take out meals. Nestled amid the Amish farmlands of Lancaster County, this Mennonite family-owned business features farm fresh meats, poultry, fruits and vegetables from nearby farms and Grandma Smucker's favorite Penn
Reviewed By creativewoods
My wife & I stopped in for dinner before heading home on our two hour trip. We were extremely hungry. We decided to stop here because the parking lot was crouded and we thought the food must be good and affordably priced. We were wrong on both thoughts. We would have been better stopping at McDonald's or Burger King.Dear creativewoods, thank you for telling us about your experience. I am sorry that you did not enjoy our establishment. We prepare nearly all of our dishes from scratch while sourcing local ingredients within a few miles of our restaurant so we couldnât be more different from a Burger King or McDonaldâs.
4. Smokehouse BBQ and Brews
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1261 reviews
A fun new dining experience featuring slow-smoked meats, killer sides, house-made sauces, sandwiches & salads, craft beers, locally made wines and cocktails. We also feature traditional Lancaster County dishes, including our famous Build-Your-Own-Feast.
Reviewed By Jack F
My wife and I must have driven past this restaurant 200 times over the years but when we checked into out current hotel we received a list of recommended area restaurants and Smokehouse was on that list.We had a long ride due to traffic so instead of dining out we decided to have takeaway and relax in our room. . We drove to Smokehouse and their menu was rather small but ample. I asked the lady taking out order what she would recommend and she immediately responded...The brisket. I love brisket so I'll take it. My wife asked for a second suggestion and she said the turkey is also very good. My wife went with the turkey. The sides selection is ok, I went with the fries and applesauce . My wife went with coleslaw and corn fritters. My brisket was very dry and the small portion of gravy wasn't enough. More gravy would have saved my brisket because it was tasty but very dry. My fries were average fried frozen fries. The applesauce was definitely out of a jar. My wife said her turkey was good but the sides were not very good. The coleslaw was the mass produces slaw available in every market. BLAH! The corn fritters were very good. I tasted one and it was good. Considering the many, many very good restaurants in that area I don't think we will return to the Smokehouse..Jack F, Thank you for giving us a try and providing us with feedback. I apologize we failed to impress you with your take out meal overall, but am glad you enjoyed some aspects of your meal.
3. Dienner's Country Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 2021 reviews
Reviewed By rebeccasU86SB
We ate here twice, for dinner and for breakfast. The sticky buns at breakfast were awesome. The rest of the breakfast buffet was just okay, nothing special. They have a dinner buffet, but we opted to order from the menu. My burger wasnât that good - meat seemed to be a pre-prepared patty out of the freezer. My sweet potato fries were good and my husband said his beef and mashed potatoes and gravy was okay. If you like buffets try Dienners. Because of the sticky buns we give them 4 stars. Since we didnât have the dinner buffet, we canât rate that feature.We are so sorry to see you did not have the best possible experience at our restaurant. We are glad to see you enjoyed the sticky buns so much. Thanks for giving us a try and taking the time to share your feedback. We hope you have a great day.
2. The Olde Mill Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 563 reviews
Olde Mill Restaurant is committed to celebrating the history, heritage and hospitality that have been a part of the town of Intercourse in Lancaster, PA for more than 200 years. Their combination of delicious homemade food, incredibly friendly staff and
Reviewed By lather66
First visit while in area. Limited menu. I had meatloaf which had sausage in it, menu did not mention that. I do not like sausage. Bread filling was nothing but grilled potato bread cubed, no flavor. I swear the "mashed potatoes " were leftover baked potatoes, smashed, placed in a mold and dumped on plate. Also did not like. Husband had fried chicken and said it was good but very salty. Corn fritters and iced tea were good. Server was friendly and efficient. Much better PA Dutch for elsewhere. I would not return Dear Lather66, Thank you for taking the time to offer us your review . I do apologize you did not enjoy your meal with us . I assure you our meatloaf is not made with sausage and our mashed potatoes are made from Yukon gold potatoes and we leave the skin on them. We are please to hear our server was friendly and efficient and I hope you will give us another opportunity to provide you with excellent service and product.
1. Yoder's Restaurant & Buffet
Overall Ratings
4 based on 437 reviews
Reviewed By DENNIS_WJohnstown
Was looking for a good place for a breakfast buffet but all the usual places just didnât sound appealing. Finding Yoderâs restaurant in the advertisements made me want to drive to new Holland and try the restaurant. This place by far in our opinion has the best tasting food in the Lancaster County area. Excellent selection for just about anybody the usual breakfast items plus many breakfast items made fresh to order .Meats, potatoes ,salad bar ,soup incredible desserts I donât know what else you could ask for this was an incredible brunch. If you are not a local like us find it on the map make the trip it will be worth it.
Most Popular American food in New Holland, Pennsylvania, United States
