Top Restaurants in Peaks Island
Countries
Where to eat Bar food in Peaks Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Reviews on Bar food in Peaks Island, Maine, United States including Cockeyed Gull Restaurant, Vena's Fizz House, The Inn On Peaks Island, The North Point, J's Oyster, The Thirsty Pig, The Front Room Restaurant & Bar, Novare Res Bier Cafe, East Ender, Andy's Old Port Pub
Things to do in Peaks Island
10. Andy's Old Port Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 385 reviews
Serving Outstanding Pub Fare from 11AM â 10:30PM Daily Andyâs Old Port Pub is a waterfront watering hole frequented by tourists, islanders, fishermen, music lovers and locals. A tricky little Pub to find. Andyâs menu includes the freshest of fish & chips;
Reviewed By on_to_the_next_pl
Their sign out front says they have the best lobster rolls. I disagree with that statement but they were pretty good. I have had much better but they were decent. A little tough and not all that tasty but ok. A little better than just average but a little less than very good. Sorry we tried! Thank you for trying Andy's Old Port Pub. And thank you for the four stars even though we didn't live up to your expectations. Andy's uses only the most tender knuckle and claw meat - and only Maine lobster - on real butter-grilled rolls. Ours are traditional Maine lobster rolls - so don't compare us to the restaurants using fancy buns and herbs. The fancy buns and herbs are lobster creations - and the are also delicious - but they're not the traditional Maine lobster roll. Thank you again for stopping in.
9. East Ender
Overall Ratings
4 based on 330 reviews
The East Ender offers new American food with bold New England flavors. Chefs Karl Deuben and Bill Leavy . We source products from local farmers and purveyors. Quality local ingredients allow East Ender to create a menu from scratch and present it in an ap
Reviewed By kathy g
So glad the hotel we stayed at recommended East Ender Restaurant. It was exactly what we needed. They took our reservation for 4 and made it easy to reconfirm or cancel if needed. The food was outstanding, very fresh with great subtle flavors. Each of us got something different from cheeseburgers cooked to order, fried haddock that was fresh and crispy (best one had in Portland), salads and chicken sandwich. We were able to change the food that accompanied the main dishes and to order dishes for the table to share. We ordered extra french fries (which were better than Duck Fat's) brussels sprouts (which were liked by all) and a delicious Asian cole slaw to share for the table. Service was friendly and the food came quickly. Loved the upstairs dining area with a view out the sunny large windows. My party loved the choices in beers, too. The food just felt delicious and healthy at the same time. Liked the location, too.
8. Novare Res Bier Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 263 reviews
Reviewed By Karen C
If you want to try different beers, especially German, with a huge selection, you need to stop by. It is off the beaten path and has mostly picnic tables for seating inside as well as outside when the weather is nice. The food menu is limited but the pretzels were delicious as was the grilled cheese. The banh mi sandwich was just OK as was their bratwurst. It has a cellar vibe and great local place to stop in for a drink.
7. The Front Room Restaurant & Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 376 reviews
If youâre looking for a great brunch spot in Portland, Maine you have come to the right place! The Front Room offers a variety of affordable dishes that the entire family will love. Chef Lee Harding has dedicated his life to the culinary arts and focuses
Reviewed By Joseph V
My wife, son and fiance stopped in on a referral from some of our son's friends. It is a very cozy, open kitchen setting that smelled terrific even from the street. They have a good selection of local craft beers, drinks and food specials. For appetizers we ordered a Cornbread Pan, Caesar Salad, Arugula and Beet Salad, and Deviled Eggs. All of which were excellent. For dinner my wife ordered a blue plate special which was medalions of Pork Tenderloin with Bacon and Cheddar Red mashed. It was all cooked perfectly but was to salty for her taste and she likes salt. Her son ordered the Short Rib special which was perfect. His fiance ordered the Carbonara which she loved. I ordered the Chicken Pot Pie which is served in a roasting hot cast iron skillet. The presentation was great. However the home made pie crust was about 3/4 burned which I had to scrape off. Frankly I was suprised they served it that burnt. But everyone else was eating and I didn't want to have to wait another half hour for another pot pie, or replacement meal. After cooling the filling a bit I took my first taste. It was thick, creamy, rich in flavor but a little heavy and over powered with Rosemary. As I worked my way into the filling I noticed very little chicken. The few pieces I did find were white meat and very tender. But there was really no more then 3 to 4 fork fulls. Our waiter was marginal at best. He forgot drinks and had to be reminded to bring them. He admitted having forgotten one of our orders and returned to the table to review what we ordered. Thats not really a bad thing, except about 10 minutes had gone by before he realized he only placed 3 orders for a table of 4. Perhaps thats why we waited 45 minutes to be served. But everything was freshly prepared. Lastly he presented us with another tables bill. He was seemingly a nice guy and pleasant enough, but way off the mark that night. Because of these items, to salty, burnt pie crust, sparse chicken, overpowered Rosemary, spotty service, I can only say the food was very good as an average, and really the service was just average. Great place with great ambiance. OK parking if you're willing to walk a few blocks. My wife and I would like to give it another chance. But not an overall excellent experience.
6. The Thirsty Pig
Overall Ratings
4 based on 279 reviews
Beer and Sausage. The two things we do best. Paring our house-made sausages with the best Maine-made beer we can find.
Reviewed By TomJ83
Went on a busy Saturday lunch time, simple ordering system, delicious hot dogs and great beers. Couldn't be better!
5. J's Oyster
Overall Ratings
4 based on 2027 reviews
Reviewed By Twotrainsrunning
Warm and welcoming, crowed and congenial, this is the place for buckets of steamers and a platter of lobster. Try not to come during prime time when the wait could be lengthy. We joined the convivial diners at 5:20 pm and were seated about 10 minutes later. Server was delightful. Huge bucket of steamers (and that was the medium size), 1.25 lobster with corn and more steamers, piping hot and plentiful. Just the type of destination you will find mid Maine but you don't need to drive. Wonderful meal in a perfect setting. Hidden from the tourist crowd, you will need to hunt for this find.
4. The North Point
Overall Ratings
4 based on 225 reviews
A visually exciting, warm, upscale dining and drinking experience, without attitude or pretension. Just delicious, top quality, beautifully presented cuisine, delicious cocktails, excellent wines by the glass or bottle - all very affordable, ten taps feat
Reviewed By Hello420
What a hidden gem. We created our own cheese/meat board and it was AMAZING! The waitress was so helpful and helped curb our board - we went a bit crazy with so many options. No gluten free crackers but who needed them with so much cheese to choose from. The seating was fun and casual and the atmosphere was uplifting. A hidden and unassuming gem. Check it out for sure.So very happy you found us, and that you found plenty of food to enjoy! Just a note for anyone else reading: we do have 100% corn (gluten free) chips which we can substitute for bread points! We're always looking for other gluten free options for crackers and the like, feel free to let us know of any "winners"!Thank you again, we're always happy to hear how happy we've made our guests! See you next time!-dan
What to do and see in Peaks Island, United States: The Best Places and Tips
3. The Inn On Peaks Island
Overall Ratings
4 based on 130 reviews
Reviewed By CS1Portland
We enjoy coming to eat and drink here and will continue. The food is really excellent especially anything with lobster, and we had fabulous lobster salads all around. Fish n chips was good but small portion for lunch. Clams casino also very good but rather high price. Drinks good as well, thank you Shipyard. Thomas was our waiter and he really was terrific. We sat outside on the deck and looked at the view of islands and Portland. Excellent thank you
Peaks Island Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Peaks Island
2. Vena's Fizz House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 264 reviews
Reviewed By CaraMHutchins
We had been years ago and decided to stop back in for some gifts. The owner was so helpful and even handwrite a recipe for a dark and stormy cocktail. We purchased the ingredients and just prepared it at home. It's absolutely delicious. Be sure to find some time to shop and drink at Vena's!
Best Contemporary food near Peaks Island, Maine, United States
1. Cockeyed Gull Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 259 reviews
Waterfront restaurant with a full selection of Lunch and Dinner Appetizers and Entree's many of which feature French and Asian influences, as with all of our menu items our desserts are all made on the premises, Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese frosting, Che
Reviewed By m0ge0
Donât walk past this unassuming restaurant, as they serve up the tastiest and most inventive food on Peaks, hands (webbed feet?) down! Fitting for a drink and appetizer or a full and flavorful dinner with dessert! Great deck overlooking gardens and Casco Bay.
Most Popular American food in Peaks Island, Maine, United States
