Location: Middlebury
Top Restaurants in Middlebury
Top Things to do in Middlebury
- 1. Pumpkinvine Nature Trail
- 2. Dutch Creek Farm Animal Park
- 3. Bonneyville Mill County Park
- 4. Heritage Ridge Creamery
- 5. Hostetler's Hudson Auto Museum
- 6. Old Creamery Antiques
- 7. Blue Gate Theatre
- 8. Krider Nurseries World's Fair Gardens
- 9. Menno-Hof Mennonite - Amish Visitor Center
- 10. Teaberry Wood Products
Countries
Where to eat American food in Middlebury: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Find out what American restaurants to try in Middlebury. Middlebury is a town in Middlebury Township, Elkhart County, Indiana, United States. It is located approximately 35 miles east of South Bend, 130 miles east of Chicago, Illinois and 165 miles north of Indianapolis. Middlebury is nestled in Northern Indiana's Amish country. As of the 2010 census, the town population was 3,420.
Things to do in Middlebury
6. Rulli's
Overall Ratings
3 based on 155 reviews
Reviewed By Chocoholic2660
We've been to Rulli's several times but last night we had "mama's pizza" and it was inspirational! It has a great combination of red onions, chicken, and cheese that is outstanding. They have a Senior menu which we've found helpful also. The bar is separated enough that this is also a family restaurant. Trivia two nights a week. Good variety of sandwiches and entrees with satisfying quantities. Full bar.
5. Aunt Karen's Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 48 reviews
Reviewed By Karen T
After spending the morning at the flea market, my husband and I wanted a cozy place to eat lunch. This hit the spot! Delicious food and homey atmosphere. And a homemade cookie to top it off!
4. Village Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 80 reviews
Reviewed By Consultcinda
Oh my! Three of us went for lunch on a weekday. The restaurant was filled with mostly local people and very fun to see. It looks just like the local places of my childhood hometown. We had biscuits and gravy, scalloped cheese potatoes, and cole slaw. The top off was a piece of lemon creme pie. It was all yummy and worth a stop. Portions weren't so huge that the pie was too much.
3. West On Warren
Overall Ratings
4 based on 39 reviews
Family owned and operated, West on Warren Gallery + Grill is about more than just food and art -- every part of our restaurant is designed to build community. We are dedicated to providing a space where friends and family gather to enjoy the best food and
Reviewed By Msjoannwil
Weâve been to West on Warren numerous times, have seen the changes along the way. Itâs great having choices other than Amish cooking. Service last evening was great, our drinks were prepared properly and promptly. The salmon entree was blackened as requested, excellent. The blackened prime rib sandwich was so good, would have liked more prime rib. It was approximately only 2 oz which is a tad small! There were 4 in our party and we were able to have good conversation without having an intrusive server. He checked on us from time to time. I would love to have more vegetables choices available. Maybe a healthier dessert?
2. 41 Degrees North
Overall Ratings
4 based on 163 reviews
A cozy eatery in downtown Middlebury, IN featuring quality ingredients and made from scratch entrees. Craft beer focus and unique signature cocktails.
Reviewed By 376deej
After reading all of the wonderful reviews on Trip Advisor and other sites, I was really excited to try this restaurant. Middlebury really needs restaurants like this, but the food has to be good. I am hoping that the regular chef was not working the night we were there. If he, or she, was there this restaurant is in trouble. I ordered the Fish tacos, which were tuna tacos. I have had many variations of tuna tacos,at other restaurants, so was prepared for some good tasting food. My husband had a basic black and bleu burger with an upgrade to onion rings. I asked that the tuna be as raw as possible and the waitress assured me they could do that. I received three corn tortillas that were so hard and cardboard-like that I could not eat them, so resorted to just eating the contents. It is like someone left a list of the ingredients that should be in the taco, but neglected to say what to do with them. Each taco contained a huge chunk of way overdone tuna (remember I wanted it as close to raw as possible) that was not shredded or cubed or cut in any way, just a big old hunk of tuna.There was a small slice of avocado, a miniscule 1/4 of a slice of tomato and several small droplets of goat cheese, all at one end of the taco.That was it, no sauce for flavor and no slaw for crunchiness. There was an amazing amount of tuna in the three tacos and I just wish it had been rare and tasty rather than overdone and gray. My husband asked for his hamburger to be medium rare, but came out with the really rare preparation that I wanted on my tuna. So not a good food night overall. If we lived in Middlebury, we would give them another chance.when there hopefully would be a competent chef in charge. For the sake of cuisine in Middlebury, I hope they can make a go of it.
1. Das Dutchman Essenhaus
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1264 reviews
Reviewed By RCSColumbus
This is one of those typical large tourist focused Amish-style restaurants with an attached bakery and gift shop. I don't mean that in a bad way, but if you've seen one, you've pretty much seen them all, and this place certainly meets expectations. Good broasted chicken, lots of choices for side dishes, and good pie, reasonably priced large buffet available for each meal, and friendly, attentive service. The gift shop here is small but has some unique country-style merchandise. This is definitely worth a stop if it's along your route but not worth going out of your way for.Greetings! Thank you for visiting with us and enjoying a meal around our table! We are delighted to receive your review and hope to have the pleasure of welcoming you back again soon.
