Location: Bayfield
Top Restaurants in Bayfield
Top Things to do in Bayfield
Countries
Where to eat American food in Bayfield: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Bayfield, Wisconsin, United States. Bayfield, at the northern tip of Wisconsin, on the shores of Lake Superior, is the main gateway to the Apostle Islands National Lakeshore, a series of pristine islands known as "The Jewels of Lake Superior." Camp, hike, kayak, scuba dive and sail amongst these 21 islands, exploring hidden sea caves, six historic light stations and forgotten ship wrecks. The mainland is a popular destination for art lovers, with a large community of local artisans operating galleries and workshops.
Things to do in Bayfield
10. Wild by Nature Deli
Overall Ratings
4 based on 64 reviews
Wild by Nature Deli is back at our original location at 100 Rittenhouse Ave., with our entrance on 1st street. Serving our signature huge sandwiches, subs, salads and breakfast burritos.
Reviewed By Dogpilot
If your taking onne of the tourboats around the Apostle Islands you may want to get a box lunch from this little deli. Freshly made sandwhiches and salads reasonably priced either made to order or ready to go. Service with a smile and they take credit cards.
9. Portside Bar and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 123 reviews
Portside is located at Port Superior Marina, just two miles south of Bayfield on Highway 13. We're open seasonally - May thru October, when the boats are in the water. We offer casual waterside dining with both indoor and outdoor seating. Our All-American
Reviewed By 2BNKD
We found this place by chance. The hostess seemed to be confused about where to seat us. But not to worry. From then on it was great. Our waitress Dianne was quite the comedian. She was really the best waitress weâve had in a long time. She was very knowledge about the meals and made great recommendations based on my food allergies. I had the walleye. My wife had chicken Marsala. It was very good. We will be back! The scallops were fantastic!
8. Morty's Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 108 reviews
Morty's has a large selection of craft, imported and domestic beers. Combine that with fresh Lake Superior Whitefish, great burgers, fries, sandwiches & appetizers and you begin to see why Morty's in Bayfield is the hot spot for fun. Tell your friends to
Reviewed By Shellymarcus
Stopped here during the week after the sunset cruise. They are open till 9:30 pm. Bar atmosphere with quite a few tables. You seat yourself. Small menu. Waited on right away. Ordered the fried bologna sandwich and it was super good. The whitefish and chips was amazing as well. Very quick food service. Pretty impressive. Average prices for the area. Great food, give it a try.We are so glad you enjoyed your visit!
7. Greunke's First Street Inn & Dining
Overall Ratings
4 based on 507 reviews
Located in the heart of Bayfield, Greunke's has been serving food to locals and visitors alike since 1940. Our fun, funky, and eclectic décor sparks memories for all generations and we are family friendly! Our fabulous staff makes your experience even mor
Reviewed By Beatriz121
When street parking was at a premium, Greunke's parking lot was empty so we decided to stop there for lunch. The place definitely provides a trip back in time. The waitress was quite talkative and we had a chance to look at the memorabilia on the walls (photos, newspaper articles, album covers, and records) while we waited for our lunch to arrive. The food was tasty and portions were larger than what we needed. Of all the things I looked at, the most unforgettable was a collage of items about John Kennedy Jr. and his stay at the inn.
6. Maggie's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 797 reviews
Reviewed By Kate S
Lunch for 5 of us was prompt and delicious. I had a very interesting take on a Caesar salad which was a southwest interpretation with a spicy dressing and tortilla chips. Very good. My colleagues had a vegetarian pizza that they devoured. The service was excellent.
5. Pier Plaza Restaurant & Pickled Herring Lounge
Overall Ratings
4 based on 559 reviews
Reviewed By Becky Z
My family visited this restaurant during a trip to Bayfield in August 2019. Two of us enjoyed the fish & homemade chips, and the other two could not stop raving about the grilled romaine & shrimp salad. Yummy ice cream for dessert. Great service too
4. The Bayfield Inn Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 298 reviews
"Full Service" is back year-round in The Bayfield Inn Lakeside Dining Room. Breakfast, Lunch, & Dinner are served daily with the best view in Bayfield! Our Breakfast menu features classic favorites, and several original regional-inspired dishes. Enjoy a c
Reviewed By TheManagerV
Classic Bayfield. Majority of the crowd wearing t-shirts. Smaller place, so gets crowded early and a little loud. Not formal, but nice decor. Good kidsâ menu. Most tables have a decent view of the water. Service is quick, but very good. You can get fresh Lake Superior trout or whitefish prepared several ways. If you want local, this is your place. Menu was very good. Food was well prepared. Highly recommend.
3. Manypenny Bistro
Overall Ratings
4 based on 200 reviews
American fare with a Turkish flare! Hos geldiniz/Welcome. We are a Full Service Restaurant & Bakery. Our breakfast is the best in the area serving many American classics with a bottomless cup of drip coffee. Choose from our daily baked goods as a treat to
Reviewed By 521jf
Quaint diner vibe is coupled with great service, delicious food and large helpings. There were four of us and each got something different and everyone was super happy! Who ever thought of the build your own breakfast biscuit sandwich is a genius! We would have headed back for a different meal but time didnât allow for that - next trip for sure there will be a return visit.
2. Landmark Restaurant at Old Rittenhouse Inn
Overall Ratings
4 based on 244 reviews
Part of Old Rittenhouse Inn, Le Chateau is a Bayfield, WI bed and breakfast set in historic mansion overlooking Lake Superior. It is an ideal location for romantic getaways in Wisconsin, weddings, and special events. The property features seven guest room
Reviewed By Barrett A
Excellent personable service, both meals, but a small mixup on the dinner order. We had a cocktail out on the porch before dinner. Very nice and comfortable spot in a pleasant breeze. Our orders were taken, we were not hurried in the dining room. It was properly quiet, food was excellent. Heartily recommended for an intimate dinner for two or more. And breakfast was equally so. Wish I had taken away a dozen muffins. And bacon. For the Road.
1. The Copper Trout
Overall Ratings
4 based on 489 reviews
We are a seasonal restaurant in downtown Bayfield, serving fresh fish, gourmet pizza, delicious pasta and Black Angus Beef steaks.
Reviewed By RiceWP
My wife and I came here for dinner because it was recommended to us by the staff of the old Rittenhouse Inn. It was a great choice.While my wife had the spaghetti and meatballs which were very tasty, I think the best value on the menu was the surf and turf. It was a 10 ounce New York strip and fresh whitefish from the lake for only five dollars more van the New York strip by itself. The steak was cooked to perfection and very flavorful.We would certainly come back here again next time we are in town.
