Location: Baileys Harbor
Top Restaurants in Baileys Harbor
Countries
Where to eat American food in Baileys Harbor: The Best Restaurants and Bars
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Baileys Harbor, Wisconsin, United States. Baileys Harbor is a town in Door County, Wisconsin, United States. The population was 1,003 at the 2000 census. The unincorporated community of Peninsula Center is located in the town. The census-designated place of Baileys Harbor is also located with the town.
Things to do in Baileys Harbor
10. Florian II
Overall Ratings
3 based on 109 reviews
Reviewed By Rowing_Queen
Yearning for "supper club" food, we stopped at Florian's in Baileys Harbor. For starters, we were served a generous salad bowl, and a loaf of bread. And of course we all know that Wisconsin Supper Clubs are famous for their Friday Fish Fries, and I could not pass up ordering their perch plate. It was very tasty. It's been a long time since I had a really good perch plate and I'm so glad that I ordered one at Florian's.My friend ordered BBQ pork ribs and he said it was fantastic. He should know, because that is his favorite and he orders ribs a lot!I'd definitely recommend eating at Florian's. The wait staff is friendly and helpful and you can't beat the spectacular view of Lake Michigan!
9. Thyme Cuisine
Overall Ratings
4 based on 48 reviews
Thyme Cuisine is located at the beautiful Maxwelton Braes in Baileys Harbor. Offering casual, gourmet cuisine prepared from the freshest ingredients, sourced locally when available. With a welcoming bar and dining atmosphere, Thyme Cuisine serves breakfas
Reviewed By Calmac3
Driving home from a day at Penninsula State Park and North Point, we decided on the way back to dine at Thyme Cuisine, Located within a golf club. It was quiet, my filet was excellent, prepared exactly as I wanted and my husbandâs wild rice risotto with chicken breast must have been delicious as he scraped the bowl clean. We were seated at a window overlooking the course. Little touches like fresh flowers on every table and big cloth napkins were appreciated. Our server was Nadia and was efficient and friendly; the bartender created us before and after our meal. Great place to dine. Weâll be back!
8. Blue Ox
Overall Ratings
4 based on 74 reviews
Reviewed By doorcountytraveler
This place has not changed much in all the years it has been open and it is pretty dark inside....but we knew they had good cheese burgers there, so we sat out front on the porch and enjoyed them. As they say, "You Can't Judge A Book By It's Cover" and that is true here....I would rate the food at a B+.
7. AC Tap
Overall Ratings
4 based on 69 reviews
Phone: (920) 839-2426
Reviewed By Donna B
This place is a country bar popular with the locals. Their menu offers up a wide variety of food options including burgers, wraps, fish, fried appetizers and soups. Between the four us, we tried a cheeseburger, Philly steak sandwich, Philly chicken sandwiches, French fries and cheese curds - both regular and buffalo style. All the food was served up promptly and fully satisfied our tastebuds. The bar music played as we ate. Atmosphere was rustic. Service was generally good and we would eat here again.
6. Top Deck Restaurant and Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 159 reviews
This restaurant is in the Gordon Lodge complex, but is open to the public.
Reviewed By Millie C
Although the menu is small,there is something for everybody. Some of our favorites: Homemade Blue Cheese Chips, Brussel Sprout Chips and Steak Bites, Margherita Pizza and the Pot Sticker entree. The drink menu is quite extensive and the service top notch. We enjoy sitting on the outdoor deck or at the bar to watch the sunset over beautiful North Bay. The bartender knows his trade!!The only drawback is the noice level. Acoustics are poor and it is too loud for enjoyable conversation.
5. PC Junction
Overall Ratings
4 based on 274 reviews
Reviewed By conanthedestroyer
I had a meal here with my sister, her husband, and two kids. The kids loved the fact that the train delivered the food. The atmosphere is pretty fun and the staff is dedicated, constantly changing the toys that were on the train, and making sure we were well taken care of. The food was good and reasonably priced. The bloody marys were great as well.
4. Peninsula Pub
Overall Ratings
4 based on 149 reviews
Please call for seasonal hours
Reviewed By jennifersH8774IB
I hadbeen on a quest for quite some time for an amazing burger that you can bite into and it will get dripped all over your face. This place take the cake. We had north south east burger, hangover burger the lamb burger, grilled cheese. OMG. Best burger ever!!
3. Baileys Harbor Cornerstone Pub and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 436 reviews
Reviewed By Josieryan
We stopped here to check out Baileyâs Harbor! It didnât disappoint. We had a few drinks served by Tonya... very nice conversation! We then went to have an early dinner. I chose the Think Summer wrap with sweet potato fries. Outstanding! I also got a cup of the black bean soup with sausage... I couldâve had another! The broasted chicken my husband got was outstanding...coleslaw was not good... but overall the rest was great!Hi Josieryan! Thank you for the positive rating. We are so pleased you and your husband enjoyed your time with us!
2. Coyote Roadhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 421 reviews
Reviewed By 920mikeg
Had Quesadillas and they were about the best Ive ever had. Cooked perfect with delicious chunky salsa. It was labor day weekend and we sat outside. Great view under a huge tree with a partial view of Kangaroo lake. Plenty of space out back to occupy you and any children if you have to wait for a table. I'll be back again for sure and maybe just a stop for drinks.
1. Chives Door County
Overall Ratings
4 based on 311 reviews
Reviewed By Lungbuster
This is the meal my wife and I had been looking for during our recent trip to Door County. After several mediocre and less than memorable meals, we hope Chives would live up to our expectations. From the service to the menu selection, Chives did not disappoint. The veal chop I had was spectacular. The veal was cooked perfectly, tender and juicy and the sauce was savory and complimented the meat perfectly. My wife had the shrimp and it too was cooked to perfection. Although the dessert selection was small, both of ours was delicious. Highly recommend
