Top Restaurants in Mexborough
Countries
United Kingdom Food Guide: 5 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Mexborough
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Mexborough including E'Lupo, Goodfellas Italian Restaurant, W Italian Bar and Restaurant, Frankie & Benny's, Trattoria Toscana
1. E'Lupo
Overall Ratings
4 based on 460 reviews
Reviewed By GAIL78
Visited Elupo's. Food good quality but not exceptional. High prices compared to other Italian restaurants serving just as good food and in nicer surroundings outside and inside.Service only average. - not enough staff, therefore having to remind staff to bring condiments by which time food had gone cold. Then had to get up out of seat to fetch them myself as they continued to forget as too short staffed.Saw staff auguing amongst themselves. Girl on the bar decided to shout across the restaurant at a male for something she was unhappy with.Then saw waitress lick the icecream off a spoon she was serving.Overall not impressed.Dear Gail78, Thank you for taking the time to provide us with your feedback. We appreciate that it means a lot to you, having now received it from you more than once, although we do wish that you had given it to us on the night of your visit. Naturally, it can be difficult to spot when an individual is disappointed when we see clean plates and smiling faces. We are pleased that you have commented on our food being good, although we find it difficult to reconcile your comment in connection with our prices, which are at the bottom end of the scale when considered in the context of other, similar types of eatery in the area. We can see that you have reviewed a large chain restaurant more favourably. Big companies with multiple sites who can afford to buy bulk produce which requires less preparation can, and often do, charge less. That isnât what we are though. We pride ourselves on serving freshly prepared, lovingly made and locally sourced authentic food. As for our surroundings, we appreciate that we may not be as fancy as you might be used to. We canât apologise for who we are. Our focus has always been on being friendly and serving good food, not on being fancy. We are a small, family run restaurant and so problems do occur from time to time, especially at peak times, such as weekends when, as you will have witnessed, are always full to capacity. As we explained, we had one staff member less than usual on Saturday due to circumstances beyond our control. These things can and do happen. Thankfully, they happen rarely.Because we are so busy and we have an open kitchen, it can get rather loud at times, especially from the laughter and good conversation that our guests and staff enjoy. They will, at times, need to speak to one another loudly. For over 30 years now we have been serving happy customers, the majority of whom have been very understanding of this. We are sorry that you find yourself in the exception. We arenât sure what condiments you are referring to in your review. All of our condiments are kept in our kitchen and so if you did have to enter the kitchen to get your own, we would be surprised, as customers are not allowed. The only thing that we keep front of house is our rather large pepper mill, which would would certainly have added some heat, if your food had not been to your desired temperature. Finally, we hate to see any unsold desserts go to waste and so we do encourage staff to enjoy a taste of anything delicious that might be going spare from time to time - especially our home made cheesecake on Saturday nights as any fresh dairy items will not keep until we re-open the following week. We are sure you wouldnât deny them that. After all, they have worked exceptionally hard to ensure that we have received the TripAdvisor Certificate of Excellence for five consecutive years and a 5 star hygiene certificate. We think that certainly deserves a sweet treat. Again, we recognise the time that you have taken to leave your comments more than once and we value all of our customers and their feedback. If you feel that you need to repeat anything again, please do telephone us and will be more than happy to listen to your concerns.With very best wishes, The EâLupoâs Family
2. Goodfellas Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
5 based on 372 reviews
Reviewed By pauldeb64
This is our go to restaurant. Lovely owners and staff where nothing is too much trouble. Excellent food with a varied menu and additional specials. House red wine is gorgeous, a little too much if truth be told.Will keep going back. Highly recommended call in you wonât be sorry
Where to eat Seafood food in Mexborough: The Best Restaurants and Bars
3. W Italian Bar and Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 307 reviews
Reviewed By KathrynT
Six of us visited here for dinner on a Saturday night. We all had starters....calamares,prawns,bruschetta,girella,carpaccio beef and mushrooms. My self and my husband had cod loin which was beautiful. Others had monkfish, salmon, and spaghetti carbonara....all looked lovely. One couple shared a very nice looking chocolate dessert too. Plenty of Sauvignon blanc and peroni ....as well as water! Our friends agreed the meal was wonderful.....this being their first visit. Yet again another wonderful meal served by very friendly staff.
4. Frankie & Benny's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 123 reviews
Buzzing with the sound of lively chatter, this restaurant attracts everybody from couples and parties of friends out for good times and great food, to families treating themselves to a night out. In typical Stateside fashion, service at Frankie & Bennyâs
Reviewed By carly87uk
I enjoy coming here for breakfast. The staff are always cheerful & helpful, but do try to sit you close to other people, unless you ask for a quiet table away. I usually have the full english which comes with lovely herbed potatoes. The bacon can be a little too crispy, so if you don't like it crispy, you can just order it less done. You can have unlimited refills on tea & Americano which is handy! Prosecco is also available as there's a bar, which is a nice treat! There is usually some swing music on in the background too which I enjoy & the toilets are modern & clean. Will keep coming back - thank you!
5. Trattoria Toscana
Overall Ratings
4 based on 439 reviews
Reviewed By L1925INsarahl
We've been dining here for about 10 years now.Feelsike family. Dino and the boys are fantastic at what they do. Chef chooses the very best ingredients for his meals especially the steaks.You will not find a nicer, tastier cut of steak anywhere.Great atmosphere and quaint Italian decor.Staff can't do enough for you.Please give Toscana a visit, if you haven't already.Top tip you will need to book if after 7pm.
