Location: Hunter
Top Restaurants in Hunter
Countries
Top 9 Italian food in Hunter, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Hunter, New York, United States. Hunter is a town in Greene County, New York, United States. The population was 2,732 at the 2010 census. The town contains two villages, one named Hunter and the other called Tannersville. The town is on the south border of Greene County.
Things to do in Hunter
9. Messina's LaGriglia Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 105 reviews
Reviewed By Slc498
This restaurant lacked everything. There were only a few tables with people upon my arrival, but they had a hard time deciding which table to give me. When people came after me and the waitress had to choose which table to give them, she often uttered a curse word while deciding where they should sit. At no point was the place more than half full (at any given point there were about 6 tables with people). I was alone, most tables had two people with two waitresses. Almost never could I find my waitress and whenever I did she kept telling me she will be right over to me. At one point, I was tempted to get my own water because I waited about 15 mins with an empty glass but ended up calling over the overwhelmed other waitress dealing with her three tables of people. Food was edible. I got Grandmaâs spaghetti and meatballs but asked for angel hair which I was told was great. Well, andpparently no one wanted to tell grandma her cooking is bad, I couldnât eat most of it. I waited about 25 mins for the check to find out they charged me $2 extra for angel hair. After waiting almost 15 mins for the waitress to return, I finally got up and went to her. She asked the manager what to do about the $2 charge that I was not made aware of. The manager asked if I complained, the waitress said yes, and the manager responded to the waitress that she should tell me to âscrewâ myself but she took it off my bill. Would not be returning here again.Lots of made up drama. it is hard to believe the experience was that bad. Sounds like someone was having a bad day. I am from Coram N.Y 53 Andover Drive right off of Route 112.
8. Neapolis Pizzeria & Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 77 reviews
Reviewed By 158caseyj
Everything is from your Greek/ Italian grandmothers kitchen. Pizza was good, spanakopita was okay (needed more garlic?). Casual dine-in or takeout restaurant with good service (our waitress was so funny!). You could taste the authenticity in the food, nothing processed. Great place to unwind after a long hike.
7. Messina's LaGriglia Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 105 reviews
Reviewed By Slc498
This restaurant lacked everything. There were only a few tables with people upon my arrival, but they had a hard time deciding which table to give me. When people came after me and the waitress had to choose which table to give them, she often uttered a curse word while deciding where they should sit. At no point was the place more than half full (at any given point there were about 6 tables with people). I was alone, most tables had two people with two waitresses. Almost never could I find my waitress and whenever I did she kept telling me she will be right over to me. At one point, I was tempted to get my own water because I waited about 15 mins with an empty glass but ended up calling over the overwhelmed other waitress dealing with her three tables of people. Food was edible. I got Grandmaâs spaghetti and meatballs but asked for angel hair which I was told was great. Well, andpparently no one wanted to tell grandma her cooking is bad, I couldnât eat most of it. I waited about 25 mins for the check to find out they charged me $2 extra for angel hair. After waiting almost 15 mins for the waitress to return, I finally got up and went to her. She asked the manager what to do about the $2 charge that I was not made aware of. The manager asked if I complained, the waitress said yes, and the manager responded to the waitress that she should tell me to âscrewâ myself but she took it off my bill. Would not be returning here again.Lots of made up drama. it is hard to believe the experience was that bad. Sounds like someone was having a bad day. I am from Coram N.Y 53 Andover Drive right off of Route 112.
6. Brandywine of Windham
Overall Ratings
4 based on 115 reviews
Reviewed By isles8083
The brandy wine is a great restaurant. we have been going to this restaurant for many years. It always brings me back to my childhood and many good memories. Now I take my family there every time Iâm in the area. Great food , service and cocktails. You canât go wrong.
5. Millrock Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 136 reviews
Located in the Great Northern Catskills, Millrock is a lively restaurant inspired by Italian traditions and rustic American roots. Millrock opened in the fall of 1996 and is located on historic Main Street Windham. Since then, Millrock has been committed
Reviewed By FromJersey123
My sweetheart and I enjoyed a nice meal our first night in the Catskills. The penne with vodka sauce was fair. It was tasty, but not anything special. We shared a chicken marsala too. That was also tasty, but not unique, exceptionally good or memorable. So, if you're looking for good service with a decent, Italian meal in a casual setting, consider Mill Rock Restaurant. However, don't have high expectations. I've had better Italian food, but I've also had much worse. So, I guess this place was average. However, the waiter was a nice young man and he worked hard and was quite pleasant.
4. Vesuvio Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 164 reviews
Mountain Top Fine Italian Dining Restaurant Proudly Women Owned Business Serving From 4 Decades Makes You feel Home
Reviewed By lunarscape
We stopped for dinner and the place is in disrepair. Maybe they are the process of rebuilding. The staff was extremely rude and seemed to enjoy making travelers feel unwelcome. Do yourself a favor and skip this joint.Thankyou for coming to the restaurant and letting us know what you experienced in my restaurant And I personally apologize for the service. I would like you to come to Restaurant again And would like to offer you a dinner on me please
3. MaMa's Pizza Parlor
Overall Ratings
3 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By stacyb636
We enjoyed this restaurant. The food was excellent, we had the pizza which was a thin crust we love, delicious eggplant w out cheese. Jen is fabulous as waitress, chef, cashier & friendly neighborly conversationalists. We hope the decide to deliver this ski season.
2. Ladoria Ristorante
Overall Ratings
5 based on 117 reviews
Experience the warmth and the European tradition of serving guests as family at Ladoria Ristorante where family memories and food intertwine. Our family has a devotion and passion for utilizing natural fresh ingredients sourced by local farms and purveyor
Reviewed By Zzardvark
There used to be a time when the Catskills were made up of ethnic vacation enclaves, whether Jewish, Italian, German or Irish. Nobody mixed and everyone went to their own. The Villa Vosilla, where Ladoriaâs is located, is an Italian version, and going there is like stepping back into the ethnic 1960s. Itâs like Brooklyn before hipsters, when red sauce and big hair ruled. If youâre comfortable with this, youâll have a good time. If youâre coming up for the new Hudson Valley or to see something at the Orpheum, you might feel out of place.Donât get me wrong, the food is tasty and youâll probably have a good meal. The menu isnât extensive and the choices are what youâd expect, Chicken Marsala, Penne ala Vodka, Eggplant Parmesan. Itâs like a well done Sunday dinner. Part of the reason the reviews are so high is that Ladoria self-selects its crowd and that unfortunately Tannersville is a ski town in the winter and a modest resort in the summer, so there really are fewer good restaurant choices than there should be. The pictures on line make it look much better and much more sophisticated than it is in real life. The outside is completely vinyl sided and you enter under the illuminated sign that says âbarâ. You walk through a gigantic bar and have a choice of rooms that while spotlessly clean, look like Staten Island in the 1960s. We came up to see a dance performance at the Orpheum and when we reserved, expected a new Hudson Valley Italian bistro. When we walked in, we felt it was a mistake and almost walked out.We stayed. The staff was very nice and efficient and the meal was good but it was the type of tasty food we can also get at nearby diners. If youâve got kids and want a family meal, this is a good place. If you want Italian cuisine, eat in Hudson.
1. Messina's LaGriglia Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 105 reviews
Reviewed By Slc498
This restaurant lacked everything. There were only a few tables with people upon my arrival, but they had a hard time deciding which table to give me. When people came after me and the waitress had to choose which table to give them, she often uttered a curse word while deciding where they should sit. At no point was the place more than half full (at any given point there were about 6 tables with people). I was alone, most tables had two people with two waitresses. Almost never could I find my waitress and whenever I did she kept telling me she will be right over to me. At one point, I was tempted to get my own water because I waited about 15 mins with an empty glass but ended up calling over the overwhelmed other waitress dealing with her three tables of people. Food was edible. I got Grandmaâs spaghetti and meatballs but asked for angel hair which I was told was great. Well, andpparently no one wanted to tell grandma her cooking is bad, I couldnât eat most of it. I waited about 25 mins for the check to find out they charged me $2 extra for angel hair. After waiting almost 15 mins for the waitress to return, I finally got up and went to her. She asked the manager what to do about the $2 charge that I was not made aware of. The manager asked if I complained, the waitress said yes, and the manager responded to the waitress that she should tell me to âscrewâ myself but she took it off my bill. Would not be returning here again.Lots of made up drama. it is hard to believe the experience was that bad. Sounds like someone was having a bad day. I am from Coram N.Y 53 Andover Drive right off of Route 112.
