Location: Water Mill
Top Restaurants in Water Mill
Countries
Top 8 Pizza food in Water Mill, Southampton, New York
Discover Restaurants offering the best Pizza food in Water Mill, Southampton, New York. Water Mill is a hamlet of the Town of Southampton on Long Island and census-designated place (CDP) in Suffolk County, New York, United States. The population of the CDP was 1,559 at the 2010 census. Its ZIP code is 11976.
Things to do in Water Mill
8. La Capannina
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By maikai-guy
I've been driving by this place for years, thinking pizza can't be good in the Hamptons. Well, I was wrong! Not only do they have a fantastic assortment of tasty pizza, they also offer a menu of Italian dishes. I've been stopping here for about a year and have run through almost their entire menu. I have not found one item I didn't thoroughly enjoy!
7. Pelligrino's Pizza Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 24 reviews
Reviewed By AllenFein
Perfect wonderfully delicious wood fired pizza with high quality toppings accompanied by two great tap beers in cold mugs. Doesn't get any better. Friendly and prompt bar service and company. Go for it!
6. Cafe Crust
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By dgyuen
We had another delicious dinner at Cafe Crust. Unpretentious in The Hamptons, but fresh, delicious fare! Started out with their Spinach Salad- might have seemed pricey at first, but it was delicious and big enough for two. Had the brick oven-baked Marguerite pie- fresh organic tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and fresh basil (made the other half with sweet Italian sausage and red roasted peppers! Outdoor dining tonight was perfect- always friendly and accommodating wait staff is a plus.
5. Pizza Place
Reviewed By HollisNYNL
This little roadside pizza parlor is a place you'd drive right by without looking twice - but that would be a mistake. Locals and summer residents alike know that it's a great spot for great pizza - especially for take-out (though you can eat there, too - and they apparently have weekly jazz on summer nights). Here's a good tip: call ahead to place your order, especially in season, so you can swing by and pick up the pizzas when ready - without the wait.
4. Paul's Italian American Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 58 reviews
Paul's Italian American Restaurant Provides Italian Food Services to the Greater Southhampton, NY Area.
Reviewed By dave809
Paul's is a terrific Italian family restaurant that serves well-prepared dinners at prices that will not make you flinch like most Southampton restaurants will. Our family (locals) dines there regularly and we're very happy with the consistent food, service, and overall value provided. Convenient location just a few feet away from Agawam Park and Jobs Lane. Their table are small but separated so that you still have some privacy. Enjoy.
3. World Pie
Overall Ratings
4 based on 171 reviews
Reviewed By AllenFein
As a regular guest of this outstanding and reliable great place to unwind and dine, I again strongly recommend World Pie for both locals and part time visitors. Meals are delicious and generous. Last night chef prepared special paella and it was perfect! Prices are very reasonable and all waiters and bar men are very friendly and helpful. There is so much more here than their wonderful large assortment of fire oven pizzas! Excellent outdoor seating too.
2. American Pie Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By 36artf
We were visiting friends and decided to visit American Pie. Wow! We ordered the Margarita Pizza and a grilled eggplant and portobello mushroom wrap. The wrap was delicious and the pizza was fabulous. Full of flavor and delicious. Iâve been eating pizza for over sixty years and this pizza was right up there with the best. If I lived in the area I would be a steady customer. There is limited seating and we were lucky to be able to eat in.
Most Popular American food in Water Mill, Southampton, New York
1. La Parmigiana Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 219 reviews
Reviewed By suzyd43
Great restaurant with delicious food. So hard to choose what to order. We did take out, and I learned that they will deliver, when you use the Door Dash app. We ordered a grilled chicken parmigiana, which was lighter without breading, ravioli, veal with mushrooms and spinach, and a wonderful salad with chicken, mozzarella, and red peppers. Almost forgotto get dessert but added cheesecake to our order. It was rich and creamy. Another winning meal from this favorite.
Where to eat French food in Water Mill: The Best Restaurants and Bars
