Location: Michigan City
Top Restaurants in Michigan City
Countries
Top 8 Italian food in Michigan City, Indiana, United States
Reviews on Italian food in Michigan City, Indiana, United States. Michigan City is a city in LaPorte County, Indiana, United States. It is one of the two principal cities of the Michigan City-La Porte, Indiana Metropolitan Statistical Area, which is included in the Chicago-Naperville-Michigan City Combined Statistical Area.
Things to do in Michigan City
8. Miller Pizza By The Beach
Overall Ratings
3 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By MarieA631
I carried out pizza and breadsticks on our way to the beach. Both pizzas had plenty of toppings and the thin crust was delicious. We also enjoyed breadsticks w tomato sauce. You can find pizzas less expensively but I like independently owned places like this. Large and medium pizzas w two toppings each and 5 breadsticks cost $36. I will return.
Michigan City Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Michigan City
7. Roma Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 21 reviews
Reviewed By Keno123123
Was craving pizza in New Buffalo and stumbled upon this place on a Monday evening. We were greeted by a friendly server and she took our beverage order of wine and a beer. We then ordered our pizza, breadsticks, and salad. After a little while our piping hot meal was delivered to our table and it was well worth the wait. This is our new favorite place in New Buffalo.
6. Gelsosomo's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 44 reviews
Reviewed By IndianaDaisy
My teens and I stop by about once a month for pizza. We are always greeted, seated timely and waited on quick. The pizza and sandwiches are always served hot and tasty. We will continue to come back.
Most Popular Seafood food in Michigan City, Indiana, United States
5. Wana Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 25 reviews
Casual Dining. Delivery, Pizza Sandwiches, salad wings
Reviewed By Antiquelover2
Called for pick up and the young lady was very polite. Large 3 topping pizza and breadsticks for $12.99 I thought was a great deal. Tried the "sweet sauce" - what a mistake as it was horribly sweet. I think someone may have made it wrong as it was terrible. Other pizza places have sauce on the "sweet side" (Gelsosomo's and The Vineyard are two I know of) and the sauce is great, but this was way too sweet/sugary. Sausage was pretty plentiful, but mushrooms and tomatoes were rather sparse. We may try again with regular sauce, but definitely not a good pizza by any means.Hello. Thank you for trying our pizza. I'm sorry the sweet sauce was to sweet for your liking. We will gladly mix the sweet and traditional sauces to make a less sweet sauce. We will happy remake any pizza that is not to a customers liking, just call us. I will admit and often advise people that our sweet sauce is sweet and you will either love it or hate it. I sure hope you do give the traditional sauce a try. Hope to see you soon! Thanks Mike.
Where to eat Diner food in Michigan City: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Taverna Tonelli
Overall Ratings
4 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By Monique R
We had not visited the new location until last week. The decor is tasteful makeover of the old Maxims. The vibe is the right level of energy with great acoustics. -not too loud.The menu offers a tempting range of light to substantial depending on your appetite . The portions were generous especially the pastas. The fish was delicious.. The wine list has something for everyone including some very high end selections. We were too full for dessert as we ate too much of the delicious bread with oil-garlic-cheese dip served with their healthy house salad. We will be back!
3. Scartozzi's Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 29 reviews
Reviewed By stantsy
just got back from the Notre Dame football game September 5th 2015.the group that I was with have used Scartozzi's before and I will say they did not disappoint.we picked up our food as per ordering earlier in the week, staff were super friendly upon getting there and we packed up the food as best we could (staff helped pack it up) as it is a bit of a drive back into South Bend. as a hint we bought a few hot / cold bags to help keep the food warm for the drive back to South Bend / tail-gatingnow to the food, was awesome, we had the veal / chicken / pasta and a platter of cheese and meats, all were well above what I actually expected. We had sterno's and racks to keep them hot as per tail-gating but the food did not disappoint at all.I would do this again in a heartbeat if I am ever lucky enough to attend a Notre Dame football again and or have the opportunity to eat at Scartozzi's again.keep up the good work.
Where to eat American food in Michigan City: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
4 based on 57 reviews
Reviewed By Chipperhigh2
Stopped for dinner at Olive Garden after checking our hotel. Was seated immediately. Service was very good. Two of us ordered their Seafood Alfredo and drinks. As always their salad was wonderful and unlimited. Food was great and we enjoyed our meal.
1. Albano's Villa
Overall Ratings
4 based on 100 reviews
Reviewed By Gregory B
Old fashioned atmosphere, very classic joint, the way we like it! Dimly lit, cozy ambience! The food was so authentic Italian, and the staff was fantastic. Huge selection, all food tasted from scratch. Please do not miss this gemstone on Franklin St!
Best Steakhouse food near Michigan City, Indiana, United States
