Location: Peyton
Top Restaurants in Peyton
Top Things to do in Peyton
Countries
Top 5 Italian food in Peyton, Colorado, United States
Reviews on Italian food in Peyton, Colorado, United States. Peyton is a census-designated place and a U.S. Post Office in El Paso County, Colorado, United States. The population as of the 2010 Census was 250. The nearby unincorporated area of Falcon also uses zip code 80831. Peyton and towns such as Falcon, Calhan, Ramah, Simla, and Matheson straddle U.S. Highway 24 between Colorado Springs and Limon, Colorado where US 24 intersects with Interstate 70.
Things to do in Peyton
1. Black Forest Pies & Grinders
Overall Ratings
4 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By j4wolfe
The food was very good, I initially was surprised at the price having only ordered fried pickles, cheese sticks, and cheese bread. Upon opening the boxes I realized how much food we actually got and was pleasantly surprised, as the cheese bread seemed to be a small pizza cut up and stacked into the box. The kiddo loved it all as did the girlfriend and myself, definitely worth it if you need good food in black forest.
Colorado, United States Food Guide: 3 Cafe food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Peyton
2. Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano
Overall Ratings
4 based on 279 reviews
(719) 262-9500
Reviewed By debcar7
When we arrived we were seated right away. Our waitress brought out two types of bread and made "Biaggi's Butter"...{oil, parmesan cheese and salt} We started off with the :SPINACH & ARTICHOKE DIPOven-Baked Fresh Spinach, Artichokes, Creamy Italian Cheese Blend & Parmesan Breadcrumbs, Grilled Baguette It was very flavorful and was plenty for 3 people. Our waitress had asked for extra Baguette bread for us.I had the :SMOKED SALMON "STRAW & HAY"Applewood House-Smoked Salmon, Scallion Cream Sauce, Parmesan & Romano Cheeses, Spinach & Egg Fettuccini It was very good and was even better tonight when I re-warmed what was left. The portion was perfect but, I filled up on the appetizer and wanted dessert...My partner had:BRAISED SHORT RIB RAVIOLIBraised Beef Short Rib-Filled Ravioli, Sage-Brown Butter Sauce, Veal Reduction, Hint of Horseradish, Seasoned Breadcrumbs He said it was very good and the horseradish did not over power the dish.His son had:SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLSHousemade Sicilian Meatballs, Marinara Sauce, Parmigiano-Reggiano Cheese It looked very good but, he didn't seem to be impressed with it...I should mention here that he is a 13 year old so...take that for what it's worth.For dessert we had:GELATO & SORBETTOYour Choice of Three Scoops of Gelato - Amarena Cherry, Cappuccino, Vanilla Bean, Chocolate, Spumoni or Blood Orange Sorbetto As soon as I saw Spumoni, I had to have that!!! I wanted two scoops of that and one of the Blood Orange but, they were out of it.Overall the meal was very enjoyable. Our waitress was very attentive. The only complaint I would have is that it was very noisy so, carrying on a conversation was a little difficult at times. Definitely not a quite romantic Italian restaurant.I would recommend it for a family or group but, not necessarily for a 'couple' outing unless you sit right next to each other.Ciao
3. Borriello Brothers
Overall Ratings
3 based on 29 reviews
Also service Pizzas. There number is 719-282-6200
Reviewed By Shelby L
We chose this place because it was near my friend's home and we didn't feel like going anywhere fancy. We arrived at around 8 pm on a Friday evening. Surprisingly there were only a few patrons. The restaurant was clean, the staff friendly, and the prices reasonable. The pizza, while not the absolute best I've ever had, was quite good. They also have a small selection of beer (all were good brands), and wine-by-the-glass. This is not a "destination restaurant," by any means, but that isn't really what it appears to strive for. It is a fairly straightforward neighborhood pizza parlor, offering good food at reasonable prices, served by friendly staff in a clean environment. I expect that I'll return often.
4. Walter's303 Pizzeria & Publik House - Flying Horse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 36 reviews
Our Pizza At Walterâs303, our recipe is simple; dough made fresh daily, sauce from scratch, premium toppings, and 100% whole milk mozzarella. Our recipes have roots in family tradition with a modern twist. Weâre not fancy, fussy or fake. We are devoted to
Reviewed By theapp
Went here one evening before a snow storm and had their wings for the first time - Italian seasoned. What a treat!!! They were flavorful, finger licking good. None of that chicken drowning in sauce nonsense that's taken over the market - these were tasty, juicy wings with a rich seasoning, ready to eat as-is or with a little dipping sauce for those so inclined. Yum!We had other items as well, but the wings were the real winner. Place is nice and spacious, and we didn't feel like we were on top of other customers, like some places in town. Service was polite, fast, and welcoming. Price was reasonable for the amount of food, drinks, etc.Overall, a nice little place a bit off the beaten path. The food is tasty and freshly made by people that appear to care about their craft. And you should absolutely try the wings...
5. Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana
Overall Ratings
4 based on 68 reviews
Authentic Neapolitan Pizzeria serving also Italian starters, dessert, draft beers and Italian wines
Reviewed By simonnike
Cute Napoletana pizza place in Colorado Springs. They had a musician playing guitar and singing inside but it was a nice night so we sat on the patio. Nice wine, beer, and cocktail options. They made me a nice Aperol Spritz. We started with a salad. It was pretty good but could have used some more dressing. The meat on it was smokey and delicious. The pizzas are the star. The diavola is quite spicy. I like my crust a bit more done/crispy but it held up and was good. We didnât try any desserts but they looked tasty.
