Location: Middletown
Top Restaurants in Middletown
Top Things to do in Middletown
Countries
Top 10 restaurants in Middletown, United States
Middletown in United States, from Nouth America region, is best know for Takeout. Discover best restaurants in Middletown with beautiful photos and great reviews from traveller around the world here!
Things to do in Middletown
1. Sushi Yama
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 93 reviews
Reviewed By Delightedtourist - Bedford, Canada
Fabulous sushi! The restaurant is in a strip mall but don't be fooled by the location. The food is very authentic, beautifully presented and delicious. The service was great! Definitely worth the trip to eat here. Wear a sweater as it was cool inside the restaurant.
2. Caruso's Bistro Cucina Italiana & Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 76 reviews
302-449-0097
Reviewed By George S - Rochester, Michigan
My first visit to Caruso's. We ordered specials that were marked on the blackboard upon entry which were specials.
The meal was very good but, I was shocked when the bill came.
The special was $24.99. This is the most I have ever paid for a special anywhere. They should have posted the prices of the specials.
3. Tom Foolery's Restaurant & Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 63 reviews
Reviewed By Robert H - Middletown, Delaware
Burger Night is awesome. Never had or heard anyone complain of the various burgers. Daily lunch specials, especially the roast beef(Wednesdays) are terrific. Staff is always friendly and are some of the best mixologists in the area.
Has outdoor seating and inside also serves as sports bar with a couple TV screens.
Local feeling.
4. Los Machados Mexican Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 33 reviews
Reviewed By SEK65 - Wilmington, DE
We went here to celebrate my niece's birthday. Since there would be 17 of us we made a reservation. There really aren't too many places to set up for that large of a party so we ended up near the door which made it difficult for people to get in and around us.
I have to say after hearing a lot about how good the food was I was incredibly disappointed. The chips and salsa that was brought out was hard for 6 people to share without plates. Several of us at the table ordered the Enchiladas Poblano #151. The enchiladas themselves were okay but the poblano sauce was awful it had a burnt taste to it. Poblano sauce should have a smoky taste but not a bitter burnt taste. The Mexican salad that came with it was nothing more than lettuce, a tablespoon of guacamole and a tablespoon of sour cream and the rice was weird.
The decor is nice and colorful and the place is clean. Service is adequate but we had to keep asking for stuff multiple times. I know a group of our size is hard to manage but they should have put more than one person on our table.
The group of waitstaff all gathered to present the complimentary fried ice cream and sang happy birthday.
I'm not sure if I would give them another chance, this place is 45 minutes away and quite frankly, not worth the trip.
5. Chick-fil-A
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 41 reviews
Reviewed By Timothy L. C - Annapolis MD area, United States
Have only discovered Chick-fill-A a few weeks ago, and I must say that this chain has quickly become my favourite fast food chain!
They offer really good quality food, friendly service and is patriotic (each restaurant proudly flies the American Flag). And as if that was not enough of a great attitude, they also closed on Sundays so that employees can go to church and be with family!
Love their spicy chicken sandwich and free refills on drinks!
Why aren’t more fast food chains following this model? Great food, reasonable prices, great friendly service, with patriot and religious values!
6. La Piazza Italian Restaurant & Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 41 reviews
Reviewed By maril35 - delaware
I don't mind paying for dinner costing in the upper 20 s IF it is exceptional. And this restaurant is ex eptional. That includes taste, service and promptness. Four of us dined at LaPiazza last week. Service was polite and prompt. I had Veal Scallopini and there was lots of meat on my plate. It included asparagus and a side of pasta and sauce.
We will be going back again soon. Too many good things to say and NO I m not connected to this restaurant in any way.
7. The Grille at Back Creek
Overall Ratings
4 based on 80 reviews
Reviewed By HonestGuyDelaware - Townsend, Delaware
Have been here many times. Ordered the crab dip appetizer. Disappointed,was a mouse with very little crab flavor and lots of cheese. Also supposed to come with crostini and arrived with pita triangles. Sent it back.
The filet was GREAT! perfectly cooked(rare) and flavorful. The sides...well,the hearts of palm inedible. The broccoli,tough..
The Mrs had a killer Salmon,with mango salsa..OUTSTANDING portion and flavor.. Manager was kind enough to remove the app from bill and comped a birthday dessert(funnel cake fries)definitely a winner.
Henry our waiter did an outstanding job. Also realizing that the app took too long to arrive and we barely started when entrees arrived.
One of our favorite places..Will definitely return!
8. Middletown Pizza Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By route50guy - Washington DC, District of Columbia
This pizza place is popular with the local community so that is a good sign. However, pizza tastes are very individual so be your own guide
9. Middletown Family Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 44 reviews
Reviewed By Vernon G - Newark, Delaware
What a pleasant surprise. Running very late for out normal date night, so we figured, we haven't been to this Diner in 10+ years and figured ...why not give it a try, we were tired and our expectations were not high. We thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. NOTHING FANCY HERE !!! But, it is all very tasty, the staff a so enjoyable, not afraid to engage the customer, and chat. The food was wholesome and plentiful and the pricing was excellent. No need for a suit and tie here, just come, be yourself and allow the night to be relaxing and enjoyable.
10. 1861
Overall Ratings
4 based on 85 reviews
Reviewed By Boomerang025 - Homer
It has been several years since my last visit but not much has changed. The menu is small but continues to offer an eclectic selection of tastes that are well prepared. The scallops with lobster polenta, champagne broth and bacon jam was delightful. The scallops were huge. We also enjoyed the 1861 spicy wings with carmelized onion, garlic, and rosemary for a unique flavor blend. This is a comfortable spot to have a drink. It would be nice if somehow they could expand their parking.
