Location: Fleming Island
Top Restaurants in Fleming Island
Countries
Top 10 restaurants in Fleming Island, United States
Fleming Island is an unincorporated community and census-designated place (CDP) in Clay County, Florida, United States. It is located 21 miles (34 km) southwest of downtown Jacksonville, on the western side of the St. Johns River, off US 17. As of the 2010 census the Fleming Island CDP had a population of 27,126. Fleming Island's ZIP code became 32003 in 2004, giving it a different code from Orange Park, the incorporated town to the north.
Things to do in Fleming Island
1. Santioni's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 178 reviews
Reviewed By Mark G - Jacksonville
This is our favorite place to take friends or just the two of us. Many tasty entrees
and top staff. Very popular so reservations are recommended but usually they will fit you in if they can. The owner's singing and piano player are bonuses to the quality food.
We have never found spumoni ice cream as authentic as this since I move from
California. Highly recommended.
2. Sweet Frog Premium Frozen Yogurt
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 28 reviews
Reviewed By dad81 - Fleming Island, Florida
Pricey but the kids enjoy it. I can't imagine why they charge so much for this stuff. Maybe there is a "club" or coupons but I don't think this is anything special but the kids like it. Publix frozen yogurt is way better and cheaper too.
3. Mackey's Munchies
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 65 reviews
Reviewed By Michael S
Wow, everything we ordered was super salty. Wife ordered gumbo. It was not good. Too salty and not a lot of stuff in it, too brothy, almost inedible. I had fried shrimp and fried okra. Shrimp were small and tasted like grocery store frozen then fried shrimp, not very flavorful. Okra was pretty good. Mackie's sauce is quite good. Staff and owners are super friendly but need to lay off the salt. Sorry, I had high hopes for this place but sadly we won't be back.
4. Corky Bell's Seafood
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 126 reviews
Reviewed By Bud S - Callahan, Florida
Wife and I stopped by on Friday lunchtime during one of our rides. Nice place, the staff was very friendly and on top of things. We both had the lunch fried shrimp special . The meal came out quickly and was hot and fresh. There was a good amount of shrimp, we're decent size and cooked just right. I had fries, which were hot and crispy and cole slaw which was perfect for my taste. My wife had baked beans and cole slaw and liked both. Overall thoughts, nice place, great staff, good food for a decent price. You can't ask for anything else.
5. Mojo Smokehouse
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 100 reviews
Reviewed By Judy B - Jacksonville, Florida
Visit like 4 times a year and order the same delicious pork and smoked yellow corn. Server was very helpful and pleasant. Music a little loud. Not my style. Good decor and pleasant atmosphere. Will return.
6. Joey Mozzarella
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 527 reviews
Reviewed By Mommy2R
My family LOVES this place! The food is delicious and their specials are amazing. Always great service, large portions and very affordable! Our go to for Italian!
7. Mellow Mushroom
Overall Ratings
4 based on 149 reviews
Reviewed By Wayne C - Orange Park, Florida
My Lady and I with her son and granddaughter stopped by for a pizza and Spinach & artichoke dip - Her son recommended a pizza not on the menu - shrimp & endue sausage - it was ok - pizza crust was kind of bready and the sausage wasn't much - the mozzarella cheese was very good - BUT the Spinach & artichoke dip was EXCELLENT - served with toasted bread pieces - the server was very good and the atmosphere was pleasant - would go back but not in a hurry
8. Shrimp Shack Seafood Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 139 reviews
Reviewed By RLWOrangePark - Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida
Ordered their Tues Special 30 Shrimp with 2 sides (fires and cole slaw). Shrimp were very good although not as large as usually (hence only 4 stars in stead of their usual 5 star rating). Fries were hot and fresh. Do wish they would bring back their loyalty program.
9. Your Pie Fleming Island
Overall Ratings
4.5 based on 63 reviews
Your Pie is a fast casual franchise restaurant concept that invites guests to express their "Inner Pizza!" Guests choose from three dough, nine sauces, nine cheeses, and 40+ different toppings to create their own custom 10" inch pizza. Baked in five short minutes in a fiery hot brick oven, YOUR PIE is fresh, fast and flavorful! Other signature menu items include panini, chopped salads,creamy Italian gelato and ice cold craft beers.
Reviewed By RamonaL34
Your Pie has wonderful pizza. The sauce has a little hint of pepper in it, it's very tasty. They offer all kinds of different pizza toppings - artichoke hearts, pesto, chicken, bacon, even ones with vegan cheese. They also offer gluten free bases. They serve a wide variety of beers and sodas to drink.
They have indoor and outside seating. The staff at Your Pie are very friendly and helpful. Excellent place! Highly recommended.
10. Talons At Eagle Harbor
Overall Ratings
4 based on 66 reviews
Reviewed By Jim K
Fairly new restaurant in neighborhood. Was told by friend that crab cakes were good but average at best. Do not expect bread with meal and you will pay for any substitutions for sides. Certainly not fine dining although a bit pricey. Would be hard pressed to go back. I think food was better prior to remodel. Too many better places to spend your dining out buck.
