Location: Allegany
Top Restaurants in Allegany
Countries
Top 10 Pub food in Allegany, New York, United States
Best Pub restaurants nearby. Discover the best Pub food in Allegany. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Pub restaurants near you.. Allegany is a town in Cattaraugus County, New York, United States. The population was 8,004 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Allegany
10. Mickey's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By cyndycac
Mickey's is another favorite in Olean, NY. The atmosphere is casual and reminds you of a pub feel. They serve seafood dinners, pasta, steaks, subs and pizza is made to order. Theme type evenings are planned, like the annual Pepper Fest and Leak Fest. Food is excellent and a back dining room hosts meetings, receptions, special dinners and events.
9. The Old Library
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By audpr
I cannot fully express just how grateful I am to the owners and employees of this establishment. I have a wonderful wedding here! The food was out of this world delish!!! They are beyond accommodating for those picky eaters and will make a special plate for them. We had a "smore's bar" and it was beyond my expectations. It was simply amazing! They really pull out all the stops and create the most magical and enchanting event. Now, on to the B&B....This place, on a scale of 1-10 is a 30! We rented the whole house for our bridal party and it was worth every penny. The ladies that cared for us in the morning, and made us all breakfast, and treated us like family! I cannot wait to go back for an anniversary and spend the night. A giant thank you! XOXO
8. Union Whiskey
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By nylady21
We enjoyed the tables near the open front wall and awning. Drinks were creative and good, although some were sweeter than usual. I'd definitely ask for less simple syrup next time. The trash can Nachos were great and plentiful. The hanging pretzel was delicious and we all enjoyed breaking off pieces to dip. The bartender was a bit overwhelmed on Friday afternoon so service was sometimes slow (and you had to go the bar to order). All in all, though, a great addition to Olean.
7. The Broken Wing Pizzeria & Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By nylady21
The personal flatbread pizza with pulled pork was exceptional. Great crispy crust and abundant, high quality toppings. The Buffalo chicken wrap had a wonderful, thin pizza-like crust. There were a number of different craft beers in addition to the standards. Service was friendly and attentive. The atmosphere was warm, with background music that allowed for conversation. Great place with many regular locals, but we were warmly welcomed too. Excellent value.
6. 3rd Base
Overall Ratings
4 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By Johnandjoanne1971
Any time I'm traveling I'm always in search for the best wings in the area. The 3rd base did not disappoint. It's a typical old fashion pub with a small kitchen behind the bar. The service was great and the wings were superb! Would highly recommend their wings if your in the area.
5. Woodside Tavern on the Range
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By JRD52
I went to eat here while staying in the area I was tired from driving all day and did not want to spend all night looking for a nice restaurant service is good food is so so for the price its not wow and not bad its just foodThank you for taking the time to leave us your feedback. Weâre happy that you chose to dine with us while visiting the area. We appreciate your business and hope you will dine with us again the next time youâre out this way. Please donât hesitate to speak with one of our managers if there is anything we can do to ensure that your next visit is five-star and âwowâ worthy!
4. Grand Slam Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 18 reviews
Reviewed By markwake717
We enjoyed our visit to the Grand Slam Grill. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't great either. Just average. The upside: the service was good, and my son loved his Grand Slam Burger. Our waitress was very attentive and helpful. Our drinks were never empty.The downside: my wife didn't enjoy the chicken salad wrap. There wasn't much seasoning on the wrap. It was pretty bland.The average: Today's special was a chicken strip sandwich with blue cheese dressing. It was okay. Not outstanding, just okay. The prices were a little higher than we would have liked. Not unreasonable, just a little high for the quality of the food.We wish the Grand Slam Grill all the best. They seem like great people, but they need to step up the quality of the restaurant.
3. The Burton
We have been family owned for over 40 years, and are known for our burgers throughout the community and Bona Nation since the 1950's. We extended our kitchen hours three years ago, and serve from noon until at 7 p.m. every day (closed on Sundays). Known a
Reviewed By ceharv
The Burton Burger is a local tradition, essentially required eating for St. Bonaventure U. students, parents, etc. Otherwise it's a decent and friendly family-owned bar. I can't comment on the other foods offered, get the burger if going.
2. Randy's Fireside
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By Christopher A
Randy's Fireside is one of the places where you go when you know you want good comfort food in a friendly setting. The food is very American but it's really good. It's a great place to meet friends on Friday or Saturday night, knowing that you can sleep in the next day. (Unless you're going to church on Sunday morning, then shame on you for thinking that way! Just kidding, go anyway but leave just a little earlier). There is also outdoor seating which is nice for the 2 weeks of summer we get up here in WNY before the snow starts again. (Kidding again, it's 3 weeks of summer.) The menu is very good overall. The fried green beans are the BEST.
1. Randy's Up the River
Overall Ratings
4 based on 45 reviews
Reviewed By 8374judyj
Whoâs cooking back there? Itâs certainly not who it used to be. Everything you order tastes like itâs DRENCHED in oil. That means either the fryer is not at the correct temperature or they are trying to cook to many things in it at once.CERTAIN waitresses there are terrible and i have NO idea how they keep their job!Youâll never get another Penney of my money!
Where to eat American food in Allegany: The Best Restaurants and Bars
