Location: Grand Island
Top Restaurants in Grand Island
Countries
Top 10 Italian food in Grand Island, New York, United States
Reviews on Italian food in Grand Island, New York, United States. Nathan McMurray (D)
Things to do in Grand Island
10. Lombardo Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 228 reviews
Established in 1975, 40 years and 3 generations later Ristorante Lombardo has evolved into one of the regions best and most authentic Italian restaurants. Our seasonally changing menu features original creations inspired by regional Italian preparations,
Reviewed By MisaelWNY
The gem of WNY and Buffalo, Tommy Lombardo and staff work extremely hard at providing 5 star service, with exceptional customer engagement and great service after the sale. We've become quite fond of this North Buffalo haven and continue to return for those romantic nights. This place induces romance and labors to become the best of Buffalo. Two thumbs up!!!
9. Touch of Italy
Overall Ratings
4 based on 68 reviews
Reviewed By RickFLL
A great restaurant with friendly and efficient staff offering wonderfully delicious Italian food. There were four of us and we shared meatballs and sauce, lasagna and a large pizza (with mushrooms, cheese and sausage) and all was very delicious. I would recomend this place to friends and family and look to return again soon.
8. Joey's Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Reviewed By misscrusty
Joey's came highly recommended from a few locals from the neighborhood, but this seems like more of a neighborhood bar than a legit pizzeria. Pizza: very dry, undersauced, tough, and tasted somewhat stale. Salad was made of shredded iceberg, resembled coleslaw, and was flat/soggy. Prices were higher than most. When I arrived to pick up, workers were swearing and complaining. Probably OK if you're a regular and have a few cocktails in you before trying the food. Otherwise there are too many other good pizza spots in the Falls to patronize.
7. Donatello's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 434 reviews
Reviewed By TravelBugVA
This unassuming family place has excellent pizza!! We ordered the 17â pizza that easily serves 3-4 people. We wanted the âItalianoâ with artichoke hearts, ricotta cheese, mozzarella cheese, red bell peppers. Wow! We loved it! Another person got a Greek salad with sliced, grilled chicken. The salad was very large with lots of black olives, feta cheese, and very fresh tomatoes. Another person in our party got a personal pizza with ham and mushrooms. Againâexcellent!Please keep in mind that this little place is not fancy. You use paper plates and plastic utensils. We certainly didnât mind a bit. We went there for the great food!
6. Bella Vista Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 92 reviews
Located in the Four Points by Sheraton Niagara Falls you'll find the best thin crust pizzas, hand made pasta and gnocchi, flavorful paninis and many other authentic Italian dishes.Enjoy dinner on our riverfront patio or warm up inside by the fire. Itâs It
Reviewed By hershey272
We were staying at the Sheraton Four Points restaurant so decided to have a couple of meals at the in-house restaurant itself. The restaurant is Italian with a wonderful view of the river. The menu has plenty of options. We had stuffed hot peppers and buffalo wings for lunch and pizza for dinner. The staff is friendly, service reasonably quick and food good. We also had tiramisu for dessert and it was presented well and tasted amazing. We had the breakfast buffet both days and it was prepared well. The local brews are really good. Plus, the restaurant is reasonably priced. Definitely recommended!Hello and thank you for your kind words. We are so thrilled we could make a difference to your stay with us. Please come back soon.Dan ThomasDirector of Food and Beverage
Most Popular Barbecue food in Grand Island, New York, United States
5. Olive Garden
Overall Ratings
4 based on 369 reviews
Reviewed By tshep42
If youâre not familiar with the menu, itâs mostly Italian with a selection of other dishes. Good wine selection. We came for lunch and there was no wait, although shortly after there looked like a short wait. Food was cooked very nicely and service was very friendly and attentive. Maybe. Bit slow but it was a pretty busy.
Best Steakhouse food near Grand Island, New York, United States
4. Michael's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 354 reviews
Reviewed By ChiefM55
We had the Italian Veal Dinner, the Spaghetti and Meatballs and Ziti and MeatBalls Entrees. Waitress was really helpful. We also added the plus up option to the house salad - sliced mozzarella cheese rolls. the salads were good. We were disappointed in the Veal, the veal was what appears to be frozen Breaded veal patties, not home made or a fresh pice of veal. the meatballs were fantastic, the sauce was excellent. The pasta was cooked well.
Where to eat Chinese food in Grand Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
3. La Cucina Di Mamma
Overall Ratings
4 based on 544 reviews
Open for lunch & dinner. Casual Italian restaurant featuring home made specials. Located inside the Kalika Hotel on the corner of Rainbow & John Daly Boulevards.
Reviewed By Rustymuscles
Quaint place. Servers friendly, food amazing. We ordered ravioli and spaghetti. When back in Niagara, will return!
Most Popular Bar food in Grand Island, New York, United States
2. Pizza Amore
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By ejtanner
Ordered a steak and cheese pizza, California pizza, and a prosciutto and arugula pizza the other night. Can't decide which one we liked best! The wood fire adds so much to the flavor of any pie from here. Oh, and loved the cannolis!
Where to eat Brew Pub food in Grand Island: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Buzzy's New York Style Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 450 reviews
Reviewed By Kaupert
Dont know how we have missed this place all these years !! Delicious !! We ordered 2 specialty pizzas and wings !! Plenty left over.
