Location: Elmsford
Top Restaurants in Elmsford
Countries
Top 10 Italian food in Elmsford, New York, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Elmsford, New York, United States. Elmsford is a village in Westchester County, New York, United States. It is part of the New York metropolitan area. Roughly one mile square, the village is fully contained within the borders of the town of Greenburgh. As of the 2010 census, the population of Elmsford was 4,664.
Things to do in Elmsford
10. King Pizza
Reviewed By BRADH520
The pizza was great as was the salad. Ordered the pizza unknowing of what type we would get (We just got to our hotel and were tired). We called them up and they delivered - both figuratively and literally! The staff was great on the phone as was the delivery driver. The pizza was the best we have had in a long time. Glad we only ordered 1 because boy were they huge! I highly recommend. Great tasting and great staff!
9. Racanelli's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By sisterbrianl
Ate here on 6/8/17. Nice looking place and sort of attentive waiters. The salads are huge and not fresh. I would have appreciated the waiter telling us that one salad would serve at least four. Pizza was excellent but I felt meal was too pricey. The waiter seemed bored and didn't do much. The food was good but if I returned I'd go in with eyes open!!!!
8. Flames Steakhouse
Reviewed By lauraeK7750TG
This is the second time my husband and I ate here. The wait staff are very unapproachable making you feel like they are doing you a favor by serving you. With that said I was willing to look beyond this giving benefit of the doubt everyones entitled to be in a bad mood. We had a glass of wine each (12.00) for 1/4 glass. Oyster Rockefellar for appetizer (served with slices of lemon ???) Hubby had Linguine w clams which was nothing more than linguine with what seemed to be chicken broth and clams on top. I ordered chicken Martini and asked for side pasta instead of potatoes and was told bluntly "no substitutions' . Chicken was horrible. Hard and chewy. Waiter placed a dish of mashed potatoes on the table with our meal which we didnt order. Hubby took a few forkfuls before the waiter noticed he gave it to the wrong table and came to remove it to give to the table next to us!! Once I told him my husbands fork was already in the dish he placed it back down!! Coffee and dessert was next (12.50 for Sambucca for black coffee???) The meal itself ($160.00) was so not worth it but the worst was 45 minutes later when we got home and I was in one bathroom vomiting and my husband was in the other. Both of us dizzy and ill. NEVER AGAIN !!
7. Sapori
Overall Ratings
4 based on 102 reviews
Reviewed By Worldofood
Amazing Italian food served with excellent service staff. Grilled Octopus was a perfect starter. Wonderful selection of Italian wine. Good for a business meal and family dinner. Parking in the backyard was very convenient.We will certainly visit again for another business meal.
6. Carmine's Italian Deli & Cafe
Reviewed By Sally F
We had a business appointment nearby Carmine's with only 30 minutes to spare. We did a quick online search for a deli nearby and found Carmine's. It is definitely a local's place with most of the people there obviously known to each other. We went to the counter to order. My companion had a NY sandwich and I had the corned beef plate special. Wow to both. They were quick and so very good. The corned beef tasted homemade with cabbage and potatoes on the side. All three were tender and tasted like the corned beef broth. It was served with seedy brown mustard. The menu for breakfast, lunch and dinner all looks good. I wish I could go back again. A tip. You order at the back and give what you ordered when you pay at the register. Don't forget to pick a beverage from their very large selection in the frig.
5. Capri Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 119 reviews
Reviewed By Ken G
Got take out from Capri when were staying at a hotel right down the road. Place was suggested by the front desk. Man were they right about this place! Extensive pizza and Italian menu. Food was ready by the time I arrived(20 min). Prices are great and can't say enough how big the portions are. My kids each had individual pizzas that they could've split and been very full.(In the picture).We ordered: -Individual chicken/bacon/ranch pizza that was delicious.-Individual chicken parm pizza, also amazing.-Chicken parm hero. Excellent!Not included on the menu was the fact that they have a gelato bar. I got 3 small s for us. Cookie dough, peanut butter fudge and Dark chocolate. All were delicious.The wait staff was friendly and got me in and out with my order very fast. Would definitely eat here again.
4. Alex's Bar & Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 120 reviews
The best Italian restaurant with a Mediterranean touch in Westchester. Our specialties are Wine, Steaks and Traditional Italian Cuisine. We pride ourselves in making your food fast and fresh when you order it. We have the dining experience you crave. Rese
Reviewed By Petie W
We took our grandchildren and it is now their favorite Italian restaurant. We ordered veal, chicken and 2 pasta dishes and everyone cleared their plates! The red sauce was outstanding, the veal soft and savory, and the pasta al dente! The price was moderate, and the service was wonderful. We will be back!
3. Buon Amici
Overall Ratings
4 based on 166 reviews
Reviewed By SUSANL3538
Food is good, zillion specials, don't know how the waiters remember them. Love the hostess. Only problem is the noise level. Impossible to have a conversation. Would go back during the week, not on a weekend.
2. Mulino's of Westchester
Overall Ratings
4 based on 280 reviews
Reviewed By DANIEL M
I have eaten at this Excellent Italian restaurant numerous times and have never been disappointed. There is metered parking in the area. The restaurant does take reservations. The main theme is Italian food. The steaks are also excellent. Great atmosphere, especially try and attend during the Christmas season. The staff is very friendly and efficient. The menu is very extensive and the prices are reasonable for the quality of the food. If you are in a rush this is not the restaurant for you. Fine dining that I would definitely recommend
1. Casaletto Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 152 reviews
Reviewed By MarkWBoca
Only visiting Westchester every few months, I dine at Casaletto every visit. I sometimes forget just how outstanding it is. I have spent a long, happy lifetime traveling the world, including many trips to every part of Italy. Casaletto is the best Italian restaurant In the world, at least in my experience. Tonight I shared the spectacular grilled polpo (octopus) with my wife and daughter. Often I have enjoyed Casalettoâs perfect veal chop. On a whim I decided to try the special stuffed veal chop. Iâll never go back to their outstanding but more normal veal chop. I tasted everyone elseâs appetizers and mains - all as good as you can get anyplace. We all shared wonderful tiramisu and cannoli for dessert. The secret to Casaletto is that it is owned and managed by Italian-born waiters who live their Italian food. At least a couple of these owner-managers are always on the floor, moving from table to table, insuring that all service is tops and that the food served is cooked to perfection and beautifully presented. Dining out doesnât get any better.
