Location: Deer Park
Top Restaurants in Deer Park
Countries
Top 10 Italian food in Deer Park, New York, United States
Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in Deer Park. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. Deer Park is a hamlet and census-designated place (CDP) in the town of Babylon, Suffolk County, New York, United States. The population was 27,745 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Deer Park
10. Milan's Pizzeria & Ristorante
Reviewed By 388bag
The correct name of the restaurant is Milano's. It replaced another Italian restaurant in that location. Problem is the old restaurant had very good food. My wife and her friend had eggplant parm. They both said it was very tough. I had lemon chicken which was small pieces if chicken over very soggy pasta. Some of the chicken pieces were so tough, I couldn't cut it with a knife. The dish was basically tasteless. The other issue I have is that they brought out two dishes to my friends, and I waited and waited for my dish to come out. I hate when a restaurant does that. By the time my dish came out the others were well into their meal. I don't think we'll ever return. Just not good
9. Cafe Dolce Vita
Overall Ratings
3 based on 10 reviews
Reviewed By jack M
First time for us. We happened on it going to Tanger Mall. Stopped for pizza. Not bad, not great but not bad. Tomato sauce better than the average sharp acidic kind found in most similar local establishments. Abundant pizza variety; I couldn't even recognize some of the toppings. Staff very pleasant. Place quite clean. May stop again if in the area.
8. Bella's Pizzeria
Reviewed By Robert C
Bella's is found in an industrial park area right on a main road in Deer Park. The pizza we had was fresh, hot and, most importantly, excellent! The ingredients were fresh and tasty and I can't wait to return to try more things!
7. Rita's Italian Ice
Reviewed By MikeNYPhotographer
I said that Rita's is good for ices, because Ralph's actually has better ices. However, I actually prefer Rita's custard ice cream over everything anyhow. It is so smooth and creamy. They will give you a coupon if you ask. Definately can use it next time, might even let you use it this time. Kid size is plenty, the medium or large are a tremendous amount. Rita's is all over the Northeast, Ralph's I think is just Long Island. Other than two homemade places, that are far away, one in Babylon village and one in Huntington village, Rita's custard is the best ice cream around. I'm an ice cream snob obviously if I am the first one writing a review and I would only get ice cream from those two other places, or maybe Friendly's if my wife persists :). Never Carvel, or any of those other chains. That being said, Rita's is a chain, but they get it right. The staff is friendly, this location is very nice actually, perhaps the best one I've ever seen.
6. Dalisa Pizzeria and Restaurant
Reviewed By LongIslandGiirl
This is my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE pizza place on Long Island. They make the best pizza. Their food is good too, but I usually get pizza. They make it with lots of cheese, good crust, yummy, I want some right now!
5. Bellissimo Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By gnomeguy
I dined this past weekend at Bellissimo Ristorante in Deer Park New York. We had reservations for a party of six, at an early 6:30 time spot. Lucky for us we had early reservation because later diners willingly stood in line and waited for a table so they could enjoy the food at this excellent restaurant. We had been told the Baci Baci was to die for, but unfortunately it was not available the evening we were there. Our table selected six different meals, and all were judged to be excellent and well worth doing. I seriously doubt there is a bad meal on the menu. I personally had veal and peppers, a pesant dish I had not had in several years. What a treat
4. Pizzaiola
Overall Ratings
4 based on 60 reviews
Reviewed By Nancy B
This is a go-to place for us when we want pizza delivered. The price is reasonable and delivery is quick. The pizza crust is very good. We have tried some entrees (dined in), but we think they are just average.Won't go there again for a meal, just order pizza.
3. Mama Sbarro's Pizzeria Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 19 reviews
Authentic Italian recipes that are fresh and homemade daily. Dine-in, take-out, delivery and catering options available.
Reviewed By DnDvn
I love the Rigatoni Ala Mama past dish. It has freshly made sausage, mushroom and mozzarella. The sauce is also very good and it is something I can't make so I don't mind buying it from time to time. I used to be able to buy one order and it lasted for dinner and lunch the next day. I will say the portions appear to have gotten a lot smaller but I guess that is to keep the prices the same in spite of the rising price of goods. Either way the food is good and worth it.
2. Richie's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 49 reviews
Reviewed By Steve F
I stop by this place when I'm in the area for a few slices and the best garlic knots around. You can't avoid seeing them covered in garlic and Oil....just too hard to resist!
1. Brunello Italian Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4 based on 41 reviews
Reviewed By Sherry R
Needed a restaurant near the mini golf at Heartland Golf Park. I checked TripAdvisor and this restaurant seemed good. So we went and we were pleased. The service was good, waiter reasonably attentive, they changed the item I ordered to suit my needs which was great and I very much appreciated. The ambiance was good and it was not one of those VERY noisy restaurants.
Where to eat American food in Deer Park: The Best Restaurants and Bars
