Location: Barrie
Top Restaurants in Barrie
Countries
Top 10 Italian food in Barrie, Ontario, Canada
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in Barrie. Barrie is a city, and manifesting regional centre in Central Ontario, Canada, pleasantly positioned on the shores of Kempenfelt Bay, the western arm of Lake Simcoe. The city is located in, and county seat of Simcoe County, however is considered politically independent. It is part of the historically significant Huronia region of Central Ontario, and is within the northern part of the Greater Golden Horseshoe, a densely populated and industrialized region of Ontario.
Things to do in Barrie
10. Sicilian Gourmet Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 68 reviews
Authentic from the start, from hand tossing the pizza to the stone fired oven. We make the best pizza around. From the usual to many gourmet choices on our menu alone. Toss in sandwiches, pastas, salads and other flavorful dishes, you'll all start salivat
Reviewed By Davax
We thought we would try it out because we received a flyer in the mail and the menu looked good.We arrived on time for our reservation, which was unnecessary as the place was virtually empty. Even with an empty place, it took 10 minutes for our drinks to arrive.I ordered a veal parmigiana which comes with pasta of your choice. I asked for penne, which was repeated back to me. I received spaghetti instead. It was okay but very awkward. They serve the whole meal in a bowl! Have you ever tried cutting a piece of meat, sitting atop a mound of spaghetti, in a bowl? Not easy...I gave up on it out of frustration and brought it home where I could at least have it on a plate. I know, I should have complained and given them a chance to fix it but I was just so frustrated that I feared I might be rude, so did not. Wife ordered the fusilli ...it was as ordered but nothing special....service overall was slow....prices average as it cost me $55 for two of us. Would I return? No.Hi DavaxFirst of all i want to thank you for taking the time to write a review for us. Every review, positive or negative makes us stronger and we learn something new everyday from the reviews. im sorry if you didnt have a good experience, but for 35 years in the buisness, we always put the pasta in a bowl, with or without veal parmesean, because if you put the pasta on a plate, the pasta sauce will go all over the plate. this is the first time I had someone want their pasta on a plate, but as you mention, you should let your server know and she will take it back to the kitchen and put it on a plate for you. Overall, if you were happy with the quality, you can give us one more chance to come in and talk to me to serve you the way you like it and I will personally look after you. In the end I have to add, every customer has different ways to eat their food and they have different taste and expectation. So, we can not satisfy 100% of our guests especially if they dont tell us right away. Hope to see you soonCheersPapa Rez
9. Cocelli Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 53 reviews
Reviewed By Dan K
Located right next to our hotel made it very easy to take advantage of the walk in special. Crust is very important and on ours was very tasty. Somewhere between a Pizza Pizza and Pizza Hut crust but not as greasy. True test of course is the next day, it wasn't dried out and heated nicely.
8. Cicco's Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 89 reviews
Reviewed By CelesteG722
I made a reservation via the restaurantâs website. My husband and I wanted to enjoy a meal. I received a confirmation in my email when I made the reservation. Imagine my surprise when we arrived at Ciccoâs and they didnât have our reservation! The hostess acknowledged us, looked confused when we gave us her name, and then left us standing there to serve another table. We left because we were offended and unimpressed. Thanks for nothing! Celeste,I spoke with you personally and did admit we did not receive your reservation and offered an apology. However, we did say we would get you a table right away the night you arrived, even without the reservation handy and the waitress said sheâd be right back she needed to go make some moves to get that done. It would have hardly been a wait at all. You left as she was doing that for you then proceeded to call the restaurant and swore at her. I have also reached out to try to rectify this with you personally and you have declined. If you are not willing to let us make it right then please stop writing reviews all over the internet.
7. The Italian Bakery
Overall Ratings
4 based on 69 reviews
The Fuda Italian Bakery is a family owned business since 1957, that has grown and expanded in the last decade. We offer our community and visitors an Italian experience. We pride ourselves on offering you the best of Italy; fresh baked breads, sweet mouth
Reviewed By Joe W
This place opened up as a lunch spot, now it's like an Italian grocery store. The owners have never made me feel welcome there, they are always there but not a friendly couple. their food is okay if you like hot tables, lots of stuff sitting there for hours. For a place that looks okay, it is very average and overpriced in my opinion.
6. Paezano's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 34 reviews
Reviewed By Andy C
Second time to use this pizza place and frankly was not as impressed this second time. The pizza was average [had a medium Canadian - pepperoni; bacon and peppers] with 10 honey garlic wings combo with 4 drinks. Cost was $30.25 [I added two dipping sauces to bill]. Food was freshly prepared as I watched it get made since we were walk-in customers. Probably will go elsewhere the next time to find more taste. Just seemed kind of so-so and bland. Not enough other toppings.
5. Bacio Trattoria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 25 reviews
Reviewed By douglas p
Quant family run Italian Restaurant. Order from the menu or try the chef's sampler,which includes antipasto platter, pasta, fish, ribeye steak.. The sampler is brought out in courses and you definitely will be full. William the owner/chef is phenomenal and you are treated like family.. Only Italian restaurant I will eat at in Barrie.
Barrie Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Barrie
4. Casa Mia Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 187 reviews
Reviewed By sanjay42k
A quick stop during a drive, but thoroughly enjoyed feta bruschetta appy, daily dinner special pickerel, and wonderfully presented and very tasty seafood pasta main! Wonderful service and good Italian valpolicella!
3. 147 Italian Cuisine
Overall Ratings
4 based on 88 reviews
Reviewed By AlmostSeenItAll
We have eaten here many times ... it's pretty much Italian dishes, with several pasta offerings (gluten free is available). You can get a steak or fish if you are not craving mediterranean. The 147 starts you off with a tasty bread platter as you wait on your appetizer and main.The meatball starter (3 big ones) is popular.I had the gnocchi and my husband had the seafood linguine. Both quite nice and portions were good sized. Service was very good.
2. PIE Wood Fired Pizza Joint
Overall Ratings
4 based on 540 reviews
Reviewed By JimS48
Dropped in on a Friday around 4pm. We had missed lunch because of a flight so we were combining lunch and dinner. Staff were welcoming and looked after us promptly. Food arrived swiftly and was hot and delicious. We shared a pizza which was certainly enough for us. Wide ranger of condiments and peppers available to shake onto the pizza.
Ontario, Canada Food Guide: 10 American food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Barrie
1. Il Buco Ristorante
Overall Ratings
4 based on 699 reviews
Reviewed By wkie
This hidden gem in Barrie is amazing, wonderful service, attention to detail and food....oh and you can't forget the view .
Where to eat Canadian food in Barrie: The Best Restaurants and Bars
