Location: Smithtown
Top Restaurants in Smithtown
Top Things to do in Smithtown
Countries
Top 10 American food in Smithtown, New York, United States
Best American restaurants nearby. Discover the best American food in Smithtown. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for American restaurants near you.. Smithtown is a town in Suffolk County, New York, United States, on the North Shore of Long Island. The population was 117,801 at the 2010 Census.
Things to do in Smithtown
10. Mosaic
Overall Ratings
4 based on 74 reviews
Reviewed By dylanboyd2007
Chef Johnathan Contes delivered a sophisticated 9 course menu with help from our host who was extremely instrumental in not only hosting it but coordinating with the different wine flights, (16 bottles in total.)Dinner began with a dorado crudo with an avocado brulee, red onion ponzu finished with a peanut sesame sauce. From there we went to a very unusual escargot tempura with chanterelles, peaches, bed and yellow beets, summer truffles accompanied by a roast corn-pistachio pesto with watercress.Course # 3 was a tuna sashimi, with heirloom tomato gazpacho, hard boiled egg, watermelon, pine nut crumbs with a caponata vierge - My personal favorite of the night! Next up was a very unusual pastrami spiced sweetbread "Reuben," fresh pretzel, along with a rhubarb mustard and a strawberry horseradish.The sweetbread was followed by my 2nd favorite presentation which was a venison carpaccio along with pickled wagyu tongue, shaved foie gras, and a cherry fennel confit with capers. This dish was then followed by a lemon sorbet with chartreuse :-(Now we are getting to what was to be the star of the night a whole suckling roast pig with chilli relleno, zucchini, burnt almond along with a saffron marmalade and a sofrito hollandaise, an interesting dish to say the least.The last 2 courses were both of the desert genre; first was a ricotta banana tart with pistachio ice cream and marshmallow, This was followed by a ripened chevrot, with a fig and a smoked coffee foam topped with balsamic which was a nice conclusion to a very eclectic meal. Kudos to our host and to Chef Jonathan and staff.
9. Rockwell's Bar & Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By marc p
my wife and I go there once in awhile for a different venue the food has always been good portions are good and the prices are great for what you get
8. Faraday's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 62 reviews
Reviewed By Goatsgruff
Went here last Sunday after a show at the Performing Arts Center... it's a short walk away. Our party of 8 had a reservation for 2pm, though we really didn't need one. We had kids (7 and 10 y.o.) adults and grandparents in our group. They have a kids menu which includes all the usual stuff. Several people had burgers. A few had wraps (very hearty) and a few had salads. Everyone seemed to lie his/her meal. The service was very friendly and accommodating.The place is small, with maybe a dozen tables. There's a backroom that is glass enclosed.
7. Pace's Steakhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 210 reviews
Nothing arouses the appetite more than a sizzling, juicy, tender steakâ¦.hot, fresh from the broiler, resting on the plate before you, ready to be carved, ready to be eaten⦠a Pace's steak. Our meat is different, and you'll taste why. We pay a lot of atten
Reviewed By Elizabeth R
Never disappointed in this place. The food is awesome, the service is fantastic and the drinks are made well. My friend and I shared a Tuscan steak perfectly cooked to our liking a wedge salad and lobster tails and dessert. Everything was perfect, will definitely visit again.
6. Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi
Overall Ratings
4 based on 311 reviews
Insignia prime steak & sushi is much more than a steak house it offers something to everyon. The menu consists of prime dry aged steaks, the best sushi on available and the freshest seafood. Friendly, knowledgeable wait staff and the captivating ambiance.
Reviewed By FabulousFidel
Some really imaginative dishes and beautifully cooked steak. Australian tomahawk ribeye is particular good, as is the table flamed bacon entree. Decent wine list, although on the pricey side, but worth it. Would love to see chateau Musar on the list, as something different but very high quality. I have been too this restaurant several times and always received great service. I particularly like Rob who always remembers us and gives attentive and friendly service. The outside tables are particularly good and all in all, although its not cheap it does deliver. The good life app also works well and generates customer loyalty. Will be back!
5. The Garden Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 100 reviews
Reviewed By sheajanet996
Garden Grill is my favorite restaurant. I had a wonderful birthday celebration with my children and grandchildren. It was a Sun. afternoon, so it was quiet. The food and service was excellent. Everyone enjoyed their dinner. Portions are plentiful. Pretty restaurant. They have separate dining rooms. One with a fireplace. The holiday decorations are beautiful.
4. H2O Seafood & Sushi
Overall Ratings
4 based on 228 reviews
H2O Seafood & Sushi in Smithtown showcases seasonal seafood, served with passion, conceived with creativity. The sea dictates whatâs on the menu at H20, as, whenever possible, our Chef sources local fish and supports local farmers through creative takes i
Reviewed By Carol D
Having been here before, I was expecting an enjoyable experience when I was invited to join friends for a pre-Easter supper. From the warm welcome upon arriving and throughout the evening the attentive, professional wait staff was part of the pleasant nautical ambiance.The menu is broad in scope....From the delicious steak, scrumptious crab cakes, over the top popovers, warm goat cheese salad and tender asparagus everyone was totally satisfied with their choices. Weather appropriate, there is an outside area with several fire pits that would be perfect to add to the overall experience.Everything is al la carte.Another enjoyable evening at a relaxed pace.You'll be happy you came hungry.
3. Javier's Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 108 reviews
Reviewed By Travel50StatesUSA
Met a friend for lunch today at "Javier's Café". The food was fabulous!! I couldn't find anything on the menu I didn't like!! Finally decided on the "Ovengold Turkey Sandwich", with a side of French Fries. They offer both Breakfast and Lunch from 6am through 3pm, the hours they are open, so if you want French Toast, eggs, or pancakes for lunch, this is your place!! The service was friendly, and efficient. The restaurant is small in size, and was full at the time we were there, so it does have a tendency to be somewhat noisy. Parking is easy, as there is ample parking in the rear of the restaurant, and an entrance from the parking lot, as well. I will definitely be going back soon, and I recommend it highly to others!!
2. Chop Shop
Overall Ratings
4 based on 154 reviews
Reviewed By Elizabeth R
Nice place to meet some friends for a drink. There are small tables by the bar to enjoy a meal as well. We usually sit there and split a meal as it's more than enough for two. The drinks are tasty and the service is very good. Will definatly go back another day.
1. Maureen's Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4 based on 518 reviews
Reviewed By AllanNCynthia
What a find! only open for breakfast and lunch, this "cow themed" local favorite is incredible. Family managed, outstanding quality and service, large portions, and gourmet touches throughout the menu, presents the best of the old diner days and today's high quality standards. Whatever can be homemade is and the efficiency is really something to observe. You need some time to enjoy this busy spot and there's enough interesting things to notice while you wait. Even a motorcycle decorated in cow patterns. Couldn't believe our first visit, had to buy a couple of Maureen's cow coffee mugs, and then brought some grandkids a few days later. Come hungry and better bring cash - no credit cards here.
