Location: Sheffield
Top Restaurants in Sheffield
Countries
Top 10 American food in Sheffield, Massachusetts, United States
Find out what American restaurants to try in Sheffield. Sheffield is a town in Berkshire County, Massachusetts, United States. It is part of the Pittsfield, Massachusetts Metropolitan Statistical Area. The population was 3,257 at the 2010 census. Sheffield is home to Berkshire School, a private preparatory school. The former resort town includes the village of Ashley Falls, and is bordered by various other towns and villages, such as Egremont and Great Barrington.
Things to do in Sheffield
10. Roma Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 52 reviews
For over a decade, Roma Pizzeria has been Canaan's destination for good food and great memories! Relax with friends or family in our comfortable atmosphere while you grab a bite to eat, or call in for a delivery. Our menu features a variety of items from
Reviewed By jktmrose
We stopped at Roma after a nice hike at Bear Mountain. The restaurant is on Rte 44 in Canaan and you cannot miss it! Our meatball pizza and grilled chicken salad were very good and there was enough to bring home for leftovers. Our server, Stephanie, was very nice and she was handling the whole restaurant by herself. Roma was a good place for lunch and worth a stop even if you are just passing through town.
9. Prairie Whale
Overall Ratings
4 based on 254 reviews
CLOSED Jan 1st, 10 days in April, July 4th, Labor Day, Thanksgiving Day, Christmas Eve & Christmas Day. Brooklyn food pioneer Mark Firth has brought to the Berkshires the same rustic and delicious food he served at his previous restaurants, Marlow & Sons
Reviewed By susansM3116HS
We spend time in the Berkshires every summer and are always a bit disappointed in the quality of restaurants there. What a find this was. They were cooking over an oak fire behind the place when we parked and we met and talked with the chef. The very best entre' was the lamb kabob cooked over the fire; super tender with great spicing. The house made sausage was also delicious!
8. The Well
Overall Ratings
4 based on 115 reviews
Reviewed By ART9099
Great location right on Main Street but it is very difficult to find parking on the weekend. Otherwise, we really enjoyed this place. We just had drinks and appetizers but their nachos are fully loaded and delicious. It's a small, cozy place but we love the vibe and decor.
7. Cafe Adam Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 298 reviews
A chef owned destination restaurant featuring local ingredient driven cuisine. Award winning wine list, full bar, outdoor seating, special events, and large parties can be accommodated. Menu features homemade pasta, raw oysters, extensive native wild fish
Reviewed By maven75
I had been told how great this place was. It was a letdown. Service good. Back room quiet. Prices high but no tablecloths. Limited menu. I had the meatballs which were like rocks. Greek salad looked great. Ribs very good. Noisy when full. Maybe I should give it another try since consensus is that itâs very good.
6. 20 Railroad Public House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 271 reviews
Seasonally inspired pub fare and traditional Neapolitan Pizza. Using Local, Regional, responsible and Sustainable products. Craft Beers and Cocktails.
Reviewed By Richard R
My wife and I had dinner here on a Tuesday night in mid-April 2019. We are senior citizens and tourists,visiting Great Barrington for the first time. The dinner was excellent and we are so glad we chose the Public House. The mussels are outstanding and are served with a thicker-than average sauce with coconut flavoring. My wife's trout dinner was superb. The fish had crispy skin and it came with risotto and brussel sprouts (very tasty). For dessert the brownie a la mode was perfect. Good service. The place is popular and it got crowded as the evening went on. The room is lovely and historically renovated, and the exterior storefront is very attractive, as well. The restaurant is on the liveliest block in town - Railroad St. We highly recommend this eatery.
5. Old Inn On The Green
Overall Ratings
4 based on 238 reviews
Reviewed By JackieDz
The quality of the food, the service and the wine list all exceeded our expectations. We enjoyed the many course tasting menu with wine pairings. The quality of the food and all over ambiance is unique (the room is entirely lit by candlelight, hardening back to the days that this was a stagecoach Inn). Highly recommend and look forward to returning!
4. Great Barrington Bagel
Overall Ratings
4 based on 119 reviews
Reviewed By Jayablake
I love coming here. The food is great. I would recommend the dr mark on of my favorite foods of all time. I go too the bagel shop a lot, almost every week. If you are visiting Great Barrington I would recommend coming here to have lunch solo or with friends. Itâs a great place too get bagels and I would say one of the greatest restaurants in Great Barrington.
3. Old Mill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 199 reviews
Reviewed By TravelJ
We sat in the back room - in the trees. It is so beautiful and even though it wasn't in the main room, we absolutely loved it. The food was absolutely incredible. We loved the crusty bread and the spread it came with was delicious. The muscles were so yummy and our waitress gave us extra bread! We both ate the cod because it sounded so good. Usually we like to try two things but our waitress told us it was so yummy just to get it! We are so glad we listened. I couldn't finish so my husband said no way am I leaving that! Thank you old mill!!!!
2. The Stagecoach Tavern
Overall Ratings
4 based on 78 reviews
Reviewed By wamrazing
Friends invited me to join them for dinner here recently and I had driven by the Stagecoach a number of times but never went in until now. I'm sorry I waited so long.The setting is small and intimate, lots of wood...old building...low ceilings..a romantic location for that quiet dinner with someone special. The wait staff was young but attentive and very helpful when it came to choosing our dishes.We shared a number of appetizers and all were terrific...then the main courses. The waitress recommended the pork chop to me...so I went for it and thanked her later for the tip...it was succulent, tasty and easily the best pork chop I've ever had. I was amazed at how good everything was and also that in a small and busy restaurant it was also easy to have a conversation at a normal voice level.Pricing is a bit higher than some places locally but the food and service are worth it. I can't wait to go back again.
1. The Bridge Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 64 reviews
Reviewed By Elsa_O
We've loved stopping in at The Bridge in the past, but we don't get to the Berkshires very often, and regret that they are no longer open during the lunch hour. Their tostada is really special, something I look forward to ordering.In past years they were closed for 4th of July, so this year I called ahead and was told they would be open on Tuesday, July 3. Unfortunately when we got there they had a big sign announcing that they were closed on July 3 and July 4. I wish their staff would provide accurate information.Hi Elsa,This is Michael Dutton, owner of the Bridge. I apologize for your experience July 3rd. Our air conditioning wasn't able to keep up with the heat and so we reluctantly decided to close. There was a note in the front door and an explanation on our Facebook page. There wasn't enough room on our front sign to explain the problem.I also just want to mention that we have never been open for lunch in the 11 plus years we've been here. The previous restaurant Limey's did serve lunch for awhile.I'm so glad that you like our place and look forward to seeing you again.Yours,Michael
