Location: Reynoldsburg
Top Restaurants in Reynoldsburg
Countries
Top 10 American food in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, United States
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, United States. Reynoldsburg is a city in Fairfield, Franklin, and Licking counties in the U.S. state of Ohio. It is a suburban community in the Columbus, Ohio metropolitan area. The population was 35,893 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Reynoldsburg
10. LongHorn Steakhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 75 reviews
Reviewed By gilthorp
Had a gift card and used for a nice dinner. Joined their e-club and had a very nice $12 appetizer of shrimp. Meer was pricey for a local IPA at $7. Ordered 6 oz filet medium rare and was tasty and done right. Certainly recommended for families and moderate steak dinners.
9. O'Charley's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 75 reviews
Our menu is filled with classic American dishes like steak, salmon, burgers, sandwiches and salads, as well as other traditional favorites like slow-roasted prime rib and our famous chicken tenders, all at a great value.
Reviewed By rblackburn85
We go here about once a week, mostly for an evening meal.The service is always good and the food never disappoints.Although the lot looks full, the inside is never overcrowded.We seem to be seated within 5-10 minutes on weekend evenings.The last two visits-we have had Taylor as a waitress -we love her.Very attentive and cheerful.This restaurant addresses gluten issues and has a variety to satisfy all.
8. TGI Fridays
Overall Ratings
4 based on 49 reviews
In Manhattan in 1965, there was no place where people could go out to meet friends and make new ones in an environment that was at once both relaxed and yet exciting. Then, Alan Stillman opened Fridays as a way, he said, "to meet Pan Am stewardesses." Sud
Reviewed By WhyMee2
It was my twin girls "12th" birthday and they wanted to visit TGIF. Twins enjoyed the food they were more excited about the dessert called a "Cup of dirt." it had chocolate pudding with worms, Oreo's and a chocolate bar. Huge portion for kids. Waitress was good, food good, price good. My only dislike was when we arrived the male host took us to the back of the restaurant for a booth. I asked him could we sit at any of the booths that we had passed, he claimed there were no waitress available for those booths. I watched other customers come in and he seated them at the booths we passed. I want this male host to know that you sit customers where they want and get a server to serve them. This is 2018, not the 1940's I choose NOT to sit in the back of anywhere and definitely not the back of the restaurant. I can sit upfront with all the other customers who you seated in those booths. I noticed that the ladies that were in the back where we were seated were extremely loud talkers, even my "12 year old birthday twins" said why he sit us back here with these loud women, we can't hear each other over them. STOP THE SEGREGATED SEATING
7. Cracker Barrel
Overall Ratings
4 based on 132 reviews
Reviewed By HENRY T
Our group's travels have taken us to several fascinating venues throughout the eastern part of our great country, and there has always been a need to get our batteries charged up for the day's activities at a great breakfast spot; and that means a Cracker Barrel is in order! For our foray to visit the Ark Encounter and Creation Museum, the CB in Pickerington, Ohio was our selection. Manager Dan is perfect for his job, and he was able to get our mass of stomach- grumbling patrons quickly seated and able to bury our noses into their expansive menu . EVERYONE, yup, EVERYONE was bragging later that they had made the best choice from the interesting options. Indeed, it is impossible to make a wrong selection at a Cracker Barrel! What really impressed me about this particular CB ; besides Dan the man, and the oh-so-delicious breakfast, was their famous gift shop attachment to the restaurant. Pickerington's shop seemed to be larger than other CB shops, with a lot more selections of their totally unique clothing gifts, unusual and hard to find games, and those nostalgic candies! Those candies! I simply HAD to buy a few tons of them because I just knew that my uncle or cousin or neighbor would be so pleased if I bought them a candy that they had remembered from their childhood.( Yeah, right! They were all for ME! Ha Ha Ha) Anyway, hats off , or belt loosened in honor of this great version of Cracker Barrel in Pickerington, Ohio. You folks are doing a really great job there. Keep up the good work, Manager Dan and crew!
6. First Watch
Overall Ratings
4 based on 28 reviews
First Watch specializes in delicious creations freshly-prepared to order. Their fresh, award-winning Breakfast, Brunch and Lunch dishes are made using only the best ingredients without the use of heat lamps or deep fryers. The best part is their creative
Reviewed By Swimmer626
We had a small business brunch here yesterday. One of us was a vegetarian. There were lots of healthy and not so healthy choices. They were introducing some new options that looked wonderful! We had the Market Hash, the Eggs Benedict, and the crepes, which are no longer on the menu but they were happy to make them for her anyway. All of us were happy with our choices. Our waiter kept our coffee hot and checked on us regularly. Because it was a meeting we kept the table for nearly two hours. Our waiter never stopped paying attention to us, and we tipped him extra, but he never could have known that. We will absolutely return!Thanks for the awesome review! We're happy to hear that you enjoyed the variety our menu has to offer and that you experienced wonderful service during your visit as well. We can't wait to see you again soon!
5. Loving Hut
Overall Ratings
5 based on 30 reviews
Reviewed By JoyBulldog
I came here due to the great reviews. The service was fast and friendly. The waiter helped me select my food according to what I told her I liked--healthy, nothing fried. I ordered the quinoa salad and royal Pho (after the waiter told me I could order it without broccoli). It was all seasoned perfectly. I'm stuffed!!
4. Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 125 reviews
Reviewed By Tony H
Stopped in here the other evening for supper-our first time being here. Kind of a big and roomy place. Unique décor. Food was ok-but a little high priced. Drinks were definitely high priced. No happy either that I noticed. Service was decent. Lady was kind of friendly (waitress). For the amount of money we dropped we weren't overly impressed.
3. City Barbeque
Overall Ratings
4 based on 103 reviews
Fast-casual barbeque restaurant serving authentic comfort food. Serves award-winning BBQ, huge sandwiches, homemade sides, fresh salads, and incredible desserts. All meatsâbeef brisket, pulled pork, St. Louisâcut ribs, Amish chickens, turkey breast, and s
Reviewed By Kadabi
City BBQ is one of my favorite places to eat BBQ - Rib Bone Tuesdayâs are hard to beat! This particular location always has super friendly staff, and the owner is very friendly. A plus for me is they are dog friendly if you are stopping by to eat on their patio. From their ribs, to their banana pudding to the deep fried pickles everything Iâve had here so far is awesome! The atmosphere and delicious food make this a stop for us more than a few times a month.
2. Prost
Overall Ratings
4 based on 99 reviews
Reviewed By 454christinac
I have to say, the food was absolutely delicious. Fresh ingredients. Tasty combinations. The bruschetta flight was delicious - every single bruschetta we had was divine. The goat cheese and pepper - a favorite. The pepper jam and Gouda - absolutely fabulous. My panini of prosciutto and fig jam was out of this world. Service however was very slow. Not unfriendly or not seeming wanting to be helpful - but incredibly slow for it not seeming that busy. It did seem there were few servers but it was also disorganized where people coming behind us got offered drinks before us and had food come out before ours. The food thought would make us come back despite the experience.
What to do and see in Reynoldsburg, United States: The Best Places and Tips
1. Hickory House Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 200 reviews
Reviewed By LonestarBux
The restaurant has a small town feel to it but the food delivered big time taste. We had a short wait at the bar before our table was ready and several of the bar patrons were regulars...quite friendly, engaging and complimentary of the restaurant. Our party had the ribs and the porterhouse steak and both were flavorful and tender. It was our first visit and hopefully wonât be our last.
Reynoldsburg Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Reynoldsburg
