Top Restaurants in Simpson Bay
Top Things to do in Simpson Bay
Countries
Sint Maarten, Caribbean Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Simpson Bay
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Simpson Bay, Sint Maarten, Caribbean including IZI Ristorante Italiano, Isola Italian Restaurant and Brick Oven Pizzeria, Mama, Sale e Pepe, Mezza Luna, Pizza Italy, Tortuga Maho, Pizza&Co SXM, La Rosa Restaurant, Moomba
Things to do in Simpson Bay
10. Moomba
Overall Ratings
4 based on 162 reviews
A match made in heaven, the friendly island and a concept whose entire being is based upon having fun...fresh seafood equal to none, the most creative tapas in all of the Caribbean, all accompanied by libations and wines of the world, in a uniquely St. Ma
Reviewed By Lawrence R
Best stop I had in Sint Maarten. FANTASTIC food. My wife and I had french onion soup, Fried calamari, the sopranos pizza. Pizza stood out from any others. My wife loved the calamari, I loved the soup.Hi Lawrence,Thank you for visiting us at Moomba.I'm glad to read you enjoyed every single dish you ordered.The calamari are indeed an all time favourite!Hope to see you again in the near future.Thanks for your great review.Kind regards,Marnix
9. La Rosa Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 242 reviews
Nestled in the far corner of maho resort complex, la rosa restaurant is familiar haunt for local and visitors-in the -know. Consistent top-quality italian food with caribbean flair,served by a prompt friendly staff in an attractive atmosphere has kept the
Reviewed By roro3300eh
Pretty restaurant but disappointing food Bruschetta came out and was great. We thought we were in for a treat. We ordered eggplant parm, fusilli pescatore and lasagna. Sauce was bitter, and other dishes were flat. Salad had so much dressing, we couldn't eat it. Go next door to nona rosa, you'll love it.
8. Pizza&Co SXM
Overall Ratings
4 based on 86 reviews
Reviewed By lauramR2681YT
Pizza & Co is the most AMAZING pizza in all of St. Maarten..You donât need to go to Italy for the best pizza..We had the pizza with half bacon and half hot/spicy sausage..cheesy and crispy crust with so much flavor..
7. Tortuga Maho
Overall Ratings
4 based on 63 reviews
Reviewed By ajwitthoeft
Great atmosphere! Right on Maho Bay! The waves, sunsets, the novelty of watching the planes flying over the beach and all the tourists covered in oil! Forget all that....... what really makes Tortuga special are the people! From the Kitchen staff firing out dishes left and right to a waitstaff of servers and Bartenders that will extinguish any thirsts you may have acquired throughout your day. Come in and say Hi to Tom and Mery. 2 of a kind you will never forget!
6. Pizza Italy
Overall Ratings
4 based on 173 reviews
In Our Restaurant You Can Find The Original Pizza, Napoli Style, Named After The City Responsible For Its Creation. We Adhere To, As Close As Possible, The Rules Proposed By "original Neapolitan Pizza Association". Therefore Our Dough Is Prepared 48 Hours
Reviewed By Butterfly_n1
We ate here on two separate nights and both experiences the food was fantastic. Reasonable priced, too. We enjoyed the open-air seating, and the servers were friendly. It was a great option as a family, with good prices and large portions.
Where to eat French food in Simpson Bay: The Best Restaurants and Bars
5. Mezza Luna
Overall Ratings
4 based on 223 reviews
Reviewed By johnlQ571ZJ
Ness continues to do a wonderful job with the place...best pizza on the Island in my opinion and his full service dinner menu with daily specials is and has been just superb. Each dish is prepared when ordered...all with fresh homemade pasta...a better meal is hard to find.
Where to eat Pub food in Simpson Bay: The Best Restaurants and Bars
4. Sale e Pepe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 345 reviews
Reviewed By Kim W
Sale e Pepes came highly recommended and didn't disappoint. We were seated overlooking the water and the breeze coming thru the patio area was quite nice. The decor is very classy (for St. Maarten) yet comfortable. The menu is quite extensive, having something for everyone, tho' slightly on the pricey side. However, the portions are more than adequate. And, they have a large number of specials in addition to the menu. It seemed to take awhile to get our meals but that gave us time to savor the great bread and very flavorful olive oil. Our server was very friendly and good with the kids. Several staff came by to make sure everything was to our liking, including the chef. The food was good - probably the best meal we've had on the island. I'm adding Sale e Pepes to my list of "go to"s for a return trip to St. Maarten.
Top 10 Caribbean food in Simpson Bay, Sint Maarten, Caribbean
3. Mama
Overall Ratings
5 based on 34 reviews
Reviewed By waicool
We arrived late from our flight so we wanted something simple and easy. We were delighted at how good the pizza was!! The dough was tasty and crisp. Their pizza options had a nice variety too. Also, their daily specials and pasta dishes looked good. The bar has some good drinks and you can enjoy the view of the water!
2. Isola Italian Restaurant and Brick Oven Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 540 reviews
Isola is an authentic Italian restaurant with the purpose of delivering the best food and service to its guests. Prime materials straight off Italy, the manager from Milan, the chef from Rome and the pizza man from Naples are the perfect ingredients for a
Reviewed By 621nancyp
Location was super convenient so we tried it with a relatively large group. Food was good, some dishes better than others. The lasagna was just OK, but others raved about the veal meatballs, salmon, half moon ravioli and lobster risotto. Ceases salad OK. Also had the scallop appetizer with puffed pastry that was amazing. It was nice that we could split the salad and appetizer and the salad was huge. Service was OK, got slower as the night progressed...took a long time to get deserts and then the check and also the left over to go items. Not sure I would go again as there are some other amazing Italian restaurants in the area if you have a car or taking taxis.
1. IZI Ristorante Italiano
Overall Ratings
4 based on 1541 reviews
Reviewed By Destination255141
Great experience. Wonderful dinner. Excellent service. Canât beat the price. We love the atmosphere. Nathaniel was so kind to photograph us for our anniversary. This was our third time to celebrate our anniversary at Izy. It is our favorite dining experience on the island. We really enjoyed the surprise with our dessert.
Most Popular International food in Simpson Bay, Sint Maarten, Caribbean
