Location: Shrewsbury
Top Restaurants in Shrewsbury
Countries
Pennsylvania, United States Food Guide: 9 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Shrewsbury
Best Italian restaurants nearby. Discover the best Italian food in Shrewsbury. View Menus, Photos and Reviews for Italian restaurants near you.. Shrewsbury is a borough in York County, Pennsylvania, United States. The population was 3,823 at the 2010 census.
Things to do in Shrewsbury
9. Mamma's Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 25 reviews
Reviewed By Mike B
Good pizza, NY style crust, with a decent amount of ingredients. We had a pepperoni, and a veggie deluxe. The pepperoni was a little better, Also ordered something they call chicken sliders, which were like giant Totino's pizza rolls, and they're pretty good.
8. Messina Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 13 reviews
At Messina's, we take our mission to provide you with quality, fresh and flavorful food very seriously.
Reviewed By travelinmama1731
We thought we would try this place again. At one point they offered specials and not your typical "Italian" pasta done 100 different ways. Now, it seems as though they mostly offer subs, pizza. Which is fine.. and that is not why I gave it a one star.We arrived and were greeted immediately and had drinks brought over immediately. We placed our order and that is where the good service ended. The waitress, who was very friendly and nice, took our order (spaghetti and meatballs and a sub) and 40 minutes later we were served. Mind you there were 2 other couples in the restaurant. She was very busy talking with another couple and totally ignored us and the other couple for almost 30 minutes. We couldn't even get her attention as she literally pulled up a chair and sat with this other couple.. very very unprofessional. At one point a guy walked in the door and went in the back (I'm not sure if he was the delivery person or not) but honestly my car mechanic was cleaner looking than he was. The food was ok, nothing special. And one of the many "kids" at the front counter who was fixing pizzas and working the register was standing there at the counter applying makeup or doing something to her eyebrows.. ugh.. no more.
7. Original Italian Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 23 reviews
Reviewed By AllisonJessicaRabbit
They have a football theme atmosphere. STEELERS city up there!We always make a pit stop before we had to Maize Quest that is just right up the road. The pizza is very good. They do a thin crust. Worth a stop if you want a nice slice of pizza!
6. Original Italian Pizza
Reviewed By vintage993
When my guest stay at American Vintage I send them here to eat the Best Pizza in town. I also recommend their Philly Cheese Steak Hoagies, once you eat them you will not go else where. I take my family there for lunch often, use their delivery service often. got to try them and thank me later.
5. Glen Rock Pizzeria
Reviewed By Pamela R
This is my favorite pizza shop. They have really good hot and colkd subs and sanadwiches too. The lunch special is hard to beat. The service is fast and friendly.
4. Paesanos Pizza Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 49 reviews
Reviewed By gmcmlc
Great pizza and great subs. Pasta choices from spaghetti and meatballs and veal specials. We had 3 generations and everyone was happy and full. BYOB. Reasonable prices and great service by Stevie.
3. Rita's Italian Ice
Reviewed By Richard S
Have been going there since it opened. Everyone likes a Rita's and now we have one. My wife sends me there several times during the summer to get us a treat. I always enjoy going there and getting the custard ice. Good place to go and pickup a treat, no seating so you will have to eat it standing up or eat in your car. Always fun.
2. Sons of Sicily Pizzeria & Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 71 reviews
Welcome to Sons of Sicily At Sons of Sicily we take pride in ensuring you have the best food and best service we can offer. Our restaurant is more than just a business to us. Itâs a family way, itâs tradition and itâs a matter of pride. Whether you come a
Reviewed By Richard S
1st time at Son's of Sicily. Very friendly and efficient staff. Short wait time to order and have food served. We ordered baked Ziti, cheese steak sub and fries. All food was just average, nothing special. The pizza did look good and I will try it on my next visit.
What to do and see in Shrewsbury, United States: The Best Places and Tips
1. Nikolas' Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 71 reviews
Reviewed By Linda62410
Ordered eggplant roll up , very nicely done marinara sauce home cooked it came with a salad that looked fresh. Excellent service that took great care of my table and everyone else around then gave me directions to an Amish market nearby
Shrewsbury Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Shrewsbury
