Location: Sharon
Top Restaurants in Sharon
Countries
Pennsylvania, United States Food Guide: 8 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Sharon
Discover Restaurants offering the best Italian food in Sharon, Pennsylvania, United States. Sharon is a city in Mercer County, Pennsylvania, in the United States, 75 miles (121 km) northwest of Pittsburgh. It is part of the Youngstown-Warren-Boardman, OH-PA Metropolitan Statistical Area.
Things to do in Sharon
8. Pizzas By Marchelloni
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
We make all of our dough fresh daily, and use only the freshest ingredients for a taste you'll love. Your satisfaction is guaranteed! Available in our original Chicago pan style or authentic thin crust. Fresh dough made daily. Toppings: Pepperoni, mushroo
Reviewed By rduinc
We were spending the night in the nearby Travel Lodge and this place was recommended by the front desk staff. We ordered a roasted garlic pizza with chicken and it was excellent. The medium size was just the right size for two people. Pizza was delivered to the door of our hotel, another added bonus!
7. PaPa Louie's Italian Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4 based on 8 reviews
Reviewed By JnL2004
For a place with a Italian name they sure can do sauce. It taste, looks, & ever smells like its mixed 1c sauce and 3c water. The tomato smell is very faint as well as the taste. The chicken parm was just as bad. Chicken was over cooked and the pasta was super over cooked. Their is no texture to it at all which is a complete shame. When something was said to the staff she got rude. I can say having a bar also is extremely great idea. People can be drunk before they see their so called food.
6. Toss'd Salad & Pizza Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By Otter421
Tried the new Toss'd location. Disappointing to say the least. It was a bit crowded because its new location but our service was atrocious wait a long time for our drinks to arrive, one was wrong...never did get a refill. The food was average at best. We ordered 2 to go salads ...no dressing in them...tried to find someone to remedy...but was not easy. Really liked the sub shop...picked up orders often there. The new place just not working...i will go back in a couple of months to see if its just growing pains.
What to do and see in Sharon, United States: The Best Places and Tips
5. Hometown Pizza
Reviewed By Theorchidmoon
Delicious pizza close to home! They are always friendly and nice to talk too! Pizza is so good ! My favorite is white or chicken bacon ranch!! Always hot and tons of meat ! Love the crust too! Good prices and great service and delicious pizza. What more could you want!!
Sharon Food Guide: 10 Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Sharon
4. White Rose
Overall Ratings
4 based on 16 reviews
Reviewed By pdq724
You cant be in a hurry if you come here but the spaghetti is worth the wait. Don't judge a book by its cover. If you're in the area you wont be disappointed.
Most Popular Pub food in Sharon, Pennsylvania, United States
3. Scotto's Famous Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 36 reviews
Reviewed By Tom S
My wife and I were visiting in Hermitage and felt like having something Italian for supper. I saw the high ratings for Scotto's on Trip Adviser and so we went there.I ordered the lasagna and my wife ordered ravioli. There are only about 4 or 5 booths in the place and from my seat I could see the cook (a short Japanese guy!) in the kitchen working on our meals. I was astonished to see him put our meals in a microwave oven! Were our meals frozen?I ate most of my lasagna except for the noodles; there were only a few of them and they were black on the bottom side. My wife only ate half of her ravioli. We wished that we had not eaten at Scotto's.There were quite a few people stopping to pick up pizza that they had ordered and the pizza did look good so maybe that is why they get good ratings.My wife and I will never visit Scotto's again.
Where to eat Diner food in Sharon: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Combine Brothers Bar & Grille
Overall Ratings
4 based on 149 reviews
Reviewed By Doug K
A hug serving does no equate to fine cuisine in my book and I left unimpressed by this restaurant. It is loud, crowded and does not serve any meals for older seniors. The entrees were overpriced and the paper laid out as a "table cloth" was not the only rip off in the place.
1. Muscarella's Cafe Italia
Overall Ratings
4 based on 118 reviews
Small family-owned Italian Restaurant in Sharpsville, PA. Food is excellent and comparable to any Italian Enoteca in Italy
Reviewed By chimayred
Less than a half an hour ago I finished eating dinner at Muscarellaâs. Iâm up here on business and although the people are very nice in general, no one would confuse Sharon and Sharpsville with Beverly Hills. So when a local recommended Muscarellaâs I remembered it from TripAdvisor. Driving up there was a little dicey, itâs just a depressed area. The street that itâs on has a couple of warehouses and dilapidated buildings, donât let that put you off. Iâve seen worse and Iâve eaten at worse. This place is worth the drive. Let me repeat that. Itâs worth the drive. I gre up in New Jersey and I know good Italian food. This is up there. I had stuffed Hungarian peppers and the sauce alone wouldâve been worth the price. The bread was perfect, just basic white Italian bread with whipped butter. Skip the butter, and use it to mop up the red sauce. I had a very functional Caesar salad, the lettuce was fresh, it was nothing outstanding but it was a side and it served itâs purpose, a little roughage to chase everything else. For dinner I had a baked tortellini and chicken dish and while it didnât look like an enormous portion it was, and it was fresh and absolutely delicious. Two local craft beers that were outstanding a $36 bill and I gotta tell ya Iâm gonna come back the next time Iâm in the area
