Location: New Holland
Top Restaurants in New Holland
Countries
Pennsylvania, United States Food Guide: 8 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in New Holland
Reviews on Italian food in New Holland, Pennsylvania, United States. New Holland (Pennsylvania Dutch: Seischwamm) is a borough in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, USA. As of the 2010 United States Census, the population was 5,378, up from 5,092 in the 2000 United States Census.
Things to do in New Holland
8. Rosario's Pronto Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 56 reviews
Reviewed By travelkitty50
We stopped in for lunch before a show at American Music Theatre last Saturday. Hubby said that he'd been past it many times and wanted to see it. We found our own seats and quickly ordered our standby Italian dishes, he, spaghetti with meat sauce, me, lasagna. There was an offer for two glasses of either wine or beer with two dinner purchases, so I wanted wine with mine. The server brought me a Lambrusco which was perfect with me heavy dish. Hubby got his Yuengling draft which I would normally enjoy too, but this day wanted something different. The salads were pretty basic, the meal came with warm buttered garlic bread, and there was plenty to eat, so it was a good visit.
7. Osteria Avanti
Overall Ratings
4 based on 146 reviews
Reviewed By janie51
The best thing about Osteria is that it is on property. The restaurant is very small. Breakfast was fair. Their chicken salad sandwich for lunch is fantastic. Their dinner menu is limited and the food was average and portions were on the small side. Service is average. The best part of Osteria is Mike. He does everything---bartender, server, host, etc. Mike is the nicest individual, and he makes Osteria. We loved the property but were disappointed in the restaurants and how small Osteria is. Bring back Maggio's and keep Mike. The property is excellent and the staff wonderful, but the restaurants need improvements.
6. DiMaria's Pizza & Italian Kitchen
Overall Ratings
4 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By Ava L
Happy we searched out to find the Original restaurant, We had enjoyed this restaurant's fare when in Mount Joy until it was sold. Staff still as friendly and food is delicious.
5. Slice of Italy Pizzeria
Overall Ratings
4 based on 22 reviews
Reviewed By Bluebirdsinging
Had their take-out ham sub for lunch. Meat and vegetables were fresh and sub was very good. Full of locals.
4. A Slice of Brooklyn - New Holland
Overall Ratings
2 based on 20 reviews
Reviewed By 1983pam
Just dropped in for the first time tonight. Food was ok, but nothing that would prompt us to return. Service was pretty much non-existent. Once our waitress too our order and brought back the dinner, she never returned to the table. Dirty dishes were not removed and no check in on how the food turned out. What was particularly interesting was that we were only 1 of two couples in the restaurant. Counting guys making pizza and waitresses there were seven staff members...waitresses talked amongst themselves and when we finally realized no one was coming back to our table we went to the register and asked for our bill. They hadn't totaled it but did so while we waited.We won't be back.
3. Carini's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 43 reviews
Reviewed By Steven L
The location of this restaurant is ideal. There food is pretty good and prices are very reasonable. The atmosphere is very nice and is a great place to sit down for a bite to eat. The staff is very friendly and you feel like part of their family. If you are local, you can of course call in and place an order.
2. Sal's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 35 reviews
Reviewed By Robert C
Pizza parlors come and go. Let's just hope Sal's is here to stay. The family run restaurant, with its friendly atmosphere, is frequented by regular customers. They keep coming back, which is a sign of a good establishment. Either takeout or eat-in, the pizza is varied and always good. No burnt crust, and the portions are huge. The service is excellent, unhurried yet efficient. It's a relaxing place to go to eat.
Where to eat Dutch food in New Holland: The Best Restaurants and Bars
1. Palermo Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 111 reviews
Reviewed By heatherj941
My mom and I went with my 4 year old daughter and food was great, I had lasagne, mom had spaghetti, and my daughter had pepperoni pizza slice. Everyone was happy and service was excellent.
Most Popular American food in New Holland, Pennsylvania, United States
