Location: York
Top Restaurants in York
Top Things to do in York
Countries
Pennsylvania, United States Food Guide: 10 Italian food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in York
Find out what Italian restaurants to try in York. Billing itself as "The Factory Tour Capital of the World," York, Pennsylvania, is the home of thirteen different factories open to the general public. Find out how everything from potato chips to motorcycles are made! The free Harley-Davidson Motor Company Tour takes visitors into the plant to watch an assembly line churn out hogs. The York Barbell Factory includes the USA Weightlifting Hall of Fame, where visitors can see such sights as a license plate torn in half using only bare hands.
Things to do in York
10. Infinito's Buffet
Overall Ratings
4 based on 37 reviews
Reviewed By Sharky442
This is the very first time I visited Infinito's and LET ME TELL YOU, This Pizza Buffet is AWESOME. This restaurant puts CiCi's pizza TO SHAME, The variety of pizzas, The salad bar and Bread-Sticks all for just 9 bucks with the drink, I'll definitely come again.
9. Nino's New York Style Pizza
Overall Ratings
4 based on 13 reviews
Reviewed By Linda T
Want a great pizza at a reasonable price? Look no further! Nino's is one of those places that is alsways great whether ordering in or out. Nothing fancy here. Just really good pizza. I know they have other things on the menu but when I walk in and smell the pizza, I just have to have it!
8. Pizza al Bacio
Overall Ratings
4 based on 33 reviews
Reviewed By Becky E
This was the first time visiting this place. It is near my house, so I thought I would try it after just having an ordeal with another pizza place.We ordered a large pepperoni/green pepper pizza. Everyone enjoyed it. The pizza had just the right balance of sauce and cheese. The crust was thin (I prefer this!), but not crispy. The sauce had good flavor too. All around a good pie.My only suggestion would be to have an extra large pizza. I thought the large was a bit small (16"). Maybe go to an 18" for the XL pizza. I'll admit it, I just wanted more pizza to eat!
7. Wood Fire Italian Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 27 reviews
Reviewed By Mobile809236
Tried the pizza for lunch - found it bland, overloaded with mozzarella, and despite wood-fired oven, uninteresting crust. Iced tea was from a mix - not good. Bathrooms had only a small amount of toilet paper. Four adults on staff, but waitress seemed to be the only one connecting with guests. Receipt is so confusing (deductions for toppings I didn't have, but weren't part of my ordered pizza either!). I will not return.
6. Deli of Italy
Overall Ratings
4 based on 32 reviews
Reviewed By gailm161
What a fabulous find in York county. They're menu has some unique and authentic Italian flavors. Out favorite is the sandwich called A little slice of Heaven. Everything is fresh and delicious.
Where to eat American food in York: The Best Restaurants and Bars
5. DiCarlo's Pizza - York
Overall Ratings
4 based on 46 reviews
Reviewed By 552lianab
We ordered a heart shaped pizza and salad for Valentine's Day! That crispy crust with the flavorful sauce and fresh cheese is just over the top! The salad is always fresh with some welcome additions - olives and sweet peppers!We stopped here a week later with friends for a late night treat after some bar hopping... we ordered a 6 cut for 6 of us and it was the perfect way to end the evening!
4. Marino's Pizza & Pasta House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 91 reviews
Reviewed By skink
We went to Marino's in February so my wife could carbo-load before her half marathon the next morning. She had the spaghetti carbonara and I had the chicken parmigiana. The portions were large and the food very tasty. We saw pizzas coming out of the kitchen and they looked great aw well. Too bad we didn't have room to share one of these. The service was very prompt and attentive and the restaurant has a friendly, family feel. We were very satisfied with our choice of Marino's Pizza and Pasta House.
Where to eat Diner food in York: The Best Restaurants and Bars
3. Tutoni's
Overall Ratings
4 based on 131 reviews
Tutoni's menu of creative dishes and new spins on traditional Italian standards - rooted in the region's abundant agricultural scene - offer customers a dining experience they can't find anywhere else. Tutoni's strives to pair top-notch service in a sophi
Reviewed By Patty6316
Well I loved the atmosphere. Not crazy about the Tapas Bar. There was NO service at the tables - at least we did not get any. Had to wait on ourselves by going to the bar for everything we needed and they were not the friendliest people either. Don't get the fried oysters - $8.00 for 2 small oysters smothered in some white sauce. The Mushroom Bruschetta was delicious. Total menu is very limited. All wine is measured prior to pouring into glass and they use the same measuring cup for white or red. Don't like that. We did not stay long and don't plan to return there anytime soom.We are so sorry to hear that you had less than a great experience at our restaurant. We take pride in giving our guests a top notch experience and feel terrible that this wasn't the case for you. Our bar area has recently been recently revamped/restructured to make sure every guest that sits at a table is able to receive service without needing to go to the bar. Our tapas menu is small but rotates through items, so the oysters will not always be there. In addition to the tapas menu, guests that sit at the bar are also able to order from our regular dinner menu. We also offer self-serving wine pour stations, so that is always a back up option if you don't like the way our bartenders are pouring.Thank you for your feedback, we will make sure we pay attention to the aspects you touched on to ensure improvement in our bar service. The next time you choose to come in, please send us an email ([email protected]) or send a Facebook message to Tutoni's and we will be sure to take care of you.
2. Mexitaly Brick Oven Brewhouse
Overall Ratings
4 based on 250 reviews
Mexitaly Is A Scratch Kitchen And Brewery. We Pride Ourselves In Providing Good Quality And Quantity At Fair Prices. Stop In For A Pint!
Reviewed By Lyoder11
My husband and I visited this restaurant on a Saturday night. There were plenty of tables but we chose to sit at the bar. My husband enjoys the craft beer (loves Pilner's or lagers the best). I ordered a "poco" big burrito and the size was perfect and it was delicious. My husband ordered the Pizza Fresca and enjoyed it very much. The crust comes out a bit burnt since they are oven fired and we like them that way. Just know that ahead of time in case you don't like yours burnt - they will accommodate you and not make it that blackened. The service was very good and we had a good conversation with the young man that was the bartender that night. We will definitely go back again and would recommend this restaurant for those Mexican and Italian food lovers.
Most Popular Steakhouse food in York, Pennsylvania, United States
1. Victor's Italian Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 206 reviews
A neighborhood staple since 1984, Victorâs has evolved into the perfect reflection of an Italian Trattoria. Though the quality of the food, thoughtfulness of the service, and the caliber of wines, beers, and cocktails offered may hint at a more upscale Ri
Reviewed By Tomkypa
We don't go here very often and when we do it's a treat. The restaurant is in an old church in a residential part of York. It seems to be always busy when we are there so you need reservations. They have a varied menu. All good, good wine selection and full bar. Parking can be tight on north side of church. There is a bustle about the place but not obtrusive. This is not in cheap eats category.
