Location: Etters
Countries
Pennsylvania, United States Food Guide: 10 American food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Etters
Discover Restaurants offering the best American food in Etters, Pennsylvania, United States. Goldsboro is a borough in York County, Pennsylvania, United States. The population was 952 at the 2010 census.
10. John's Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 375 reviews
Reviewed By 658joanw
We came to the area to compete in local dog agility trials, so we returned to our hotel late each night. We tried Johns Diner the first evening of our stay because it was conveniently near to our hotel. We liked our food so much that we came back for the next two evenings. We liked the cleanliness, the fast, friendly service and the comfort food. Everything we had was tasty and plentiful. Recommend the stuffed shells, the bleu bacon burger, the shishkebab and the tuna salad melt. Guarantee you won't leave hungry! They also bake their own desserts, which looked fabulous. We were too full with dinner to try them, but other customers said that their desserts were generous and delicious. We would definately go back to Johns Diner if we make another trip to the area.
9. Brownstone Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 316 reviews
Reviewed By Mcdonald1881
I have heard great reviews from many friends over the years and I finally had the pleasure of going recently. These friends were absolutely correct in their description of this restaurant. The food is fabulous and plentiful. The staff is so very friendly, fun and helpful!! They really make you feel at home. Great atmosphere! The coolest reuse of an old bank!! I will definitely go back!!
8. Francesco's Pizza
Reviewed By Terry D
Overpriced, over baked pizza slices. Small wraps for the price. If you want to eat cheap overpriced food this place is for you; a lot better pizza places in the area than this place.
7. Culhane's Steak House
Overall Ratings
4 based on 118 reviews
Reviewed By Kim S
This place has excellent seafood and steaks. Good sized portion at reasonable prices. Full bar and cozy atmosphere, with good service. Also nice because it is easy to get into on a Friday or Saturday evening without a reservation . Has several large rooms.
6. Crostwater Distilled Spirits & American Heritage Kitchen
A distillery & tasting room in Lewisberry PA featuring true Farm to Table Spirits and Modern Southern Cuisine. We place an importance on local, sustainable products from Pennsylvania and mid-Atlantic farmers, fishermen, and artisans. Open Wed-Sat 12pm-10p
Reviewed By Shokora1
We made our first visit tonight and it was really nice. Food and drinks are all farm to table concept. They have their own distillery, service was so friendly. Met the owners and they seem like great people and want their establishment to be the best for their customers. There is a large room in the back where you can play corn hole, music with local musicians, art room with local artist who sells her art. Just awesome! We are definently going back. Price is in the middle but itâs totally worth it,
5. Hogan's Bar & Grill
Overall Ratings
4 based on 17 reviews
Reviewed By SamanthaJ343
I ate here on Friday night and was disappointed with my meal. I ordered the stir fry with chicken, which was very soggy (to me - everything was overcooked and overfilled with "dressing"). The kicker was that it was also very, very sweet, which I was not use to in a stir fry. I could not eat it, which is rare for me...I hate sending food back. It makes me uncomfortable, and I typically blame myself for not innately knowing that the food was meant to be cooked this way. Our waitress was awesome! I wish I remembered her name (she was tall, brown hair, thinner, smile affixed to her face and worked outside). She came over and was so nice and sweet, she actually made me comfortable admitting to her that I could not eat it (only picked at the chicken). I wound up ordering the perogies which were very good! To me, a person that eats out more than they like to admit, it inspired me to write a review, as the waitress was so good. I will return just because of her.
4. Summit Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 37 reviews
Reviewed By WadeandLori
Friendly people. It's a diner with simple fare at cheap prices. It's not quite a four rating but it's better than average and our waitress was very pleasant. Breakfast was good.
3. Hillside Cafe
Overall Ratings
3 based on 142 reviews
Reviewed By HiHo143
Since rebuilt establishment after , I have made several visits back to eat. Wait staff was slow in attentiveness. Steaks average $18+ and tasty. Order of mushrooms @ $1.75 upcharge were âcannedâ. Blue cheese dressing $1.00 upcharge. Wine @ $6 for half-glass of house brand. Average bill $30-35/personEasy access from I-83, but may keep driving...
2. USA & I Pizza Subs & Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 36 reviews
Reviewed By NO2HUNGER
Of all the restaurants I review, pizzerias are the most difficult. Each area of the country has distinct preferences. Chicago likes deep dish. USA&I lists itâs style as âNew York Style Crustâ Even in New York each ship is unique. That said, pizzas here are not so big as many big-city shops, and the ingredients are not piled high. All in all the price - around $17 for a large - is perhaps a bit high for what you get. Service is good, fast & friendly. The restaurant itself is adequate, but not fancy. The pizza is a bit better than average. If you stop, I hope you love it. Iâll be watching for your evaluations of mine!
Most Popular Italian food in Etters, Pennsylvania, United States
1. The Soda Jerk Diner & Dairy Bar
Overall Ratings
4 based on 616 reviews
Reviewed By Debra W
6 in our party. Nice variety on the menu. Able to get breakfast at 11:30am. Two of us had omelets, others had not roast beef sandwiches, Turkey dinner. We were very pleased with the great service and fast arrival of ourfood. Will definitely go there again!
Where to eat Greek food in Etters: The Best Restaurants and Bars
