Location: Shelby
Top Restaurants in Shelby
Countries
Ohio, United States Food Guide: 3 American food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Shelby
Find out what American restaurants to try in Shelby. Shelby is a city in Richland County in the U.S. state of Ohio, northwest of the city of Mansfield. It is part of the Mansfield, Ohio Metropolitan Statistical Area. The population was 9,317 as of the 2010 census.
1. The Vault
Overall Ratings
4 based on 40 reviews
Reviewed By melissap2015
My sister and I decided to bring our parents here for their first time. My mom and I got the pizza buffet which consisted of four different kinds of not even lukewarm pizza. They each had a tiny candle under them for heat but they definitely didn't help. They never refilled the plates our entire meal so everyone who got the "buffet" used their same dirty plate over and over. Maybe they could add salad or breadsticks............something else other than four pizza's! Our server acted super super busy even though there weren't many tables in the restaurant and not many outside. There were two servers. We asked for a few things (like salt and pepper) and it took 10-15 minutes to get each item. My sister got salmon which came with broccoli and coleslaw. She said the salmon was OK but the broccoli wasn't even warm, didn't have any butter, sauce, salt or pepper on it. We got a couple of appetizers, stuffed dates and olives which everyone liked. The most interesting thing was a lady came out several times from a room in the front of the restaurant and never helped the servers with anything and they clearly needed it. She didn't take one look at the "buffet" either. I think the door said manager on it. We were excited for this place to open, there aren't many neat places like this in the entire area but after eating here twice I am not impressed and won't be back. The owners have (had) a good thing going for them. I hope they don't ruin it.
2. Ted and Ali's Corner Cafe
Overall Ratings
4 based on 25 reviews
Reviewed By leed809
Itâs a small town family restaurant itâs has its character and charm everyone knows each other which is always a great indicator that food is good if the local community go. Staff and guests interacting with another was a really interesting place to go to, lots of parking friendly staff polite itâs more like a diner they have there booths and tables. Breakfast was good sausages eggs and potatoes with onions coffee as much as you wanted smelt and tasted great prices also very reasonable.
3. Legends Sports Grill and Pub
Overall Ratings
3 based on 14 reviews
Reviewed By 300hollyh
We went here after attending a festival in Tiro , OH. My chicken sandwich was very moist and I enjoyed it. The best part of my meal was the homemade sweet potato chips that came with the sandwich. They also served a side of cinnamon butter with it. My husband enjoyed his hamburger and his fries were homemade as well. I do like the idea that it is not a chain restaurant.
