Location: Penfield
Top Restaurants in Penfield
Countries
New York, United States Food Guide: 7 Diner food Must-Eat Restaurants & Street Food Stalls in Penfield
Discover Restaurants offering the best Diner food in Penfield, New York, United States. Tony LaFountain (R; 2010-present)
Things to do in Penfield
7. Broken Yolk
Overall Ratings
4 based on 5 reviews
Reviewed By btobey
This diner recently changed hands/names for the THIRD time in only a few years. We were originally dismayed to see this, as we liked the two prior incarnations. However, our opinion quickly turned around when we finally visited the Broken Yolk, which opened in May 2019 - this just may be the best diner in the Rochester area!We love this diner so much that my spouse and I have been three times in just over three weeks. We are huge breakfast fans, so we've ordered mostly breakfasts, with one lunch in there. Here are some highlights:*The omelets are tremendous, with everything tasting incredibly fresh. There is a choice of side potato (home fries, shredded hash browns, hash brown patty), and these have been cooked to perfection.*The French toast (both regular and cinnamon raisin) has just the right taste and texture.*The pancakes are delish! And when we ordered a short stack to share between us, our server kindly brought us two plates and allowed us to do one with blueberries (yum!) and one without.*I had maybe the BEST oatmeal I have EVER had!!! I'm not even sure why it was so good, especially since it was unsweetened--but came with a side of banana, brown sugar, and milk. Seriously, I could order just oatmeal every day here!*The chicken salad sandwich was also excellent.Please patronize this place; we hope they will never close! We will definitely be back soon.
6. George's Restaurant
Overall Ratings
3 based on 31 reviews
Reviewed By Deb M
I gave this restaurant a great review a few years ago, but it just wasn't up to that standard this visit. My eggs Benedict and my husband's crab omelet were good, but the accompanying potatoes were not. My husband's hash browns were mushy and they and my country fries had an odd charred taste. Breakfast for 2 with coffee was around $20.
Where to eat Asian food in Penfield: The Best Restaurants and Bars
5. T's Family Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 169 reviews
Serves breakfast and lunch only.
Reviewed By Denise L
My husband ordered a western omelette that came with home fries. It was quite large and filling! The home fries were very good as well. I ordered the 1/2 sandwich and soup combo. Chose the onion soup but was disappointed. Not enough beef flavor, bread and a slice of provolone, found it lacking. The turkey sandwich had lots of meat, a bit of mayo on white bread. Only ok. Saw a great looking reuben go by to another table that looked great. Also, most breakfast items looked very well done and appetizing. Probably will stop again but make other food choices. Waitress took a while to get to us for the check.
4. Landmark Family Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 60 reviews
Reviewed By MatthewJPeacock
Good food. Great service. Very busy today. 45 minute wait. French onion soup was bland. Please give this review and photos a helpful vote.
3. Durf's Family Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 56 reviews
Reviewed By Smaske1
Lots of breakfasts in the US are either over-priced or chain restaurants without sincerity or character and breakfast here felt like a down to earth family diner with reasonable prices and good quality food and service. Always a good sign that it is busy and full of locals. Happy to recommend this.
Where to eat American food in Penfield: The Best Restaurants and Bars
2. Riki's Family Restaurant
Overall Ratings
4 based on 158 reviews
Reviewed By JoeKupe
We were a large work group for breakfast before heading out for a day of community service. Portions were large, service was prompt and we were fueled for the day, but the meal did not stand out. We ordered all the standards: pancakes, eggs, coffee, home fries and more - it filled us up but as a local diner with a large following we were expecting a bit more. If you are in Fairport and need a quick meal it will do the trick and the price is right, plus it is a local business which is great to support. Would I go back for a group breakfast, sure, but would also want to try some of the townâs other breakfast spots that have a large following too.
1. Original Steve's Diner
Overall Ratings
4 based on 133 reviews
Reviewed By MaineGuy777
This is a crowded diner, known for its gigantic pancakes (which most people don't finish, but take home to reheat later)!We waited about 20 minutes at lunchtime to get a table. Service was ultra-friendly and efficient. The food was pretty good, with mainly reasonable prices. We had challah French toast ($6.95), which was very good, but the real maple syrup cost an additional $3.50 (which we thought was excessive). The home fries ($2.95) were only fair. A broccoli and cheese omelet was good ($8.75). A side of coleslaw ($3.50) was very good. Coffee ($2.10) was decent.
Most Popular Italian food in Penfield, New York, United States
